A What car? or Keep what i've got?
Discussion
Morning everyone!
I currently have a mk1 MX-5. It is a joy to drive, thrash and slide around on my daily commute and odd trips in the evenings.
Almost every weekend however, I travel 130 miles back to Essex and return sunday evening. It is safe to say the MX5 isn't well suited to this journey. If I had to do the odd trop it would be fine but every weekend is giving me a headache. I also wonder that with a spangly new motorbike in the garage, will I really be wanting to go out in the MX5 any time the sun shines?
My current idea is to swap it in for something. Once i've sold my old motorbike and the MX5, i'll have about £10k of budget to spend. I don't need to spend it all, and I don't mind stretching a bit with a small loan or a funky finance deal for a rare car that won't lose much value. I pretty much only keep cars for a maximum of a year or so anyway so this shouldn't be a problem. I don't want to buy a new car.
I can only afford to insure one car at a time, so simply getting a shed of a second car for long journeys isn't an option.
My potential solutions have been wild and varied. In no particular order, things that have been considered so far:
I currently have a mk1 MX-5. It is a joy to drive, thrash and slide around on my daily commute and odd trips in the evenings.
Almost every weekend however, I travel 130 miles back to Essex and return sunday evening. It is safe to say the MX5 isn't well suited to this journey. If I had to do the odd trop it would be fine but every weekend is giving me a headache. I also wonder that with a spangly new motorbike in the garage, will I really be wanting to go out in the MX5 any time the sun shines?
My current idea is to swap it in for something. Once i've sold my old motorbike and the MX5, i'll have about £10k of budget to spend. I don't need to spend it all, and I don't mind stretching a bit with a small loan or a funky finance deal for a rare car that won't lose much value. I pretty much only keep cars for a maximum of a year or so anyway so this shouldn't be a problem. I don't want to buy a new car.
I can only afford to insure one car at a time, so simply getting a shed of a second car for long journeys isn't an option.
My potential solutions have been wild and varied. In no particular order, things that have been considered so far:
- Mondeo ST TDCi - I like the look of these, particularly the estate would be really practical and quite good on fuel. I've also seen a couple of white ex-police ones that look quite nice and are slightly cheaper.
- BMW 330D Touring - Same sort of reasons but quicker than the mondeo and slightly better built
- Mini Cooper S - Cheap to insure, quite comfortable, reasonably economical, fun to drive and importantly, means I don't have to buy any diesel.
- Mini Cooper S Works - Not so cheap to insure but a fair bit quicker.
- Jaguar XJ X350 - X350 V8 is looking quite a bargain but the 2.7D is also now down to around £15k
Edited by Chapppers on Wednesday 24th March 12:32
Chapppers said:
Morning everyone!
Not sure I understand this.- Mini Cooper S - Cheap to insure, quite comfortable, reasonably economical, fun to drive and importantly, means I don't have to buy any diesel.
- Mini Cooper S Works - Not so cheap to insure but a fair bit quicker.
A JCW is a Works

Also what gen of MINI are you looking at? The earlier supercharged R53 (up to 2004'ish) is arguably more fun than the latter R56 model.
Also if you plan to mod either would have a huge bearing on it.
The R53 Works/JCW is not much more than a badge engineering job on the regular CS and really isn't worth paying much more for. The R56 JCW on the other hand is very different from the regular CS.
As for what cars, well if you are finding the MX not great for these longer trips, I'm not convinced a MINI will really be much of an improvement. Sure it should be newer and quieter and maybe more comfy. But its still a small, stiffly sprung, high revving, short geared sporting car.
So the next question up, if running costs, or more specifically mpg. I doubt you could really find much more comfort than one of these and it would be the perfect compliment and contrast to a motor bike and an upgrade on an MX5:

It would be the earlier R53 mini. I've been doing some research and from what i've gathered, there are the factory "Mini Cooper S Works" and the "Mini Cooper S" with works pack. The S works has some fancier trim and 210bhp whereas the works pack gives you 197bhp.
This may very well be wrong.
Don't get me wrong, i'm not a wuss. I was doing the journey in a focus RS a few months ago and that was fine, I'd imagine the Mini would ride a bit better than that, specially if I found one with the 16s.
As for running costs, I'm fine with 30mpg (95ron) on motorways but 22.5 from the RS on VPower was starting to sting.
I did wonder about the older XK... I do love the look of them
This may very well be wrong.
Don't get me wrong, i'm not a wuss. I was doing the journey in a focus RS a few months ago and that was fine, I'd imagine the Mini would ride a bit better than that, specially if I found one with the 16s.
As for running costs, I'm fine with 30mpg (95ron) on motorways but 22.5 from the RS on VPower was starting to sting.
I did wonder about the older XK... I do love the look of them

