Golf GT TDI
Author
Discussion

mikef1

Original Poster:

126 posts

250 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
Hi Guys

Looking for a new car for the other half, she has just recently passed her test and we have a new baby so safety is my primary concern. Main criteria is 10-12k nothing older than 3 years old she wont be doing a huge mileage up to 7k per year. I'll will occasionally drive the car but she will be the main driver which I keep having to remind myself!

Although she is not a brand snob we would prefer to stick to the german marques I'm thinking along the lines of a 5 dr golf gt tdi 140 though am open to suggestions

I'v also considered the 1 series deal @ £249 a month for 3 years but would rather have something to show for 3 years of payments.

Thanks in advance

Somnophore

1,364 posts

207 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
Why a diesel if milage is 7k a year? Get a newer/better spec petrol for that cash, or same age/spec petrol but cheaper.

Somnophore

1,364 posts

207 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
Haha beat me to it

Baffled Spoon

5,260 posts

225 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
Given the low mileage a petrol would probably be better for you. The DPF doesn't like lots of short jorneys usually and the economy gains won't offset the other costs usually at that mileage. A Ford Focus would be a good bet and you could also consider a Seat Octavia alongside the Golf.

Somnophore

1,364 posts

207 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
Seat octavia?

Baffled Spoon

5,260 posts

225 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
Erm yeah, a Seat Octavia. What will those crazy Germans think of next? heh biggrin

I was probably wanting to type leon/ octavia...

sleep envy

62,260 posts

280 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
was a DPF fitted to the 140 engines?

in any case with such low miles don't restrict yourself to just looking at diesel

mikef1

Original Poster:

126 posts

250 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
was thinking the gttdi purely because I have driven one and found it to be a very easy car to to drive and has some pace if needed, haven't driven a mkv gti but would certainly consider one if it isnt going to be "too much car" this car will be taken to the supermarket, coffee shop, me from the pub...

I couldn't bring myself to buy the focus no matter how good it is spent far to many miles looking at my ford steering wheel a few years ago and unless is has a cosworth badge on its arse im not interested.


whats the dpf/dmf chat

cheers

sleep envy

62,260 posts

280 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
diesel particulate filter on diesel cars mounted in the exhaust

gets blocked up if you do loads of town driving, needs to be cleared out every few weeks

10 mins hard drive up the M1 sorts it out

mikef1

Original Poster:

126 posts

250 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
cheers
[/quote]my wife drives a GTI - to her it just means it's almost unstallable and when you put your foot down, you aren't going to be caught in the wrong gear..... because it pulls. it's not too much car - I suppose the test is where you live - we pay £250 a year insurance on it - it's group 17..... so if you have problems that way, it's out.....

DPF - is diesel particulate filter - nonsense they put to reduce diesel emissions - which actually means you increase emissions when the engine burns the contents of the filter out...

DMF - dual mass flywheel - an expensive unreliable addition to recent diesels to try to make them smoother.... - crap reliability on almost all of them (from VW, to BMW, to GM, Ford et al)
[/quote]

Thanks good info there, insurance isn't an issue as we have a company policy, what year is yours and have you had any major issues apart form the usual?

cheers

sleep envy

62,260 posts

280 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
I'd go with cloth, VAG leather is harder than that on the soles of my site boots

mikef1

Original Poster:

126 posts

250 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Will def be buying one with fsh and will double check re the brake fluid and as for the the wheels im already resigned to the fact they will look like a dogs dinner after a few weeks anyway!

Whats the taxation class on these ? iv had the 3.2 engine in a tt before but these are upto £400 a year now? now were starting to think more about a car for me argh!! we've gone from a 2.0 diesel to a 3.2 petrol its her first car!!! good times!

Edited by mikef1 on Wednesday 17th March 21:58

mikef1

Original Poster:

126 posts

250 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
could not agree more was driving my dads (07) tt today and was appalled at the state of the leather like its been made from a leather jacket bought on holiday and left to dry in the sun

baz1985

3,685 posts

276 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
8P 3.2, but I am biased. The leather is better than the ste in the G8yman

swamp

1,014 posts

220 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
What tonker said.

I've got a 3 door GTI in cloth trim, which currently ferries round Mrs swamp and baby swamp. Great car and does everything. Would like 5 doors and leather, and a few more toys inside, but I'm not going to bother changing it.

Get the 17" wheels unless you live in a field. Get auto folding wing mirrors: mine just got whacked frown

If you have £12K then a GTI will *save* you money over a diesel rot box... Honest wink

Edited by swamp on Wednesday 17th March 22:39

mikef1

Original Poster:

126 posts

250 months

Wednesday 17th March 2010
quotequote all
swamp said:
anonymous said:
[redacted]
What tonker said.

I've got a 3 door GTI in cloth trim, which currently ferries round Mrs swamp and baby swamp. Great car and does everything. Would like 5 doors and leather, and a few more toys inside, but I'm not going to bother changing it.

Get the 17" wheels unless you live in a field. Get auto folding wing mirrors: mine just got whacked frown

If you have £12K then a GTI will *save* you money over a diesel rot box... Honest wink

Edited by swamp on Wednesday 17th March 22:39
ok pretty much decided to move away from the gttdi and into the gti but whats your thoughts on this

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2010...

as I said I wont be driving it Im just looking for the freshest safest car for her

Citman

305 posts

215 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
If it's only going to be used for basic pottering to shops and the like, then I wonder if the petrol GTi is maybe as over-specced as a GT TDi? Wouldn't something like a 1.6 FSI or one of the smaller TSI engines suffice, saving even more money?

mikef1

Original Poster:

126 posts

250 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
Citman said:
If it's only going to be used for basic pottering to shops and the like, then I wonder if the petrol GTi is maybe as over-specced as a GT TDi? Wouldn't something like a 1.6 FSI or one of the smaller TSI engines suffice, saving even more money?
Obviously saving money would be nice but im just looking for something that will give me no hassle hence the smaller engine newer car, I can see it being upgraded to softroader/x5y thing within 18 months once she is comfortable with the golf and had some on road experience.

Too many decisions and its too late to be thinking about this tonight thanks for you feedback on the different models I think i need to put my sensible hat on and remember this is not a car for me!

I'll sleep on it and update you asap i want to get something sorted by the weekend but welcome any info in the mean time

cheers

the-photographer

5,211 posts

207 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
As a compromise, you could consider the Mark 5 GT/GT Sport models with either 140/170PS engines, for example

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/1461772.htm

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/1558505.htm



They use both a SC and TC, make sure you get a test drive, as some people find the engine a bit 'marmite'.

The 140 is smoother and more linear, compared with the somewhat on/off nature of the 170. An easy 40mpg
on a run and slightly cheaper insurance/running costs to a GTI (you also get a newer car for the same money).

Edited by the-photographer on Thursday 18th March 07:58

mikef1

Original Poster:

126 posts

250 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Cheers, as long as its rill got the balance of the manufacturers warranty I don't really care unless he tires and clutch are cooked