Power Vs Speed Question
Author
Discussion

catman

Original Poster:

2,504 posts

206 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
I've been in two cars with similar performance, but with very different engines.

one was a 5.7 litre V8, the other was a 1.8 litre supercharged. can anyone explain the feeling of immense power from the 5.7, and the feeling of little power from the 1.8, even though it was at least as fast as the bigger engined car?

Yes, I know that the 5.7 produced far more power, but I've noticed the same feeling from slower, large capacity engines before.

Perhaps someone can explain this, as I don't get it!

Tim

Outbound

342 posts

214 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
Higher displacement, more torque.

HTH

Edited by Outbound on Tuesday 23 March 19:36

MX7

7,902 posts

205 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
What were the weights of the cars?

kambites

71,708 posts

252 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
I don't think it's anything to do with absolute torque but rather the shape of the torque curve. The human body doesn't really notice acceleration very much; what you tend to feel is rate of change of acceleration - m/s/s/s.

catman

Original Poster:

2,504 posts

206 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
Cobra replica, vs Lotus Exige! But, as the Exige accelerated as fast, if not faster than the Cobra, it's rate of change would be superior, but the Cobra still felt much more powerful. which, of course it was.

Tim

Edited by catman on Tuesday 23 March 19:54

Rothgo Wooft

157 posts

200 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
I know what you mean... Its an interesting question.

Maybe the V8 doesn't sound like its trying so hard because of the lower revs?

catman

Original Poster:

2,504 posts

206 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
It's the feeling of being thrown along by a giant, invisible hand, to use an old quote, which isn't there, in the faster, smaller-engined car.

Why is it that you feel this power, even though the car itself is no faster?

Tim

gamefreaks

2,070 posts

218 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
Surely the noise is a big part of it.

A bloke that works where I do had a VW van with a 5.7 Chevvy V8 in it. The whole bloody building shook when he fired it up.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
gamefreaks said:
VW van with a 5.7 Chevvy V8 in it. The whole bloody building shook when he fired it up.
Pure quality!

Humans tend to like turbo cars because they "feel" the shove when turbo kicks in, even though performance low down is somewhat lacking. A proper V8 just delivers a relentless shove all the way from 1,500 rpm to max' rpm making a very fast car.

dibbly dobbler

11,507 posts

228 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
kambites said:
The human body doesn't really notice acceleration very much; what you tend to feel is rate of change of acceleration - m/s/s/s.
Kambites - I'm not with you here, surely it's the rate of change of speed (ie simply acceleration) which produces the sensation rather than rate of change of acceleration ? Can you elucidate further please ?

reggie82

1,377 posts

209 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
dibbly dobbler said:
kambites said:
The human body doesn't really notice acceleration very much; what you tend to feel is rate of change of acceleration - m/s/s/s.
Kambites - I'm not with you here, surely it's the rate of change of speed (ie simply acceleration) which produces the sensation rather than rate of change of acceleration ? Can you elucidate further please ?
A car that accelerates smoothly doesn't 'feel' as fast as a car that suddenly gives you a burst of acceleration.

Floor something big and powerful and it quite often doesn't feel that quick until you look at the speedo and realised how fast you're going. Floor a turbo'd car thats just as fast, and it will usually 'feel' much fast due to how the power is delivered.

kambites

71,708 posts

252 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
reggie82 said:
dibbly dobbler said:
kambites said:
The human body doesn't really notice acceleration very much; what you tend to feel is rate of change of acceleration - m/s/s/s.
Kambites - I'm not with you here, surely it's the rate of change of speed (ie simply acceleration) which produces the sensation rather than rate of change of acceleration ? Can you elucidate further please ?
A car that accelerates smoothly doesn't 'feel' as fast as a car that suddenly gives you a burst of acceleration.