GordonL said:
Mk 2 MX5, especially with the 6 speed box, much better on the motorway than the Mk 1 (at least, mine is!) and just about as good in the twisties. You can pick up a nice one for 3k these days.
Having done extensive miles in both, I'd say that neither are suited to regular motorway trips of 130 miles.For me, it'd be the Cooper S. Either one would be good.
TimmyWimmyWoo said:
Have you considered a V10 Phaeton diesel? Something very oddball but probably an interesting waft-barge.
Don't be stupid, yeah they're built well but if it goes wrong i'll have to remortgage my parents' house shirley?...but they are quite nice. Certainly could see myself in ein Luxurypanzerwagen...
Edited by Chapppers on Wednesday 24th March 16:02
I'm quite a fan of the V10 TDI. But mpg will be around 20-22 iirc. And they can be expensive to maintain, and as reliable as many will have you believe VW's are.
As for the MINI's. I personally think the R53 is the way to go. The Works one did have some changes, but in reality they are all pretty minor and they rigged the dyno test's so it looked like it was making more power.
Essentially for the same or similar money the Works is still a good buy. But if you can get an S for less money it'll likely offer almost identical real world performance and leave money left over should you want to tune it.
Upgrades like LSD, suspension, brakes, seats and such were not standard on the Works, so do watch out for exact spec.
Only differences I know of is, a re-worked cylinder head, which seems to be regarded as pointless as the did a piss poor job of it.
Different blower pulley, but it's only a mid way step up. Swap the pulley on a stock CS and it'll make more power.
And a slightly different air box, which is actually not bad. Intercooler might have been different, but not certain.
There was also a limited edition GP version with horrid looking wheels and door mirrors. It had a few more tweaks (not sure what and was rated at something like 218hp).
The current JCW is rated at 210hp from it's 1.6 turbo motor. This is a very different engine and car from a regular R56 CS. Different block, internals, turbo and an e-diff.
I suppose the question to ask is, what are you after from a car. £10k would buy you a heck of a lot of interesting motorcar these days.
As for the MINI's. I personally think the R53 is the way to go. The Works one did have some changes, but in reality they are all pretty minor and they rigged the dyno test's so it looked like it was making more power.
Essentially for the same or similar money the Works is still a good buy. But if you can get an S for less money it'll likely offer almost identical real world performance and leave money left over should you want to tune it.
Upgrades like LSD, suspension, brakes, seats and such were not standard on the Works, so do watch out for exact spec.
Only differences I know of is, a re-worked cylinder head, which seems to be regarded as pointless as the did a piss poor job of it.
Different blower pulley, but it's only a mid way step up. Swap the pulley on a stock CS and it'll make more power.
And a slightly different air box, which is actually not bad. Intercooler might have been different, but not certain.
There was also a limited edition GP version with horrid looking wheels and door mirrors. It had a few more tweaks (not sure what and was rated at something like 218hp).
The current JCW is rated at 210hp from it's 1.6 turbo motor. This is a very different engine and car from a regular R56 CS. Different block, internals, turbo and an e-diff.
I suppose the question to ask is, what are you after from a car. £10k would buy you a heck of a lot of interesting motorcar these days.
300bhp/ton said:
[lots of interesting stuff about minis]
I suppose the question to ask is, what are you after from a car. £10k would buy you a heck of a lot of interesting motorcar these days.
Ah ok, so you're saying a Cooper S with a few cheeky select mods and I wouldn't need a works anyway?I suppose the question to ask is, what are you after from a car. £10k would buy you a heck of a lot of interesting motorcar these days.
Yeah, this is the thing. The mx5 is a very interesting car, but doesn't suit what I use a car for. I don't know really. As I said, any other suggestions are welcome but most of the interesting stuff seems to put my insurance over £1k
Gassing Station | General Gassing [Archive] | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


