Sometimes people baffle me
Sometimes people baffle me
Author
Discussion

jbi

Original Poster:

12,700 posts

235 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
I have a good mate who recently asked me for advice on a new car as he is having a run of bad luck with his jeep cherokee (2.5 diesel) and he tells me he is sick of it.

Now I know the issue's are not that bad and the jeep has many years of service left in it... it runs great and has many new parts.

I told him to keep it but he won't... he insist's on something else.

Here is the problem.

He lives down a farm track over a mile long that DESTROYS cars. It's not even paved for the most part. Even 4x4's suffer on it, the conditions are so bad.

So I say "well your going to want another 4x4 then right?"

"no I want a car"

I know he hates 4x4's but sometimes you have to be realistic right?

"i'll park the car at the farm at the end of the road and walk the rest of the way"

So I figure.. fine lets find a car then.

He gives me a budget of a couple of grand and after I list plenty of great cars he tells me he is thinking of just buying a new car.

I tell him the depreciation will be terrible and he will regret it.

He tells me he does not want the hassle of selling his jeep privately and just wants to trade it in.

I offer to buy his jeep from him and match the dealers offer but he refuses as he claims the car is a "liability" and does not want to inflict it on anyone else.

Next thing I know he has ignored my advice and traded his jeep in under the scrappage scheme against a ford fiesta zetec.

A perfectly good car scrapped, just like that because he could not be done with the hassle of selling it, while ignoring his mates advice and buying new, along with a car impractical for the location he lives in.

  • sigh* frown

reg_slr

688 posts

212 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
jbi said:
I have a good mate who recently asked me for advice on a new car as he is having a run of bad luck with his jeep cherokee (2.5 diesel) and he tells me he is sick of it.

Now I know the issue's are not that bad and the jeep has many years of service left in it... it runs great and has many new parts.

I told him to keep it but he won't... he insist's on something else.

Here is the problem.

He lives down a farm track over a mile long that DESTROYS cars. It's not even paved for the most part. Even 4x4's suffer on it, the conditions are so bad.

So I say "well your going to want another 4x4 then right?"

"no I want a car"

I know he hates 4x4's but sometimes you have to be realistic right?

"i'll park the car at the farm at the end of the road and walk the rest of the way"

So I figure.. fine lets find a car then.

He gives me a budget of a couple of grand and after I list plenty of great cars he tells me he is thinking of just buying a new car.

I tell him the depreciation will be terrible and he will regret it.

He tells me he does not want the hassle of selling his jeep privately and just wants to trade it in.

I offer to buy his jeep from him and match the dealers offer but he refuses as he claims the car is a "liability" and does not want to inflict it on anyone else.

Next thing I know he has ignored my advice and traded his jeep in under the scrappage scheme against a ford fiesta zetec.

A perfectly good car scrapped, just like that because he could not be done with the hassle of selling it, while ignoring his mates advice and buying new, along with a car impractical for the location he lives in.

  • sigh* frown
TBH the Jeep Cherokee wouldn't be top of my list for a hard life. Shoddy US build quality and with the diesel hardly a mover. I am pretty sure if he went for a Range/Land Rover or Cruiser he would have a far better ownership experience.

jbi

Original Poster:

12,700 posts

235 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
his parents have a discovery... it has had it's fair share of faults as well.

The jeep was fine, not a speck of rust on it... the heater core was leaking which is a time consuming and awkward fix, but something I could have done myself .

Engineer1

10,486 posts

240 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
The thing is sometimes one breakdown too many too close together kills your confidence in a car, and at 10 years plus old it could be starting to feel tired, there is nothing worse than never being sure your car will start or complete the journey.

Somnophore

1,364 posts

207 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
If most of his journey is on roads, and it is just this one bit of track that is not suitable for cars it sounds like a sensbile option to have a car and just park it down the track from his house. Why have a big tired not particularly economical 4x4 when most of your driving is on road.

jbi

Original Poster:

12,700 posts

235 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
it's not exactly a short track (1 mile)

but yes if he's fine walking then by all means get a car... but I hate when I see a perfectly usable car scrapped... what a waste.

Not to mention in a few years he will be left with a car less than half he value he paid for it.

Of course I did warn him, so it shouldn't be my problem, but it still grates on me.

Negative Creep

26,146 posts

258 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
i wonder if he will have any regrets when he gets home on a cold rainy night with a boot full of shopping?

Somnophore

1,364 posts

207 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
Think in that situation I'd probably buy a nearly new car to avoid depreciation, sell the 4x4 to you as I am the same as you, don't like to see a good car go to waste, and I'd probably get a cheap quad for the track up to the house with a box on te back for shopping, simples lol

dave_s13

14,031 posts

300 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
It would have been more cost effective to get his farm track tarmac'd. FFS!

