Gordon's defeated me. 26mpg - enough is enough!
Gordon's defeated me. 26mpg - enough is enough!
Author
Discussion

matt21

Original Poster:

4,404 posts

235 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
After spending 80 quid for 390 miles, and petrol only going one way, enough is enough.

I love my 530iA, but just gots too much for my 20k pa.

I have a fun car for weekends, but want something still quick(ish), German and half decent for regular long motorway trips. Just like my BMW infact but economical!

I'm loathed to get a 530d to save 10mpg tops.

Budget is not a consideration but I need to factor depreciation into the mix so if its expensive, economical, and holds its value I'm interested!

I have seen a 57plate 520d SE with 15k for 16 grand. Thats on the list. Passat is a possibility too.

LPG makes sense but at 160k on the BMW concerned it is more trouble than it is worth.....and would I really save that much on fuel (considering its starts on petrol and does less MPG).

Discuss! smile

Matt UK

18,084 posts

231 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
I'm in the same boat..

Factor in depreciation per mile/month of the new car and double-check the 530i is not the cheaper option.

Athlon

5,957 posts

237 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
And me! fuel seems to be going up 1p per day around here, time for an eco cruiser for day to driving, in fact a cheapie £2-3K estate seems to fit the bill, any ideas?

RB26DETT

2,519 posts

206 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
Mercedes S320CDI ? Will go over 40MPG and has 224BHP.

Sam_68

9,939 posts

276 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
Matt UK said:
Factor in depreciation per mile/month of the new car...
Not forgetting the cost of interest on any loan you need for the purchase (or loss of interest if you have the cash in a building society or invested).

26mpg isn't bad for a 3 litre automatic, though - you must have a light foot. I don't get that out of my 2 litre turbo manual and the last 3 litre I had (a Carlton GSi 24V manual) was lucky to break 20mpg...

Silver940

3,967 posts

258 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
Been there, looked at the options and LPG converted my 1.8T Golf. Converted at 120k and now done 178k without too much trouble. You save loads, car does about 27mpg where it did 32 on petrol, ( Petrol currently 116.9 LPG 59.9) it runs on petrol for 5mins max in cold weather, less in the summer.

Now if I was buying another car because I wanted one I would now probably buy a diseasal as I do 500 miles a week, but buying a diseasal to save money when I had a perfectly good car and resuffer a load of depreciation - makes less sense.

If you are prepared to keep the car for at least another coupld of years then the 2k to convert start to make sense, it does tie you to the car.

And any scare stories abour LPG will probably come from people that have no first hand experience of modern conversions!

Down side, you sometimes have to queue at the station as there is generally only one pump usually badly situated and you have to fill up twice as often as you would with a diseasel.

Also if you do decide to change I was looking at options around your budget recently and the Volvo V70 topped the BM and Audi in value for money and how nice they are inside! Chipped D5 ( ok so it's no mapped 335d wink ) would make a pretty quick stealthy motor

Fittster

20,120 posts

244 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
matt21 said:
I have a fun car for weekends, but want something still quick(ish), German and half decent for regular long motorway trips. Just like my BMW infact but economical!
No Jags allowed?

Jaguar XJ 2.7 TDVI

Shaw Tarse

31,904 posts

234 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
Fittster said:
matt21 said:
I have a fun car for weekends, but want something still quick(ish), German and half decent for regular long motorway trips. Just like my BMW infact but economical!
No Jags allowed?

Jaguar XJ 2.7 TDVI
Upto 61 mpg on a motorway.
OP, I'll donate a litre of petrol.


If you wish to pour it over Winky & Slugbrow.

matt21

Original Poster:

4,404 posts

235 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
Jag's allowed but at 20,000 miles a year that XJ would depreciate fast I would imagine.

I just don't want someone to suggest Vectra/Mondeo etc... Good cars, but not for me!

deaglecat

162 posts

264 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
matt21 said:
I love my 530iA, but just gots too much for my 20k pa.
If you are only making £20k then I would get something small and economical... maybe a secondhand fiesta diesel ?

matt21

Original Poster:

4,404 posts

235 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
deaglecat said:
matt21 said:
I love my 530iA, but just gots too much for my 20k pa.
If you are only making £20k then I would get something small and economical... maybe a secondhand fiesta diesel ?
I meant 20,000 miles. I wouldn't divugle my earnings on here!

Bugeyeandy

12,719 posts

228 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
I read that more like he does 20k per year mileage?

deaglecat

162 posts

264 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
matt21 said:
deaglecat said:
matt21 said:
I love my 530iA, but just gots too much for my 20k pa.
If you are only making £20k then I would get something small and economical... maybe a secondhand fiesta diesel ?
I meant 20,000 miles. I wouldn't divugle my earnings on here!
I know... only joking mate. LoL what kind of fool would buy a car like yours if they were on only £20k... they would be so poor that they need to be eating mud.

