Fiesta ST VS Twingo RS...
Fiesta ST VS Twingo RS...
Author
Discussion

Pageo

Original Poster:

75 posts

202 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
As The title suggests PH's im in a dilemma over which car to choose from the two above,

Ford Fiesta ST or a Renault Twingo RS.

I have test driven a Twingo RS and thought it was brilliant, i have driven a fiesta before ( 1.6 16v zetec s ) and i like that too but im stuck on which one to buy, The twingo RS would cost just under £10k while i could pick up a fiesta ST for around £6k on an 2006 plate. so the fiesta wins on money value however im all in for performance and wondered if any PH'S own any of these two cars?

The main thing that bothers me that a fiesta st has 155bhp 2.0 and a twingo rs has 133bhp on a 1.6 vvt, both can do 0-62 in 8 seconds or less if pushed. Is paying extra for the fiesta insurance wise seeing as its a group 13?

Need some help guys! also is there any others cars that can match the performance of these two that are around £6-8K or less? im 23 with 3 years ncb so it would have to be a decent insurance group! the most recent qoute for an audi tt 180 was just over £1000

Wayne King

1,100 posts

224 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
If i had to choose between them, it would the Twingo. But neither would make my list, if i wanted to spend £6k used, then i would be probably be looking at the Clio 182 or Honda Integra.

It is hardly a fair comparison though, newer 'vs' older and £10k 'vs' £6k.

slipstream 1985

13,802 posts

210 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
twingo imo, depending on how inportant money is. the twingo looks cool

Pageo

Original Poster:

75 posts

202 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
I do Admit the twingo does look cool, i did think of a renaultsport clio but isnt the 182 a high insurance group? and is it better than the 172?

slipstream 1985

13,802 posts

210 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
i cant see how insurance is a problem at 23?

slipstream 1985

13,802 posts

210 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
TVR Moneypit said:
slipstream 1985 said:
i cant see how insurance is a problem at 23?
Try being 23.

The OP's next decent insurance drop will come at 25, then 30.


What sort of mileage do you expect to do be doing per year? Are you able to do your own maintinance?
i was 20 with an mr2 turbo and had the nob at 24. unless he lives in down town bassara or has no-noclaims it shouldnt be that much more for a 182 over a twingo?

Pageo

Original Poster:

75 posts

202 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
You'l be suprised, the woman at direct line and a rep at adrian flux said that its hard for youngsters ( she claims under 25's regardless of NCB and driving exp ) to get insurance on cars unless its insurance group 10 or under. When i say hard i mean as in around the £500 a year bracket

i did a qoute on my mums peugeot 107 1.0 urban on a 2008 58 plate and it came out at just £198 - with unlimited mileage and an excess of just £150 fully comp. compared to the fiesta st which is just around £800 ( with an excess of £500 and 8000 miles. it doesnt help that winky wants to put isurance premuim tax up again!!

slipstream 1985

13,802 posts

210 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
at the time 24 £500 fully comp on the nob 6 years ncb. 3 points.

admiral or elephant by far the best, have a play about with the settings available, there are set tollerance levels you can make in your favour. and add parents to YOUR policy that have clean licences. they need never drive the car but it makes a huge difference.
.

sherman

15,342 posts

246 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
There's a reason the twingo rs has been in a few recent EVO group tests. I cant remember the fiesta ever being in one.

neelyp

1,703 posts

242 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
I have two sons, the oldest has a 56 plate Fiesta ST and the younger one got a Twingo Cup at the end of January.
The Twingo is not as quick as the ST but I think it is more fun to drive, the ST is nicer inside, the Twingo nicer outside.

As for insurance, the boy with the ST is 22 and it cost him around £500, the Twingo boy is 21 and it worked out around £600.

XitUp

7,690 posts

235 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
TVR Moneypit said:
slipstream 1985 said:
on the nob
.
Thats twice in two consecutive posts.

Why do you keep talking about nobs?
Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar.

bazking69

8,620 posts

221 months

Monday 22nd March 2010
quotequote all
Wifey has been sniffing around the Twingo 133. Personally I'd wait until the Twingos are a couple to three years old before considering. They haven't yet proved themselves as a reliable ownership prospect yet for one. Plus there aren't a huge number of used about hence prices remain firm. Give it a couple of years and the prices will have dived signifigantly. £10k-£12k for a Mini-Renault is alot of money in the face of a used Mini Cooper or a barely used Fiesta ST.

Yes the Fiesta is getting a bit dated now but it's a good buy for the money IMO.