£3,000 for summer fun car. MX-5 or....?
£3,000 for summer fun car. MX-5 or....?
Author
Discussion

HereBeMonsters

Original Poster:

14,180 posts

213 months

Friday 19th March 2010
quotequote all
Say I were get bored saving for a 996 and decide I need some convertible/rwd action this Summer, I was looking at Mk2 MX-5s, but prices seem to have shot up at the first signs of spring. Would also be looking at a base 1.6 model.
Could go for a late and good condition Mk1, but I've noticed values of Mk3 MR-2s falling like a stone. An early model can be had for three grand. On paper they're faster than an MX-5, and I prefer the looks - far more modern. Mid-engined might also help me learn how to handle the rear-engined Porsche later on.

Would I be daft to NOT buy an MX-5? I have driven a number of them in the past, and all have been excellent, but the MR-2 is a much newer looking car, the interior is nicer and it looks to be faster.

redgriff500

28,982 posts

294 months

Friday 19th March 2010
quotequote all
I love MX5's but if you prefer the look of the MR-S and can cope with its decreased practicality then it is a good car.

But I like the MX5 because you can play with the rear, particularly with a 1.8 import and it will flatter and won't bite you.


HereBeMonsters

Original Poster:

14,180 posts

213 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
Been to look at both today. MX-5 values really are going through the roof. 1990 Eunos 1.6 with a ripped hood, knackered interior and rusty arches? £3495.

Skylinecrazy

13,986 posts

225 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
HereBeMonsters said:
Been to look at both today. MX-5 values really are going through the roof. 1990 Eunos 1.6 with a ripped hood, knackered interior and rusty arches? £3495.
That's called being overpriced.

By.

A lot.


theironduke

6,995 posts

219 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
Gaz. said:
HereBeMonsters said:
Been to look at both today. MX-5 values really are going through the roof. 1990 Eunos 1.6 with a ripped hood, knackered interior and rusty arches? £3495.
Lol. There is an MX5 dealer that will sell you a peach on a mk1 for £1500. I can't remember his name but he does have some nice looking cars.
3 and half bags for a dog..?? eeek. I paid just shy of 1400 for for 1991 1.6 V Spec which is tidy with loads of recent bills and full service history. And i love it!

Taffer

2,370 posts

228 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
I would really like to know where people are getting these bargain mint, rust-free MX5s! I paid £1100 for mine, but it needed a new power steering rack fitted (came with a spare, but owner hadn't installed it) and slightly rusty arches. £2-3k seems to be the going rate for tidy '5s, dependant on spec, but £3.5k for a crap one is just madness!


HereBeMonsters

Original Poster:

14,180 posts

213 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
OK, so it was a local dealer who specialises in £5-10k hatchbacks and family cars, but still, private values are not far off.
He seemed to think he would have no trouble selling it for the marked price when I remarked it was barely worth half that.

Still, moving house (to one with a garage - hence the convertible purchase) next weekend, better get on with the packing now.

How big is the boot in an MR2? Big enough for a 2 man tent, some camping gear, etc? Dealer was busy so didn't get a chance to look inside the car.

Edited by HereBeMonsters on Saturday 20th March 14:59

Luke.

12,052 posts

281 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
HereBeMonsters said:
How big is the boot in an MR2? Big enough for a 2 man tent, some camping gear, etc? Dealer was busy so didn't get a chance to look inside the car.

Edited by HereBeMonsters on Saturday 20th March 14:59
There isn't a boot. Seriously. Just two cubbies behind the seats.

HereBeMonsters

Original Poster:

14,180 posts

213 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
Luke. said:
HereBeMonsters said:
How big is the boot in an MR2? Big enough for a 2 man tent, some camping gear, etc? Dealer was busy so didn't get a chance to look inside the car.

Edited by HereBeMonsters on Saturday 20th March 14:59
There isn't a boot. Seriously. Just two cubbies behind the seats.
Nothing in the front?

Luke.

12,052 posts

281 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
Not really. Just the spare tyre IIRC.

Luke.

12,052 posts

281 months

HereBeMonsters

Original Poster:

14,180 posts

213 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
Luke. said:
Ah. I wondered why so many were advertised as having luggage racks! laugh

HereBeMonsters

Original Poster:

14,180 posts

213 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
So....any reason other than available luggage space why I should choose the MX-5?

Anyone hustled an MR-2 properly down a country lane? Will I be disappointed?

daemon

40,169 posts

228 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
HereBeMonsters said:
So....any reason other than available luggage space why I should choose the MX-5?

Anyone hustled an MR-2 properly down a country lane? Will I be disappointed?
Great little car

But the emphasis is on 'little' - no practicality at all

Taffer

2,370 posts

228 months

Sunday 21st March 2010
quotequote all
Luke. said:
Not really. Just the spare tyre IIRC.
The Mk.2 MR-2 has a small boot behind the engine:



I'd rather have one of these than the Mk.3 to be honest.......

Edited by Taffer on Sunday 21st March 00:06

falkster

4,258 posts

234 months

Sunday 21st March 2010
quotequote all
What about a 4 seater cab? Something like a facelift e30 BMW - maybe a 325??

HereBeMonsters

Original Poster:

14,180 posts

213 months

Sunday 21st March 2010
quotequote all
Taffer said:
Luke. said:
Not really. Just the spare tyre IIRC.
The Mk.2 MR-2 has a small boot behind the engine:



I'd rather have one of these than the Mk.3 to be honest.......
God no. A woman's car if ever I saw one. The epitome of bland 90s styling, exclusively driven by ageing divorcees as far as I can tell. Them, and middle aged blokes who want to get in to the Max Power scene with a JDM import Turbo and a daft bodykit. The Mk3 is far more what I'm after - light weight, poised handling, and less of the "ricer" image.

falkster said:
What about a 4 seater cab? Something like a facelift e30 BMW - maybe a 325??
Hell no. There's only one 4 seater cab that has ever looked good, and Hitler was in the back.

Speedracer329

1,507 posts

208 months

Sunday 21st March 2010
quotequote all
HereBeMonsters said:
God no. A woman's car if ever I saw one. The epitome of bland 90s styling, exclusively driven by ageing divorcees as far as I can tell. Them, and middle aged blokes who want to get in to the Max Power scene with a JDM import Turbo and a daft bodykit. The Mk3 is far more what I'm after - light weight, poised handling, and less of the "ricer" image.
That has to be a contender for the most ill advised comment I have seen on these pages sir.

HereBeMonsters

Original Poster:

14,180 posts

213 months

Sunday 21st March 2010
quotequote all
Do you really think the Mk2 is a good looking car?

Sums up everything that was wrong with early 90s Japanese design imo.

paoloh

8,617 posts

235 months

Sunday 21st March 2010
quotequote all
Skylinecrazy said:
HereBeMonsters said:
Been to look at both today. MX-5 values really are going through the roof. 1990 Eunos 1.6 with a ripped hood, knackered interior and rusty arches? £3495.
That's called being overpriced.

By.

A lot.
Yes, there is a 3 in there by mistake