What would you consider as "full service history"?
What would you consider as "full service history"?
Author
Discussion

LocoBlade

Original Poster:

7,653 posts

287 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
All

Some advice please! We recently bought a 2 year old car from a car supermarket, its done about 45k miles and was advertised as having full service history. We realised before buying that the car had been sourced from a major rental firm, but the car was in good condition and the price was competitive so we weren't too concerned about it's past.

When collecting the car I checked over all the documents as you do, all seemed fine apart from the service history booklet which only had one stamp from about a month ago at around 43k from the supplying dealer, but no other stamps for services done prior to that and no receipts for any services. Instead, in the back of the service book was stapled a photocopy of a letter from the hire company simply stating that the car had been serviced at 3 specified mileages on 3 dates "in accordance with manufacturers recommendation". The letter isn't personally signed and looks rather amateurish to me, almost anyone could rattle up something equally good within 5 minutes in MS Word by pasting a logo and typing an address in bog standard Arial font. The letterhead is of a quality you'd expect from a one man band small business, not from a well known multinational car rental business, terefore it's pretty much worthless IMHO because if I put myself in the shoes of someone buying the car from me in future, I don't think I'd believe it's authenticity.

I raised the concern with the sales chap at the time who said he could get the service book sent off to the rental company be correctly stamped by their servicing department. I was happy with this and didn't really think anything more of it, the car was fine and we had no reason to suspect what we'd been told.

3 weeks later though we received the service book back, but in exactly the same state as it was at time of purchase, still no stamps so still no evidence of the services completed. We raised it with the salesman again and he apologised for the "mix up" and offered to get a new book stamped, but that hasn't materialised either and today I recieved an e-mail with an attached Word document which is another letter supposedly from the hire company basically saying exactly the same as the one we already have! This one looks equally unprofessional, but interestingly the formatting and Logo placement within the letterhead is not the same as the first, which makes me wonder if they're genuine at all!

Basically I'd like the collective PH thoughts on whether I'm being unreasonable, whats the norm when buying ex rental cars, and where I take this next? I'm about to write a second complaint letter to the dealer but these seem to fall on deaf ears or get "answered" with e-mails like the one today, so I was wondering what recourse we have and how best to approach it?

Apologies for the length of the post!

cheers

Edited by LocoBlade on Tuesday 23 March 23:06

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
Oh dear. You knowingly bought an ex-rental with no service history.

I would imagine there are grounds for regecting the car or getting trading standards involved.

FraserLFA

5,083 posts

205 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
hornetrider said:
regecting
Or if that fails, try rejecting it biggrin

Seriously though OP, this is going to be complicated. I would tell them to take the car back before going any further. This story has a lot of twists and turns in it and could go either way in the laws eyes

Mr serge

197 posts

213 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
the sales guy lied to you he would have no knowledge if they could sort out the stamps i sold cars for a few years and the it was a tactic that was used often. you should try and take the car back and tell them that you are not happy but unless they put it in writing that they would take the car back if the service was not sorted they may try and get away with it. A threat with trading standards may help.

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
Good grief, that is atrocious spelling isn't it? hehe

All I can say is I've been up since 6am, and it's been a long day.

boxedin

LocoBlade

Original Poster:

7,653 posts

287 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
Obviously wouldnt have bought it if I knew then what I do now, we were told it did have FSH and only afterwards has it transpired that this isn't strictly true, or at least can't be proven.

I admit that in an ideal world I should have demanded to see everything at time of collection before signing for the car, but in reality life is never as simple as that! It was a 100 mile e/w trip to pick the car so not a simple matter of popping back the next day, and as said I had no reason to doubt what I had been told. I won't name names but the dealer we purchased from is also a main dealer for several manufacturers, so not a company you'd expect to do something like this.

Edited by LocoBlade on Tuesday 23 March 23:36

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
If I were you, I would ring them up and reject the car wink

Regardless of your legal rights in this situation... that would be my gambit.

FraserLFA

5,083 posts

205 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
hornetrider said:
If I were you, I would ring them up and reject the car wink

Regardless of your legal rights in this situation... that would be my gambit.
clap Well done sir. Mug of Cocoa and off to bed biggrin

falkster

4,258 posts

234 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
The car is not as described!!

How recent is recent?

Take it back and demand your money back, probably won't get you where you want but you'll either get a fully stamped book or some cash back.
You never buy a car without checking it over 100% and the bulk of that is paperwork. Fully stamped book backed up with invoices stating what work was done per stamp.

B17NNS

18,506 posts

278 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
In answer to the original question, I'd consider a full service history as a complete documented history of maintenance and repair work carried out on the vehicle from new.

Usually a stamped service book, backed up by invoices.

Go back to the salesman and kick up a fuss. Chances are it's just laziness and nothing more sinister. Problem being he's cashed your cheque now and really can't be arsed.

LocoBlade

Original Poster:

7,653 posts

287 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
Recent is about 7 weeks ago, we were waiting 3 weeks for the initial documents to come back which turned out to be unaltered, and they've been dragging their heels ever since.

