Possible HG Failure? Or what else?
Possible HG Failure? Or what else?
Author
Discussion

hardcorehobbit

Original Poster:

1,103 posts

226 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
Hey all,

I have an Astra mk4 1.6 8v, 1998 with 38k.

During my fluid and pressure checks, I noticed the presence of the white mayo like stuff under my oil filler cap. So HG failure I think. However, the car is not losing any coolant, which, a good month later, is still at the same level.

The oil itself looks fine, and there is no gunk on the dipstick. Theres no rough running, other than an occasional warning light for the EGR valve, which was appearing as a fault on the dash.

Just passed an MOT, and most of my journeys are more than 5 or 6 miles since I live out in the middle of nowhere near Perth.

I was wondering if anyone knew of anything else that could produce that white gunk, or whether I need to do a compression test to further examine what the problem might be.

Thanks in advance everyone.

B'stard Child

31,181 posts

277 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
hardcorehobbit said:
Hey all,

I have an Astra mk4 1.6 8v, 1998 with 38k.

During my fluid and pressure checks, I noticed the presence of the white mayo like stuff under my oil filler cap. So HG failure I think. However, the car is not losing any coolant, which, a good month later, is still at the same level.

The oil itself looks fine, and there is no gunk on the dipstick. Theres no rough running, other than an occasional warning light for the EGR valve, which was appearing as a fault on the dash.

Just passed an MOT, and most of my journeys are more than 5 or 6 miles since I live out in the middle of nowhere near Perth.

I was wondering if anyone knew of anything else that could produce that white gunk, or whether I need to do a compression test to further examine what the problem might be.

Thanks in advance everyone.
Is it running at 90 deg C?

hardcorehobbit

Original Poster:

1,103 posts

226 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
Only in traffic. Mostly it runs nearer 80C.

varsas

4,077 posts

233 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
Well, it could just be condensation on the inside of the oil filler cap, happens fairly often. I assume the oil level is also not going down? Run the car up to temperature, remove the cap from the expansion/header tank (carefully!) and look for bubbles...if there are then it's blown. You can also check for water comming out of the exhaust pipe, hold your hand/some paper behind the exhaust and rev the engine (a bit while the car is cold is normal though). It does sound like it hasn't gone to me though...

You can buy 'sniffer' kits which will tell you if it's gone.

hardcorehobbit

Original Poster:

1,103 posts

226 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
Oil isn't going down, no.

I'll have a bit of an examine later then. Thanks mate, big help. Bit of reassurance I'm unlikely to be in for a big bill is nice.

K87

2,111 posts

218 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
Do a compression check to be sure, but if your doing a lot of small journeys and its cold and damp weather wise its pretty normal for a bit of codensation.

varsas

4,077 posts

233 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
Even if it is HGF, as long as you catch it before the engine overheats and the head warps it's not that big a deal. Lass time I had HGF (1.6 Cavalier, so similar engine to your's I suspect) it only cost £100 to put right.

B'stard Child

31,181 posts

277 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
hardcorehobbit said:
Only in traffic. Mostly it runs nearer 80C.
Put a new thermostat in it - if the engine isn't getting up to temp the condensation is never going to get driven out - and you are going to have gunky white stuff in the rocker cover.

Same thing happens on cars constantly driven very small distances and never get hot

hardcorehobbit

Original Poster:

1,103 posts

226 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
B'stard Child said:
hardcorehobbit said:
Only in traffic. Mostly it runs nearer 80C.
Put a new thermostat in it - if the engine isn't getting up to temp the condensation is never going to get driven out - and you are going to have gunky white stuff in the rocker cover.

Same thing happens on cars constantly driven very small distances and never get hot
Fair enough. A new thermostat and a couple of long distance hoons then? smile

as much as you can hoon in a car with 83bhp.

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

286 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
hardcorehobbit said:
Hey all,

I have an Astra mk4 1.6 8v, 1998 with 38k.

During my fluid and pressure checks, I noticed the presence of the white mayo like stuff under my oil filler cap. So HG failure I think.
Very unlikely I think, the presence of mayo on the oil filler cap with no other symptoms is almost never a head gasket related issue.

When you say your journeys are mostly more than 5-6 miles, do you mean 7 miles or 30 miles?

leeeeshad

1,480 posts

218 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
Mr2Mike said:
hardcorehobbit said:
Hey all,

I have an Astra mk4 1.6 8v, 1998 with 38k.

During my fluid and pressure checks, I noticed the presence of the white mayo like stuff under my oil filler cap. So HG failure I think.
Very unlikely I think, the presence of mayo on the oil filler cap with no other symptoms is almost never a head gasket related issue.

When you say your journeys are mostly more than 5-6 miles, do you mean 7 miles or 30 miles?
The 8v astra engine is known for mayo, give it a long run and it should go.


jagracer

8,248 posts

267 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
If you have real doubts about try and find a helpful garage and get them to do a sniff test on the coolant. From what you say I'd think it's condensation.

hardcorehobbit

Original Poster:

1,103 posts

226 months

Saturday 20th March 2010
quotequote all
Mr2Mike said:
hardcorehobbit said:
Hey all,

I have an Astra mk4 1.6 8v, 1998 with 38k.

During my fluid and pressure checks, I noticed the presence of the white mayo like stuff under my oil filler cap. So HG failure I think.
Very unlikely I think, the presence of mayo on the oil filler cap with no other symptoms is almost never a head gasket related issue.

When you say your journeys are mostly more than 5-6 miles, do you mean 7 miles or 30 miles?
It depends. The nearest shop is 6 miles away. Anything else is further obviously.

It does seem to be the consensus that I'm fine though. Thank you all very much.