A long winded "what car" thread... bear with me!
A long winded "what car" thread... bear with me!
Author
Discussion

Bob Fossil

Original Poster:

954 posts

270 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
I know... hardly the most exciting thread title in the world!

Now, thanks to the wonder of MINI residuals I'm in the position where I can get out of my PCP for next to nothing. This gives me an opportunity to change cars (which I'm never averse to), but also a dilemma.

I do about 25k a year, and I have come to the conclusion that it would be nice to have a car that I can just drive and forget (in terms of trying to keep it immaculate / free from parking dents etc), as well as not worrying too much about depreciation. I could then put any savings towards a weekend toy (probably Elise / Caterham) in 1-2 years when I (hopefully) move to a house with a garage. This makes me think I should buy a cooking 3-series / A4 diesel for £12k (ish) and play the "long game", as it were. This goes against all my in-built impatience.

The "middle" me thinks I should by something like an Alpina D3 for £16k-£19k, and try to keep it nice but accept that I'll lose some money in depreciation as well as it taking some battle-scars.

The "bad" me (or sensible if you apply PH rules) says that I only live once, so to go and by something special (don't know what yet) for upto £25k and sod the money / depreciation etc...

Or should I buy something older (E46 M3?) and put some aside for running costs?

Aaaaaaaaaaaaargh! It's doing my head in.

Help!

ewenm

28,506 posts

276 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
Or get a snotter for a couple of grand and put the rest to the Caterham fund.

Bob Fossil

Original Poster:

954 posts

270 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
Sorry, forgot to add - reliability is a big thing for me, as I need to get to meetings in all sorts of places at all sorts of times... but practicality isn't - we have a Volvo estate for that sort of thing.

davido140

9,617 posts

257 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
4-6k on a half decent oil burner, and you're 10k closer to the caterham.

I got a 3 year old Mondeo Tdi for 6k, Im still coming to terms with how bloody cheap it is to run compared to my previous barges etc.

Which means I'll be back in silly cars before too long!

Gizmo!

18,150 posts

240 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
Doing 25k miles, I'd buy something nice. Probably wouldn't stretch to the Alpina though - a late E46 330d (not 335!) will be 90% of the car. Something like this http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2010... will lose a bit of money but not a lot, and won't be ruinous to run.

Then buy a cheap toy for the weekends - £3k on a Porsche 944, turbo MR2/MX5, maybe even a TVR S3...

Bob Fossil

Original Poster:

954 posts

270 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
That E46 is cheap! Is it Cat D though? The description is a big vague.

I'd love a weekend toy, but don't have the space at the minute unfortunately...

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
Id go for somthing comfy!

Bob Fossil

Original Poster:

954 posts

270 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
The more I look, the more cheap E46 M3's I see... but I imagine 25k p/a would kill one?

I've never had a convertible... maybe an Alpina S Roadster?

Mars

10,169 posts

245 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
ewenm said:
Or get a snotter for a couple of grand and put the rest to the Caterham fund.
I'm with him. In factm, it's what I've done. biggrin

g7jhp

7,035 posts

269 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
If I was doing 25k, I'd go for a E60 525d S.E. for around £12k (with 70k) as they are comfortable and chip for extra torque. Then go Caterhan for the weekend.