As if he'll park his new car 1 mile! away and walk the rest, get real!

stephen300o

15,464 posts

259 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
reg_slr said:
TBH the Jeep Cherokee wouldn't be top of my list for a hard life. Shoddy US build quality and with the diesel hardly a mover.
I think the UK ones are built in Austria arn't they? they are a bit rubbish still though.
I'd go with an X3 3.0sd?(terrible reviews, but the numbers add up for me smile)

oblio

5,604 posts

258 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
I think if it were me I would have got the car, parked it at the end of the lane, kept the 4x4 also at the end of the lane and then when I got back in the car, jumped out of the car and into the 4x4 just to drive the mile down the car@ppy track. Next day, drive the 4x4 back to the car and off we go!

I guess if it was private land he could have SORN'd the 4x4 as well to avoid tax, insurance etc

Just a thought!

useyourdellusion

5,648 posts

221 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
It sounds like he's losing the will to me.....

ex vtskid

347 posts

207 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
Engineer1 said:
The thing is sometimes one breakdown too many too close together kills your confidence in a car, and at 10 years plus old it could be starting to feel tired, there is nothing worse than never being sure your car will start or complete the journey.
This is so true. I can see where you're coming from but if he's lost confidence in it it's such a horrible feeling, had the same with my Saxo (never really gained 100% confidence in it again).

Ed.

2,176 posts

269 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
Jeeps are terrible, my 20 year old only managed 480,000 km on an untouched drive train. I did have scrap it in the end but Ontario's roads are heavily salted.

I would have sorn'd it for offroad and got a road car as oblio suggested though.

jbi

Original Poster:

12,700 posts

235 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
yeah I think it was a confidence thing... he hates cars to start with and couldn't tell one end of a screwdriver from the other.

4 new tyres, new brakes, 2 new calipers, new starter motor, new battery.

All in the last year, and now off to the scrappy. frown

He only uses the car to drive to work 2 miles there and back....

He won't drive any further as he does not really have much confidence. He would rather take the train or bus for any long trips :S

Edited by jbi on Saturday 20th March 12:46

Somnophore

1,364 posts

207 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
You having a laugh, any idea how much it would cost to level out, fill and Tarmac a 1 miles piece of drive and then upkeep it? Many many thousands, really not worth it

redstu

2,287 posts

270 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
jbi said:
yeah I think it was a confidence thing... he hates cars to start with and couldn't tell one end of a screwdriver from the other.

4 new tyres, new brakes, 2 new calipers, new starter motor, new battery.

All in the last year, and now off to the scrappy. frown

He only uses the car to drive to work 2 miles there and back....

He won't drive any further as he does not really have much confidence. He would rather take the train or bus for any long trips :S

Edited by jbi on Saturday 20th March 12:46
Worse than going to the scappy its going to get crushed!

Quite amazing really only a 4 mile journey and he gets a new car! He could have bought a mountain bike and got a bit of excercise at the same time and not have to walk!

dave_s13

14,031 posts

300 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
Somnophore said:
You having a laugh, any idea how much it would cost to level out, fill and Tarmac a 1 miles piece of drive and then upkeep it? Many many thousands, really not worth it
How much does a new Fiesta Zetec cost??....many many thousands.

He now has a fiesta, not the worlds most robust vehicle, and a long walk to and from it every day. Getting the track metalled would be a long term investment.

But, without seeing the track, you can't really say.

B3njamin

1,129 posts

218 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
jbi said:
yeah I think it was a confidence thing... he hates cars to start with and couldn't tell one end of a screwdriver from the other.

4 new tyres, new brakes, 2 new calipers, new starter motor, new battery.

All in the last year, and now off to the scrappy. frown

He only uses the car to drive to work 2 miles there and back....

He won't drive any further as he does not really have much confidence. He would rather take the train or bus for any long trips :S

Edited by jbi on Saturday 20th March 12:46
So he has a drive of two miles to get to work, yet is happy to walk one mile back home from his car? I think I'd take up jogging for that sized commute and just get an umbrella, waterproofs and some waders for when it's wet if I was in such a scenario... Would save money going to the gym and a fortune on driving.

I suppose if you are fed up with problems occurring to your car, it might seem sensible to buy something new that in theory be hassle-free - I can't help feeling it's a silly idea but I can see the thinking behind it.

Justin-W

1,095 posts

255 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
Kinda baffles me, by the sounds of it he didnt buy a sensbile car. Scrappage scheme is false economy and I'd of gone for a used car, hopefully pre emmision tax regs, probably gone for something like a Subaru Forester if the track isnt too bad.

Only the other day I popped in Ford for some car bits to be told I should of scrapped mine for a poxy new Fiesta.

So Ginetta G32 with 42k on the clock, clean bill of health from MOT this morning but needs acouple of hundred sprent to tidy her up or a Poxy fiesta for 10 or so grand....

Muppets.