Replacement Windscreens
Author
Discussion

donkeydavid

Original Poster:

22 posts

202 months

Sunday 21st March 2010
quotequote all
I just got my Laguna's (don't laugh please - it was new and VERY cheap) cracked windscreen replaced by a well-known company - you know who I mean. It was frosty on the next two days so I scraped it with the same scraper I've used for years. It's now covered in scratches. The original was three years old and had no such scratches. This begs the question - do they replace original windscreens with sub-standard versions? Is there some coating that is present on the original but not on the replacement? Has anyone else experienced this phenomenon? Not happy but if I complain they'll just say there was grit on the scraper or something like that!

V8mate

45,899 posts

220 months

Sunday 21st March 2010
quotequote all
It 'raises the question'; it doesn't 'beg the question'. There is no logical fallacy in your assertion.



Someone more helpful will be along shortly however, though I have, handily, pushed your thread back to the top of the list smile

Rocksteadyeddie

7,971 posts

258 months

Sunday 21st March 2010
quotequote all
I'm getting a new windscreen fitted tomorrow.

I shall report back in the event that it is frosty and a scraper is called for.

HTH

HellDiver

5,708 posts

213 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
I've always found replacement screens to be considerably weaker to chips and scratches than the factory fit screen.

My old work's runabout Corsa B had it's original screen for 8 years, few chips on it. A brick hit it, so new screen went in. 4 screens broke due to tiny pebbles and general road grit hitting it in the following 2 years. All replacements were branded screens fitted by RAC Windscreens.

dibbly dobbler

11,507 posts

228 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
David - if you wielded the scraper with the same degree of sloppiness that is displayed in your post is it not possible that you, in fact, were to blame and damaged the windscreen yourself ?

donkeydavid

Original Poster:

22 posts

202 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
Thank you for that useful advice, dibblydobbler. Maybe I inadvertently dipped the scraper in a bucket of sand before I used it without realising. There is no doubt in my mind that the replacement screen is sub-standard. It's probably still worth more than the car though wink

dibbly dobbler

11,507 posts

228 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
Why not just fix it

smile

Glassman

25,102 posts

246 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
There is no evidence to support your claims of replacement windscreens not being up to scratch¹.

Despite the clear divide between OEM and aftermarket, there still is nothing to suggest that there would even be a scuff² of truth in the suggestion. Industry giants such as (Sekurit) Saint Gobain, Pilkington, Guardian, Safevue, PPG, Splintex etc all supply glass to the OEMs. But not all that is manufactured with the OE logo goes to the assembly plants. The same glass made with the same materials at the same plants by the same people is also sent to the aftermarket suppliers minus one thing: the (car) manufacturer logo. In some cases, the logo can be seen under light where it has been scraped³ off.

All glass is made to OE spec. They have to be. Else it cannot be passed. No pass: no E stamp; no use.

There are also 'cheaper' brands on the market. But this is not to say that they are sub-standard or inderior in any way. Yes, there are some examples which are known throughout the industry as worse than others (and by this, I refer to imperfections such as curvature / shaping issues; poor finish on the 'cut' edges, or the sandwich construction to come apart - also known as de-laminating). In my experience, the one brand that ticks these boxes comes from a UK nationwide company who manufacture and fit their own windscreens. There is another UK nationwide windscreen company that is shipping in glass from abroad. It's cheaper and that's all I can say.

Other lesser known brands are also coming in thick and fast: Lamishield, XYG and Fuyao. But, the Land Rover Freelander 2 is assembled with Fuyao glass at source. I can't knock it, however, my conscience will not allow me to fit a piece of glass made by 'Benson' into a brand new MB CLs.

But the OP mentions a scraper... scratchchin




¹,² and ³.. wink

Edited by Glassman on Monday 22 March 21:02

deaglecat

162 posts

264 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
I had problems with a Metro (don't laugh... it was a good few years ago) where the original screen failed and then we had a quick succession of aftermarket replacement screens.

I got talking to the fitter who claimed that in his experience original screens were indeed more robust and if given the choice he would always choose to have a stone chip repaired than the screen replaced.

I have followed this advice ever since - fixes every time and NO replacement screens.

donkeydavid

Original Poster:

22 posts

202 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
Thanks (I think), Glassman, for your very full and 'frank' response. All I can say, once again, is that I have used the same windscreen scraper to remove ice for nearly three years with not a mark to be seen. I've wielded it pretty roughly in all that time too! We'll leave it at that and I'll go back to the trusty warm water solution in future - don't worry for me now, I won't use boiling water from a kettle like some people do.

Glassman

25,102 posts

246 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
Out of interest, who is your windscreen manufactured by? The name is usually around the N/S bottom, where most people would put their RFL.