Very simple What Car?
Discussion
After 15 months of running on one car between me and SWMBO we are finally getting a second car. The second car will be for me and the budget is around £1-1.2k. For various reasons I need to car fairly quickly and so plan to go look at a couple on Saturday with a view to buying one of them (provided they are both not complete sheds).
I have spent most of the weekworking looking for suitable canditates and through a very bizarre process of elimination/not really knowing what I want I have narrowed it down to two cars to view:
Fiat Seicento Sporting.
A few examples near to me can be had in budget with 50k or so miles. Look great IMO and I understand they are fun little cars, although only ever had experience of larger Fiats. Good mix of fun and economy.
Peugeot 306 DTurbo
Again, a few about. One in particular I like the look of in 3dr guise, later grille etc. Much bigger than the seicento but more comfy/refined with it. Similar levels of frugality expected.
In short, I can argue myself into either of them and was hoping for some useful input as to why one (or both) should be avoided and/or targetted over the other?
Over to you, and thanks in advance.
James
I have spent most of the week
Fiat Seicento Sporting.
A few examples near to me can be had in budget with 50k or so miles. Look great IMO and I understand they are fun little cars, although only ever had experience of larger Fiats. Good mix of fun and economy.
Peugeot 306 DTurbo
Again, a few about. One in particular I like the look of in 3dr guise, later grille etc. Much bigger than the seicento but more comfy/refined with it. Similar levels of frugality expected.
In short, I can argue myself into either of them and was hoping for some useful input as to why one (or both) should be avoided and/or targetted over the other?
Over to you, and thanks in advance.
James
MrLou said:
What are your criteria?
You have two fairly different cars on your shortlist.
Now that is the question.You have two fairly different cars on your shortlist.
Should be:
- cheap to buy and maintain and insure
- economical
But I also want something a bit fun, which is where the Seicento came in, but a bit comfy, where the 306 came in. And so I hit my problem, do I want a comfyish car or a fun one? I know would be happy with either of them, but I also know that on some days I would want the fun of the Fiat and on others the (relative) comfort and easy to drive dieselyness of the 306.
I don't know. I was hoping some comments against one of the contenders in my OP would sway me one way or the other.
Thanks for the Puma suggestion, but I have spent so long narrowing it down to these two I don't really want more options to think about

ETA At the moment I am leaning towards the 306, if only because I would guess that of all my driving I only really want to enjoy myself 10% of the time, the rest I would prefer to just get there easily and without any hassle.
Edited by cv01jw on Thursday 18th March 15:36
I only offered the Puma because I thought it was a 'what car' thread but actually you are asking us to help you choose 'which car'.
Puma would be out of the loop due to insurance as its grp12 and not really cheap.
How are you using it,mostly motorway etc ?

Puma would be out of the loop due to insurance as its grp12 and not really cheap.
How are you using it,mostly motorway etc ?
Edited by macp on Thursday 18th March 15:54
macp said:
I only offered the Puma because I thought it was a 'what car' thread but actually you are asking us to help you choose 'which car'.
Puma would be out of the loop due to insurance as its grp12 and not really cheap.
How are you using it,mostly motorway etc ?
Sorry, didn't mean the comment to sound as blunt as it did. Which car would have been better 
Puma would be out of the loop due to insurance as its grp12 and not really cheap.
How are you using it,mostly motorway etc ?
Edited by macp on Thursday 18th March 15:54

The car will be used for the daily commute mainly, which is a 35 mile round trip on Dorset A and B roads.
We have no motorways in Dorset; we have to travel all the way to Hampshire to see one of them.
Open your mind and options a bit more.
If you are buying in a bit of a rush you'll need to, otherwise you run the risk of ending up with a lemon because you rushed into a particular car by picking the best of a bad bunch.
Scour the freeads/local echo/AT/ebay for all cars within say 10 miles. Finding a decent car is far more important.
If you are buying in a bit of a rush you'll need to, otherwise you run the risk of ending up with a lemon because you rushed into a particular car by picking the best of a bad bunch.
Scour the freeads/local echo/AT/ebay for all cars within say 10 miles. Finding a decent car is far more important.
patmahe said:
It really does depend on what you will be using it for, is it a runaround or will is be doing 25000 miles a year. Will you need to carry passengers or is it just for you, is reliablility a big factor etc...
It is just for me to get to work and back in, so no real practicality is needed. BUT I have tried the 'oh well I can get little two seater then' and that one was a no goer with SWMBO 
Reliability is a factor as I will need the car for work.
bazking69 said:
Open your mind and options a bit more.
If you are buying in a bit of a rush you'll need to, otherwise you run the risk of ending up with a lemon because you rushed into a particular car by picking the best of a bad bunch.
Scour the freeads/local echo/AT/ebay for all cars within say 10 miles. Finding a decent car is far more important.
Good advice, thanks. I can travel a reasonable distance to look for cars this weekend, but will think about other makes/models based on this.If you are buying in a bit of a rush you'll need to, otherwise you run the risk of ending up with a lemon because you rushed into a particular car by picking the best of a bad bunch.
Scour the freeads/local echo/AT/ebay for all cars within say 10 miles. Finding a decent car is far more important.
From what you say the 306 seems to fit the bill well. They're fun to drive (HDI is a much better lump than the TD if you can find one) and comfortable. Best of both world's in my opinion. Would imagine you'd have to buy carefully though as there seems to be a big variety in quality/reliability levels. Find a good one though, and they seem to go on forever.
cv01jw said:
It is just for me to get to work and back in, so no real practicality is needed. BUT I have tried the 'oh well I can get little two seater then' and that one was a no goer with SWMBO 
Reliability is a factor as I will need the car for work.
I said something similar and was told by the PH massive to grow some 
Reliability is a factor as I will need the car for work.

They were correct of course.
I think if were talking reliability then maybe Toyota Yaris or Nissan Micra or how about a Fiesta 1.25.
Edited by macp on Thursday 18th March 16:08
macp said:
I think if were talking reliability then maybe Toyota Yaris or Nissan Micra or how about a Fiesta 1.25.
I think this is what you need to be looking at, within your budget and with your requirements and for utter reliability I'd choose the micra, for these reasons,- Loads in budget - so easier to find a good one
- Comfy for a car of its size
- Can be fun to drive
- Very economical
- Cheap insurance
- Ease of maintainence - timing chain instead of belts etc... servicing would be a doddle
- Great for resale when you want to upgrade.
Just be careful of rust underneath, its what kills them eventually.
Sorry to give you more to think about but I just think the two cars you are considering will be pretty rough at this price range/age
Gassing Station | General Gassing [Archive] | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



