Insurance claim against myself! Anyone had to do similar?
Insurance claim against myself! Anyone had to do similar?
Author
Discussion

Golden fleece

Original Poster:

362 posts

201 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
I stupidly backed my Golf into the front of my 911 while parking outside my house yesterday! There's not much damage to the Golf, but there's some cracked and damaged paint to the front bumper of my Porsche that will have to be repaired - front end repray would be needed I think.

Both cars are insured through the same brokers, but with different insurance companies. The Golf has full NCD (bonus protected), so I'm planning to claim on the Golf's policy and get the Porsche repaired. Think the excess is about £250.

Any problems with doing this?

Thanks in advance for all input guys!!

mat205125

17,790 posts

244 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
I bet the Porshe will look great with the stone chips repaired. Top plan! wink

Munter

31,331 posts

272 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
Have you got a quote to fix the paint without claiming? Assuming your excess is at least £250 if the spray job comes in under £500 I'd pay out of pocket and never mention it again.

LRdriver II

1,936 posts

280 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
So the 911 drove into you from behind huh?... remember to claim whiplash as well.
And get ready as BOTH your premiums will rise next year

falkster

4,258 posts

234 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
Amazing!!! Could nearly be classed as insurance fraud. Small scuff on the bumper results in a front end respray!
Fingers crossed for you.

sday12

5,068 posts

242 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
falkster said:
Amazing!!! Could nearly be classed as insurance fraud. Small scuff on the bumper results in a front end respray!
Fingers crossed for you.
You may be better off paying for it yourself because of this.

redstu

2,287 posts

270 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
Munter said:
Have you got a quote to fix the paint without claiming? Assuming your excess is at least £250 if the spray job comes in under £500 I'd pay out of pocket and never mention it again.
too late for that! You now have to admit to your accident to both insurers, so that they can put up your premiums to try to discourage you from doing it again! Don't try to cover it secretaryup as they have spies everywhere! However you might get away with it, considering that the number of fraudulent multiple accident claims that they don't seem to spot.

If it was my car I'd just get it fixed and not bother the insurance co.

ChasW

2,163 posts

233 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
I did the same thing backing a people carrier into a sports car. About the most sickening feeling I have ever had. My sports car was in the blind spot of the 7 seater. Made a claim. Lesson I learned is that parking sensors are a must on people carriers.

Daston

6,154 posts

234 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
Talking of this sort of thing, what happens if you have an accident repairing a car. For example say it fell off axle stands or a shelf fell down in the garage. Would insurance cover you?

Golden fleece

Original Poster:

362 posts

201 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
Thanks for the input so far guys! I'm not looking to do anything illegal - so that's my question - why would this be classed as insurance fraud, as it's a genuine accident, it's just that both cars are mine?!

I agree that the premium on the Golf is then likely to go up - so probably not worthwhile for £400/£500 worth of damage.

The insurance excess is £200.


bigdods

7,175 posts

258 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
Golden fleece said:
I agree that the premium on the Golf is then likely to go up
Even if you have protected no claims discount the premium will go up at renewal as you are now an increased risk. If you dont have protected no claims it will go up a lot as you will lose a few years of your discount.

The insurance on any other cars you own will also go up as you now have a fault accident against you which must be reported to all insurers.

This is why many people pay out of their own pockets for minor bumps even when insured fully comp.

Torquey

1,961 posts

259 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
That's how house insurance works if you have an accident.
I don't see the problem but I'd probably think twice if you can get it done for less than £700.

ZOLLAR

19,920 posts

204 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
Hey op just had a quick chat regarding this situation with collegues and manager, response i got from manager about whether telling insurance about the accident if you dont claim was "They should tell the insurer but if they have any sense they won't" hehe, IMO best to fix your self and not hassle your self with increase in premiums, excesses etc etc. hope that helps!.

falkster

4,258 posts

234 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
It would also mean both premiums go up regardless of which policy you claim on.

Golden fleece

Original Poster:

362 posts

201 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
Thanks for all the advice and opinions, guys! Think I'll get it fixed myself without involving any insurance companies. Less hassle that way it seems. smile