Magistrate's Attitude to Speeding
Magistrate's Attitude to Speeding
Author
Discussion

prubbert

Original Poster:

71 posts

211 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
I was flicking through a CSMA (Civil Service Motoring Association, or something) magazine and there was a letter from a magistrate. I should at this point state that I have nothing to do with the Civil Service or CMSA, the mag was just lying round at work.

Anyhow, this letter was about the use of speed limiters in cars and the magistrate wrote ‘People tell me there may be a need to accelerate out of trouble, but my view is that slowing down is the only way to get out of trouble!.’
This would be a terrible attitude for a ‘normal’ member of the public, but for someone who can pass sentence to have such a poor understanding it terrible.

Has anyone else come across this when they’ve been in from of the beak……


As an aside, there is another letter complaining about the amount being spent on speed cameras which states…’I know this is a little controversial, but is this because of the increase in the number of women drivers?’ Civil servants, got to love em…. laugh

kambites

71,703 posts

252 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
Magistrates are just people. Regardless of this particular instance (and I must admit that I have never had to accelerate to get out of trouble myself, nor seen anyone else put in a situation where they've had to), you can't expect them to know everything about everything.

LuS1fer

43,566 posts

276 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
He or she probably means that it's better to be going slowly to begin with and then slow down even more. It's probably also an indicator that he's heard a load of crap defences along these lines and is fed up with them and has no intention of paying them any heed.

As with most b*llsh*t defences, the majority spoil it for the few who might actually be legitimate and have a point - the failing to provide the identity of the driver being a classic case in point as it relies on the Post Office failing to deliver a high proportion of NIPS but still deliver all the normal post. Similarly, the number of "emergencies" arising every day that causes people to jump red lights and speed is reaching epidemic proportions.... wink

D18OCK

826 posts

223 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
Magistrates are by the very definition lay people and don't worry they have a legal adviser to point them to the law before they consider sentances!

He is no different to any other person then, in having this opinion and lets be honest if you are driving sensibly you are less likely to get into the trouble in the first place and even if you do 'need to' accelerate you still won't be breaking the law!

So are you questioning the justice system or the opinion that accelerating to get out of trouble is a good idea?

Robert060379

15,754 posts

214 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
Guilty until proven innocent. No mitigation. No Excuses. If you are caught speeding you are a menace to society and would get the death penalty if it was allowed. Most Magistrates still remember the guy with the red flag that had to walk in front of you and think the world was a better place before the great war.

prubbert

Original Poster:

71 posts

211 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
I agree that the likelihood that you would get caught and end up in court in due to accelerating out of trouble is highly remote. However, she comments that 'People tell me there may be a need to accelerate out of trouble' and dismisses this because her view is that you can only get out of trouble by slowing down.

I understand that they are lay people but if you informed of a mitigating situation (for whatever offence) wouldn't you consider your current position?

mat205125

17,790 posts

244 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
kambites said:
Magistrates are just people. Regardless of this particular instance (and I must admit that I have never had to accelerate to get out of trouble myself, nor seen anyone else put in a situation where they've had to), you can't expect them to know everything about everything.
I've often been thankful of a bit of BHP to be able to accerate clear of a slower vehicle on a dual carriageway, to enable them to pull out to allow another to merge safely. I've also enjoyed a bit of power to minimise my TED (time exposed to danger) when passing a number of slower cars.

In both scenarios I could have slowed, or remained in convoy, and eliminated the need for power/acceleration. Also, in both instances I may have sneaked past the posted limit for a couple of seconds.

If someone wants to trundle along at 40mph everywhere, then let them, however don't eliminate my ability to pass them safely and cleanly by installing a system that will lunge me forward in my seat I hit an invisible speed barrier preventing a clean and safe overtake .... no doubt whilst the vehicle I am passing has now floored their accelerator, as many seem to.

I await the "If you need to exceed the limit, then the opportunity wasn't big enough!" brigade, and don't completely disagree, however I live in reality, and am a sane and sensible intelligent animal that can exercise judgement beyond the what might be written on a circular signpost to cater for all cars/drivers/ages/experiences/weathers and conditions.

Rawwr

22,722 posts

265 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
Meh, in 2007 I went to court because of an off-duty policeman telling porkies. There was no evidence on his part, no witnesses, 'missing' 999 calls and we had evidence which showed two important physical impossibilities in his statement which proved he wasn't telling the truth, this was accompanied by statements by qualified advanced driving and riding instructors about my standards and attitude.

I got a CD10, 3 points, £250 fine, £800 costs and £2,000 legal fees for my trouble. Since then, I've rather strangely had very, very, very little respect for both the police or courts.

So, even if you can prove way beyond reasonable doubt that you're innocent, just plead guilty because in the end it'll save you time and money.

/bitter

PHmember

2,487 posts

202 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
mat205125 said:
kambites said:
Magistrates are just people. Regardless of this particular instance (and I must admit that I have never had to accelerate to get out of trouble myself, nor seen anyone else put in a situation where they've had to), you can't expect them to know everything about everything.
I've often been thankful of a bit of BHP to be able to accerate clear of a slower vehicle on a dual carriageway, to enable them to pull out to allow another to merge safely. I've also enjoyed a bit of power to minimise my TED (time exposed to danger) when passing a number of slower cars.

In both scenarios I could have slowed, or remained in convoy, and eliminated the need for power/acceleration. Also, in both instances I may have sneaked past the posted limit for a couple of seconds.