There's slightly more to the story too which may reinforce our position but I didnt want to make the above too (even more!) long winded. Basically the car had a minor electrical fault which left the car lacking in power a bit, but that only became apparent on the lengthy drive home. This left us without the car for nearly a week whilst it was at the local main dealers for warranty work as the part couldnt be sourced immediately. To be fair I wouldnt necessarily have expected the trader to have spotted the issue, but it was still a major inconvenience which they barely apologised for.

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
LocoBlade said:
We raised it with the salesman again and he apologised for the "mix up" and offered to get a new book stamped, but that hasn't materialised either
They already have your cash.

LocoBlade said:
I'm about to write a second complaint letter to the dealer but these seem to fall on deaf ears
They already have your cash.

LocoBlade said:
a major inconvenience which they barely apologised for.
They already have your cash.

You need to get motivated.


Edited by hornetrider on Wednesday 24th March 00:18

grumbledoak

32,571 posts

264 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
hornetrider said:
They already have your cash.
The above is the single most salient point. frown

I'd have a word with the CAB first, with a view to trading standards. You have been remiss; you've basically accepted a car that is not as described. Worse, you've paid and seemingly have no leverage at all.

Check up on your rights to reject the car. Then, phone the dealership fore-armed.

Best of.

pb1695

390 posts

207 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
I would certainly reject the car, we operate a car rental and leasing business and find it incomprehensible that a service history cannot be found. At the very least the "letter" should include the dates and location of the services that were carried out.

As with most other businesses like ours, we remove the service book from the car (in order to ensure they do not go walkabout). Most cars are not kept for more than 12 months so would only have 1 service, however when they are sold we would affix a copy of the service invoice to the service book. This ensures the history (and warranty) is intact.

Where cars are kept for longer periods, it is a little more tricky, however we either print off the service history records from our maintenance system or ask the servicing agents to supply the documentation - most dealers / non franchise agents have systems to do this.

A full service history should be a clear, credible and concise document proving that all routine services have been completed by a competent person as required by the manufacturer. You would have a very strong case from what you have described.


james_tigerwoods

16,347 posts

228 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
I bought my Seat Leon (which I've banged on about before) which was supposed to have had FSH - the trader insisted it did. After many months of contacting them, I spoke to trading standards who gave me some advice which led me to write this:

Letter to the idiot trader said:
I have written to you several times regarding the Seat Leon (xxxx CNN) that you sold me in May requesting the service history, manual and spare key of this vehicle.

I have spoken with Consumer Direct who has given me legal advice as to how to proceed with this matter.

You sold me the Seat Leon stating that this vehicle had full service history – this information was not provided with the car and you stated that it would arrive shortly. This did not and you then claimed to have set about retrieving the history of the vehicle with the alleged intention of passing this history on to myself.

By claiming that you had this service history when you did not places you in breach of the Trade Descriptions Act 1968 Section 1-1a.

You are in breach of Section 13 of the Sales of Goods Act 1979 by not providing me with the items as described.

I am now intending on selling this car and its value is lessened by the lack of this service history (and subsequent spare key and vehicle manual).

Please supply these items as described or provide reparations as I am at a consequential loss due to the Sales of Goods Act breach.

Please respond to this letter within 10 days or this will be referred back to Trading Standards who will then initiate proceedings against you.

I have enclosed the previous letters of correspondence for your reference.
I'm not 100% convinced the legal bits are accurate (waits to be slapped and corrected) but the trader magically turned up the history*, paid for a key and manual.

* I'd already spent several days verifying that the car had FSH anyway as I had some warranty work to be done but I wanted them to cough it up as I'd had enough of their pissing about

POORCARDEALER

8,670 posts

272 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all


We are very hung up about service history is this country....personally I wouldnt have been buying a ex hire car as the abuse it will have had will outweigh the fact its oil changes were or were not on time frown

daemon

40,169 posts

228 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
POORCARDEALER said:
We are very hung up about service history is this country....personally I wouldnt have been buying a ex hire car as the abuse it will have had will outweigh the fact its oil changes were or were not on time frown
Do people not only ever hire cars to try to break land speed records?

Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
When you buy an ex-hire car you want one from a rental company that buys 'em new and runs them to the first service. That way when you get no service history from them it doesn't matter.

Yes a hire car will have been thrashed and yes the alloys will have been dinged because people can't drive and can't park but you are getting a dirt cheap price, usually.

Picked up an 07 Vectra 2.2 SRi Estate in 08 for £6.5K - list was £21. 12K miles. The first service was overdue and they gave me an empty service book. Hey. It was cheap. I serviced it immediately and have since had things done under warranty with no complaints.

Orb the Impaler

1,881 posts

221 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
daemon said:
Do people not only ever hire cars to try to break land speed records?
I don't get this either; I treat a hire car as I would treat my own.

Jem0911

4,415 posts

232 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
I would say what you descibe is (or was when I sold for a car supermarket) commonplace.
FSH needs to be seen, and even checked.