Should Top Gear include more stuff like this?
Should Top Gear include more stuff like this?
Author
Discussion

GTstar

Original Poster:

1,163 posts

272 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ikh65PCxFGw&fea...

awesome - ignore the cheezy graphic intro but apart from that it's more exciting than the fake stunts on TG

also like the way Best Motoring race 'stock' cars 6 at a time. Can you imagine the Health & Safety involved doing this for the BBC?!

RV8

1,570 posts

202 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
I'd happily watch a show with this sort of thing thrown in, thank God for YouTube because there isn't anything I know of on TV like this. The nauseating American's cheery accent is worse than the titles imo though.
The driving is on the edge, there looks to be little margin for error at those speeds especially with the other guy following so close, I doubt any Top Gear presenter is good enough to be driving like that on a road with no big runoff's. I imagine if they did a TG race on a track like that it'd only turn into another 'hilarious' excuse to play bumper cars - stop race, set up camera "on my que - May act like your miffed off, hammond look a little more guilty" - action.

RobM77

35,349 posts

265 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
yes

It never will though because it's not a show for petrolheads. Kids and girlfriends would get bored if that came on.

Save this sort of thing for my "Final Gear" idea for a late night BBC motoring show that's actually about cars for our Sky+ boxes and iPlayers smile Renting a race track, a few talkative racing drivers and an up and coming TV presenter to hold everything together would cost peanuts compared with the obviously substantial production costs of Top Gear.

Daniel1

2,931 posts

229 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
makes me want an S2000

R1chy11

890 posts

212 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
RobM77 said:
yes

It never will though because it's not a show for petrolheads. Kids and girlfriends would get bored if that came on.

Save this sort of thing for my "Final Gear" idea for a late night BBC motoring show that's actually about cars for our Sky+ boxes and iPlayers smile Renting a race track, a few talkative racing drivers and an up and coming TV presenter to hold everything together would cost peanuts compared with the obviously substantial production costs of Top Gear.
Would definitely watch that, get it done.

Always been a fan of best motoring videos,
seeing them race f40's etc around Tsukuba is a good watch.

GTstar

Original Poster:

1,163 posts

272 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
RobM77 said:
yes

It never will though because it's not a show for petrolheads. Kids and girlfriends would get bored if that came on.

Save this sort of thing for my "Final Gear" idea for a late night BBC motoring show that's actually about cars for our Sky+ boxes and iPlayers smile Renting a race track, a few talkative racing drivers and an up and coming TV presenter to hold everything together would cost peanuts compared with the obviously substantial production costs of Top Gear.
Exactly - TG could remain a 'entertainment show' whereas a new traditional test/hardcore/pistonhead based show could be done for BBC3/online. production doesn't need to be massive save money on helicopter shots, superfancy effects etc...

RobM77

35,349 posts

265 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
GTstar said:
RobM77 said:
yes

It never will though because it's not a show for petrolheads. Kids and girlfriends would get bored if that came on.

Save this sort of thing for my "Final Gear" idea for a late night BBC motoring show that's actually about cars for our Sky+ boxes and iPlayers smile Renting a race track, a few talkative racing drivers and an up and coming TV presenter to hold everything together would cost peanuts compared with the obviously substantial production costs of Top Gear.
Exactly - TG could remain a 'entertainment show' whereas a new traditional test/hardcore/pistonhead based show could be done for BBC3/online. production doesn't need to be massive save money on helicopter shots, superfancy effects etc...
yes I so wish that could happen. I could even make my own version - my best mate's a TV actor and I race cars (plus know loads of other drivers, many at pro level), so we could almost do it ourselves! biggrin

That's exactly it - you don't need fancy helicopter shots, amazing video editing, huge road trips across the globe etc. The programme wouldn't even have to be geeky. How expensive would a race around Goodwood between a 997 GT3 RS, a Nissan GTR and a Caterham R500 be? Get three enthusiastic well spoken racing drivers to do it for free (I could round up several hugely talented drivers with a few phone calls), rent the track for a few grand (yes, it is that cheap), insure the cars (ok, that might be a bit!) and get an up and coming TV presenter like my mate to do the presenting for a fairly modest fee. That's your headline feature. You could then have a factory visit to somewhere like Caterham, Ultima, Ariel, Brooke, Morgan or Bristol (loads in the UK alone) for another feature (free because of advertising), a try out of a club level race car for another (like Autosport sometimes do), which would also be free or very cheap because championships like to promote themselves, and maybe a good old road test to round up. That's easily enough for a 45 minute show once a week. Then all of us lot can get off the back of Top Gear and let them get on with family entertainment. If the BBC are reading this then throw me a small budget and I'll make you a pilot smile

GTstar

Original Poster:

1,163 posts

272 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
RobM77 said:
GTstar said:
RobM77 said:
yes

It never will though because it's not a show for petrolheads. Kids and girlfriends would get bored if that came on.

