Thats right another what car thread
Thats right another what car thread
Author
Discussion

farrendahl

Original Poster:

1,248 posts

205 months

Sunday 21st March 2010
quotequote all
Okay folks, with redundancy looking more and more likely I have with luck been able to line up some freelance work in the summer teaching people to ride horses and doing a bit of pony transportation however to do this I'm going to need a second car because as willing as the pug is it's certainly not going to be up to the job of towing a horse box and/or carting around my riding gear (tack, saddle, equine first aide kit) so I have a challenge.

Needs

Budget of no more than 4k (prefer lower though)
Large boot capacity
Able to tow a Ifor Williams HB506 horsebox (Gross weight 2600kg)
Economical (well more than 25mpg)

Not essential

4 wheel drive
Earth shattering performance

So suggestions people?

Robert060379

15,754 posts

214 months

Sunday 21st March 2010
quotequote all
Fiat Panda.











hehe

farrendahl

Original Poster:

1,248 posts

205 months

Sunday 21st March 2010
quotequote all
Robert you are neither big nor clever, go to the naughty step this instance lol

hardcorehobbit

1,103 posts

226 months

Sunday 21st March 2010
quotequote all
Audi A4/6?
Subaru Legacy?
Skoda Octavia Scout?

farrendahl

Original Poster:

1,248 posts

205 months

Sunday 21st March 2010
quotequote all
hardcorehobbit said:
Audi A4/6?
Subaru Legacy?
Skoda Octavia Scout?
Alas the Skodas maximum tow weight is a fair bit off same with the A4/A6 and the Legacy

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 21st March 2010
quotequote all
Jeep cherokee/grand cherokee, isuzu trooper, land rover discovery tdi will all fall within your budget and will all do the job very well.
The tdi discovery will probably be the most economical with about 30mpg.
I wouldn't bother with an estate car, they just aren't up to the job. We used to occasionally use a bmw 525ix estate to tow our iforwilliams horse box with just one horse and it would struggle, with two large horses it would be downright dangerous. We have always had discoverys as our main tow car and they do a great job.

farrendahl

Original Poster:

1,248 posts

205 months

Sunday 21st March 2010
quotequote all
champ54321 said:
Jeep cherokee/grand cherokee, isuzu trooper, land rover discovery tdi will all fall within your budget and will all do the job very well.
The tdi discovery will probably be the most economical with about 30mpg.
I wouldn't bother with an estate car, they just aren't up to the job. We used to occasionally use a bmw 525ix estate to tow our iforwilliams horse box with just one horse and it would struggle, with two large horses it would be downright dangerous. We have always had discoverys as our main tow car and they do a great job.
After doing further research you're spot on, it was more curiosity and promising the other half that I wouldn't auto default to a Defender (He has an issue with 4x4's in general) that led to the search. I was pretty certain from the get go that there wouldn't be an estate on the market that would be up to the job but fortune favours the bold and all that lol.