Urban Sports

11,321 posts

234 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
deaglecat said:
matt21 said:
deaglecat said:
matt21 said:
I love my 530iA, but just gots too much for my 20k pa.
If you are only making £20k then I would get something small and economical... maybe a secondhand fiesta diesel ?
I meant 20,000 miles. I wouldn't divugle my earnings on here!
I know... only joking mate. LoL what kind of fool would buy a car like yours if they were on only £20k... they would be so poor that they need to be eating mud.
Good grief

matt21

Original Poster:

4,404 posts

235 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
I drive a 2000 X 530iA with 160k on the clock. Worth around £3k I would say.

If I kept it say 2 years I reckon it will lose a further 1500 quid and burn around £8000 of fuel - so £8k before I have started.

If I can get something that will half the fuel bills (say £4,000 for 40,000 miles) that gives around 4 grand more that can go towards depreciation and a newer, potentially more reliable car.

So what can I get that does 50mpg, German, reliable, quick, fun, well specced, and would lose less than £5,500 in two years based on covering 40,000 miles?

If that car does not exist I will have to re-evaulate my criteria smile

BlueMR2

9,476 posts

233 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
Why not £2-4k on a very nice LS400 or early LS430 then lpg it, 30mpg should be possible so depending on lpg cost could be 60+mpg equivalent.

You can only lose what you spend on it so no more than £2-4k and thats if you give it away at the end.

essexplumber

7,756 posts

204 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
You see the lefties are winning. Pretty soon there will only be 1ltr matiz's on the road. I hate this world sometimes.

Shaw Tarse

31,904 posts

234 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
essexplumber said:
You see the lefties are winning. Pretty soon there will only be 1ltr matiz's on the road. I hate this world sometimes.
Them ^^^ & busses frown
Maggie would not have approved

dcb

6,070 posts

296 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
matt21 said:
So what can I get that does 50mpg, German, reliable, quick, fun, well specced, and would lose less than £5,500 in two years based on covering 40,000 miles?
You appear to concentrate too much on fuel bills, when it seems
to me the depreciation is the more expensive item.

Suggest new shape BMW 325D. The new shape 3 series is only
marginally smaller than the old shape 5 series, a 2.5 litre
is a bit cheaper to run than the 3 liter, one less insurance group,
bit cheaper to maintain and it's diesel brother a bit cheaper still.

Ok you lose 5-10 mph top end which won't affect any English
driving you do and you lose maybe half a second 0-60mph, but that
won't affect you much either because you are in a medium
sized family saloon not some chav rocket.

s3fella

10,524 posts

218 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
matt21 said:
anonymous said:
[redacted]
I drive a 2000 X 530iA with 160k on the clock. Worth around £3k I would say.

If I kept it say 2 years I reckon it will lose a further 1500 quid and burn around £8000 of fuel - so £8k before I have started.

If I can get something that will half the fuel bills (say £4,000 for 40,000 miles) that gives around 4 grand more that can go towards depreciation and a newer, potentially more reliable car.

So what can I get that does 50mpg, German, reliable, quick, fun, well specced, and would lose less than £5,500 in two years based on covering 40,000 miles?

If that car does not exist I will have to re-evaulate my criteria smile
I dont think the sums add up to make your choices viable. Realistically, your Beemer is worth £2k, so depreciation on it is negligible over the next two years. Bills for things breaking wont be, but who knows what will break.
If you spend a net £13k on a new car, in the two years you mention, your spending a fair wedge on finance, even if you have the cash to buy outright, there is a cost of capital of not having it in savings or off the mortgage etc. If you need to borrow, you will be lucky to get it for much less than 10% APR just now. So you could be talking £2.5k in finance.
So this means you need to maybe find a car that will depreciate less than say 3k in 40k miles....it will be tough!
Alternatively, why not just buy a cheapo reliable and frugal commuter car and keep you beemer for an interesting comfy barge for weekend and special trip use? You could pick up a low miles 03 plate 1.2litre VW Polo for flip all, it will not suprise you with any bills, will get 50mpg all the time and you wont lose much cash on it. This way, you will be better off guaranteed, and you will preserve the beemer longer (particularly if garaged) and keep the miles off it to maintian what little value it has? As for running costs like insurance, well the polo will be a cheap 2nd car, but if you CAN garage the beemer safe, consider a policy like Direct Line that will let you insure the polo full time, and add the beemer for 7 occasions per year. I run my Porsche like this, just add it for a month or so in the summer, then a few odd weekends throughout the year too. It was less than £6 for a weekend fully comp last year! Your other full time car remains insured all the time.
Tax on a 1200 polo should be cheap too.

its the only way I can see you being better off, plus a second car gives you an option if you have an unexpected bill with one or other.