Save this sort of thing for my "Final Gear" idea for a late night BBC motoring show that's actually about cars for our Sky+ boxes and iPlayers smile Renting a race track, a few talkative racing drivers and an up and coming TV presenter to hold everything together would cost peanuts compared with the obviously substantial production costs of Top Gear.
Exactly - TG could remain a 'entertainment show' whereas a new traditional test/hardcore/pistonhead based show could be done for BBC3/online. production doesn't need to be massive save money on helicopter shots, superfancy effects etc...
yes I so wish that could happen. I could even make my own version - my best mate's a TV actor and I race cars (plus know loads of other drivers, many at pro level), so we could almost do it ourselves! biggrin

That's exactly it - you don't need fancy helicopter shots, amazing video editing, huge road trips across the globe etc. The programme wouldn't even have to be geeky. How expensive would a race around Goodwood between a 997 GT3 RS, a Nissan GTR and a Caterham R500 be? Get three enthusiastic well spoken racing drivers to do it for free (I could round up several hugely talented drivers with a few phone calls), rent the track for a few grand (yes, it is that cheap), insure the cars (ok, that might be a bit!) and get an up and coming TV presenter like my mate to do the presenting for a fairly modest fee. That's your headline feature. You could then have a factory visit to somewhere like Caterham, Ultima, Ariel, Brooke, Morgan or Bristol (loads in the UK alone) for another feature (free because of advertising), a try out of a club level race car for another (like Autosport sometimes do), which would also be free or very cheap because championships like to promote themselves, and maybe a good old road test to round up. That's easily enough for a 45 minute show once a week. Then all of us lot can get off the back of Top Gear and let them get on with family entertainment. If the BBC are reading this then throw me a small budget and I'll make you a pilot smile
+100: what do we need to do now then. Start a facebook page? lol - Pitch it at the improving Britsh industry, pioneering f1 industry, best designers, small volume specialists. It's looking good for Ginetta, Mclaren, atom, noble etc...

And every week there would be a PH chosen slot - what car/diesel or petrol/chipped or coilovers/bmw e46 or mx5 etc

Doesn't autocar work with/own PH - they did some online stuff, bring the 2 together and then you can get your hands on all the new cars you need...

JB!

5,255 posts

211 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
:O

amazing video!!!

makes me want an s2k now frown

Martin_Hx

4,029 posts

229 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
This is a crazy aswell, the WRC changes direction so quick

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TSZs-myn5xg&fea...

JB!

5,255 posts

211 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
Martin_Hx said:
This is a crazy aswell, the WRC changes direction so quick

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TSZs-myn5xg&fea...
wow.

that WRC isnt even in full tarmac trim either.

cut-slicks and tarmac suspension and that would ruin the S2k!!!!

UncappedTag

2,102 posts

216 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
Those are some highly skilled drivers smile

Daniel1

2,931 posts

229 months

Thursday 18th March 2010
quotequote all
JB! said:
Martin_Hx said:
This is a crazy aswell, the WRC changes direction so quick

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TSZs-myn5xg&fea...
wow.

that WRC isnt even in full tarmac trim either.

cut-slicks and tarmac suspension and that would ruin the S2k!!!!
Its not even a good rally car either boxedin

71notout

3,674 posts

268 months

Friday 19th March 2010
quotequote all
I got a mate to bring me back loads of Best Motoring and Hot Edition dvds when he was in Japan.

I can't understand a word, but the races are great biggrin

The_Jackal

4,854 posts

228 months

Friday 19th March 2010
quotequote all
Realistically guys, if it is so easy to produce a proper petrolheads tv show (which I assume at the very least all forum members would watch) on a budget, dont you think the PH management would be in a position to make this so? Especially with all the properly "rich" businessmen on here, you'd think raising the money would be easy.

The fact is, without marketing, merchandising and advertising it is not sustainable. If it is, why cant the country's favourite petrolhead site make it so? If not, then we have no hope eh?

Until it is, I suppose we just have to use one of our brain cells each year slagging off the only car programs on TV?

heebeegeetee

30,264 posts

279 months

Friday 19th March 2010
quotequote all
I've enjoyed those Japanese vids where they have 4-6 road cars of a certain class and race them on track, using proper, professional track drivers. I'd rather see more of that than the fake stunts, and if genuine standard road cars were compared, i think it would be popular with audiences.


TotalControl

8,307 posts

229 months

Friday 19th March 2010
quotequote all
71notout said:
I can't understand a word, but the races are great biggrin
Same here, I just watch with the sound turned off.

SClarke

546 posts

222 months

Friday 19th March 2010
quotequote all
Martin_Hx said:
This is a crazy aswell, the WRC changes direction so quick

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TSZs-myn5xg&fea...
The S2000 driver soooo nearly loses it at the end!