New starter motor issues?
New starter motor issues?
Author
Discussion

G_T

Original Poster:

16,163 posts

221 months

Sunday 21st March 2010
quotequote all
Hi chaps really need some help with this one as I know very little about electrickery... Car is Golf mk2 1991 1.8 8v PB digifant.

Some background: The golf died and failed to start in January. AA man arrived. Replaced terminal to starter motor, hit with hammer to no avail. New starter motor was required. Prior to this I measured 13.5V across the battery terminals so assumed the alternator was fine.

I then fitted new starter motor (an unbranded eBay variety). Wired as per original but would not work (spun constantly). So I switched the wires around. Car starts as it should. However...

Then problems. When the ignition is turned off the starter motor kicks up again and turns constantly. The only way to stop this is by disconnecting the +VE terminal.

I dabbled with the wires again and found out that by disconnecting the voltage regulator wire (small blue wire from alternator) there are no problems but obviously this is not a long term solution.

As I said before I know very little about electrics but I have been looking for breaks in the wire or anything unusual to now avail. To confound matters further the alternator now does not appear to be charging as it should but I am begining to suspect my voltmeter is knackered.

There was no sign of this problem prior to the new starter motor but everything is fine except when the ignition is turned off!

Help!

-Gareth

(Also posted in VAG section)

chris1roll

2,069 posts

275 months

Sunday 21st March 2010
quotequote all
This isn't incredibly helpful I know, but I bought an unbranded E-bay starter for my 480 turbo years back.
It made a horrible noise and lasted a month before jamming on.
Lesson learned. Or not, as I do still occasionally end up with poorly made tat arriving in the post. boxedin

Do you still have the old one, you could get it reconditioned. It might only need a new solenoid but even if it needs rewinding it would still be cheaper than a (decent) new one. Thats what I ended up doing.
Or you can get service exchange ones.

EDIT: As soon as I read the title, before opening the thread I knew E-bay was going to be involved!

Edited by chris1roll on Sunday 21st March 18:39

G_T

Original Poster:

16,163 posts

221 months

Sunday 21st March 2010
quotequote all
I actually don't think the start is dodgey (and I still have the sellers warranty, paypal warranty and credit card insurance to fall back on!). And I kept my old one just in case!

After a bit of tootling I believe the dodgey wire may go to voltage regulator. After removing the regulator it is in a bit of a sorry state.

Although quite why it's the cause of firing 12v to the starter is beyond me... Going to have to replace, check earths, then try again...