If someone wants to trundle along at 40mph everywhere, then let them, however don't eliminate my ability to pass them safely and cleanly by installing a system that will lunge me forward in my seat I hit an invisible speed barrier preventing a clean and safe overtake .... no doubt whilst the vehicle I am passing has now floored their accelerator, as many seem to.

I await the "If you need to exceed the limit, then the opportunity wasn't big enough!" brigade, and don't completely disagree, however I live in reality, and am a sane and sensible intelligent animal that can exercise judgement beyond the what might be written on a circular signpost to cater for all cars/drivers/ages/experiences/weathers and conditions.
Ding! Spot on. It's a real world out there, not a perfect one.

mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

286 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
Rawwr said:
Meh

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
PHmember said:
mat205125 said:
I await the "If you need to exceed the limit, then the opportunity wasn't big enough!" brigade, and don't completely disagree, however I live in reality, and am a sane and sensible intelligent animal that can exercise judgement beyond the what might be written on a circular signpost to cater for all cars/drivers/ages/experiences/weathers and conditions.
Ding! Spot on. It's a real world out there, not a perfect one.
It is a real world out there & the possibility of points/fine are in the equation when you exercise your judgement.

mattviatura

2,996 posts

231 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
About 20 years ago someone I know was driving across a narrow bridge when some poor guy in a large truck died at the wheel, causing his truck to slide and roll at the exact moment she was passing. If she hadn't floored her MR2 she'd have been killed. Luckily for her the truck only caught the back of her car, writing it off.

Speed doesn't always kill.


mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

286 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
Very few people possess the skill and understanding to drive well...

Magistrates constitute a tiny proportion of the population.

It follows that few, if any, have a clue about driving.

Judges, too...

Listening to some of the things they say in Court, an alien would be excused for thinking your bowels melt at 100mph.

So the comment you mention is to be expected...




PS....what's wrong with the CSMA...?

dnb

3,330 posts

273 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
I've always looked on the "accelerating out of trouble" as the safer option:

I generally look out of the window in the direction I am travelling, so I have the best visibility of the situation in that direction and if I'm going to get closer to these things, I really want to know as much as possible about what they're up to. So acceleration can easily be the option with least unknowns and therefore can be the safest and best option to keep the traffic flowing.

Compare this with braking: I have up to 3 small mirrors, which I check every few seconds while driving. I have at best a collection of snapshots about what's going on behind me. Why would I risk getting closer to these things if I didn't have to?

Personally, I think magistrates delivering "justice" on road traffic law should at the least hold an advanced driving qualification of some kind (RoSPA's one is my choice - 3 yearly retests...)

flemke

23,515 posts

268 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
kambites said:
Magistrates are just people. Regardless of this particular instance (and I must admit that I have never had to accelerate to get out of trouble myself, nor seen anyone else put in a situation where they've had to), you can't expect them to know everything about everything.
Genuine question: does anyone here know what % of the cases that are dealt with by magistrates are motoring-related?

kbf1981

2,351 posts

231 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
kambites said:
Magistrates are just people. Regardless of this particular instance (and I must admit that I have never had to accelerate to get out of trouble myself, nor seen anyone else put in a situation where they've had to), you can't expect them to know everything about everything.
I exited a blind opening the other day. When you exit, you can't *really* see what's coming very well, least not if it's further than 30 yards away.

Normally you're fine, but this time a car was coming and I didn't see it. You couldn't have. Anyways, I accelerated swiftly to ensure he didn't have to slam the breaks on or go into the back of me.

kambites

71,703 posts

252 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
flemke said:
kambites said:
Magistrates are just people. Regardless of this particular instance (and I must admit that I have never had to accelerate to get out of trouble myself, nor seen anyone else put in a situation where they've had to), you can't expect them to know everything about everything.
Genuine question: does anyone here know what % of the cases that are dealt with by magistrates are motoring-related?
This site appears to contain spreadsheets with the information, but I don't have an office package installed on this computer:

http://www.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/crimstats05.html#...

kambites

71,703 posts

252 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
And by the way, I wasn't attempting to claim that such situations don't exist. Just that I've never seen one.

Put it this way. I am far more likely to have an accident in the Elise than in the OH's Punto. hehe

Edited by kambites on Wednesday 24th March 17:51

prubbert

Original Poster:

71 posts

211 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
mybrainhurts said:
Very few people possess the skill and understanding to drive well...

Magistrates constitute a tiny proportion of the population.

It follows that few, if any, have a clue about driving.

Judges, too...

Listening to some of the things they say in Court, an alien would be excused for thinking your bowels melt at 100mph.

So the comment you mention is to be expected...




PS....what's wrong with the CSMA...?
Never heard of CSMA before this and not saying anything is wrong. We did laugh about the women drivers letter though.

flemke

23,515 posts

268 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
kambites said:
flemke said:
kambites said:
Magistrates are just people. Regardless of this particular instance (and I must admit that I have never had to accelerate to get out of trouble myself, nor seen anyone else put in a situation where they've had to), you can't expect them to know everything about everything.
Genuine question: does anyone here know what % of the cases that are dealt with by magistrates are motoring-related?
This site appears to contain spreadsheets with the information, but I don't have an office package installed on this computer:

http://www.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/crimstats05.html#...
I don't know what some of the abbreviations mean, but it appears that, for '05, mags courts heard 834k summary motoring offences, 636k summary non-motoring offences, and 423k indictable offences.