Floor something big and powerful and it quite often doesn't feel that quick until you look at the speedo and realised how fast you're going. Floor a turbo'd car thats just as fast, and it will usually 'feel' much fast due to how the power is delivered.
yes I make no claims to understand why. It just seems to be the case, both from my own personal experience and from talking to other people.

dibbly dobbler

11,507 posts

228 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
reggie82 said:
dibbly dobbler said:
kambites said:
The human body doesn't really notice acceleration very much; what you tend to feel is rate of change of acceleration - m/s/s/s.
Kambites - I'm not with you here, surely it's the rate of change of speed (ie simply acceleration) which produces the sensation rather than rate of change of acceleration ? Can you elucidate further please ?
A car that accelerates smoothly doesn't 'feel' as fast as a car that suddenly gives you a burst of acceleration.

Floor something big and powerful and it quite often doesn't feel that quick until you look at the speedo and realised how fast you're going. Floor a turbo'd car thats just as fast, and it will usually 'feel' much fast due to how the power is delivered.
Right - so a short burst of high acceleration makes one feel like something dramatic is happening rather than a longer burst of acceleration at a lower level ? I can agree with that (if that's what you are saying of course !)

FreeLitres

6,128 posts

208 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
Force = Mass x Acceleration

If you are travelling at a constant velocity, you wouldn’t experience any force except gravity. For example. You could be travelling in an Aeroplane at a steady 300 mph and there would be no force pushing you back into your seat.

So it’s the rate of change of velocity (“acceleration”) that makes a car feels fast.

Good old Newton.

kambites

71,708 posts

252 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
FreeLitres said:
Force = Mass x Acceleration

If you are travelling at a constant velocity, you wouldn’t experience any force except gravity. For example. You could be travelling in an Aeroplane at a steady 300 mph and there would be no force pushing you back into your seat.

So it’s the rate of change of velocity (“acceleration”) that makes a car feels fast.

Good old Newton.
That's the point though, it's not. Whilst yes you can feel acceleration in the absolute sense the human body seems to be very bad at it. It seems to be much better at sensing rate of change of rate of change of velocity (which of course can also be felt in the absolute), as can any further derivatives.

catman

Original Poster:

2,504 posts

206 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
I'm enjoying the replies, but my original question hasn't been answered yet!

Tim

kambites

71,708 posts

252 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
dibbly dobbler said:
Right - so a short burst of high acceleration makes one feel like something dramatic is happening rather than a longer burst of acceleration at a lower level ? I can agree with that (if that's what you are saying of course !)
Pretty much, yeah. Take two cars which average 1g of acceleration from 40-60mph, one of which does 40-50 at 0.5g and then 50-60 at 1.5g, and the other of which does a constant 1g and the former will feel faster.

kambites

71,708 posts

252 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
catman said:
I'm enjoying the replies, but my original question hasn't been answered yet!

Tim
I can't do any better than "it's to do with the shape of the power curve" I'm afraid. If your smaller engine had the same shaped power curve as the large one, you wouldn't be able to tell them apart by feel.

FreeLitres

6,128 posts

208 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
kambites said:
FreeLitres said:
Force = Mass x Acceleration

If you are travelling at a constant velocity, you wouldn’t experience any force except gravity. For example. You could be travelling in an Aeroplane at a steady 300 mph and there would be no force pushing you back into your seat.

So it’s the rate of change of velocity (“acceleration”) that makes a car feels fast.

Good old Newton.
That's the point though, it's not. Whilst yes you can feel acceleration in the absolute sense the human body seems to be very bad at it. It seems to be much better at sensing rate of change of rate of change of velocity (which of course can also be felt in the absolute), as can any further derivatives.
I think I see what you are suggesting, but I'm not sure I agree. An increase in the rate of change of acceleration would be felt as "increasing acceleration" or increasing force. The force is still always dictated by the acceleration value.

HertsBiker

6,443 posts

302 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
kambites said:
I don't think it's anything to do with absolute torque but rather the shape of the torque curve. The human body doesn't really notice acceleration very much; what you tend to feel is rate of change of acceleration - m/s/s/s.
I understand totally - the Rate Of Change increases giving that exponential rush. The same as a screamer bike or a big turbo car. NOthing at first then more and more and MORE ! love that feeling.

Edited by HertsBiker on Tuesday 23 March 22:00