I hate doing this... What Car? Boring alert.
I hate doing this... What Car? Boring alert.
Author
Discussion

topless_mx5

Original Poster:

2,763 posts

249 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
My sister is looking for a car to replace her troublesome Seat Leon which has resulted in one big bill after another.

The criteria is as follows:
Budget - £2000-3000
Size - either same as the Leon or slightly bigger
Fuel - any but if petrol 1.6 or 1.8 preferred as they do a fair few miles
Criteria - the aim of this car is to get them from A to B in the most reliable way, it must be as cheap to run as possible

The only car I can think of is a Focus. Anyone have any other ideas? Astra's are too unreliable IMO, Civic will be the old old shape in that price range, don't want anything from the VAG as this has proved to be unreliable.

TheD

3,144 posts

230 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
Primera

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
Honda Civic 1.6

Oops just read it propely.... How about an Almera?

Edited by anonymous-user on Thursday 25th March 20:58

Steve Smith

1,436 posts

204 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
I suspect you have just had a bad one, generally most cars are very reliable these days, in my experience most unreliability comes from poor servcing, poor quality parts or driver abuse.

I am talking generally speaking. If you were to buy another Astra or Leon i am sure it would be fine. I can honestly say in the 13 years i have been driving i have only broken down once caused by a simple problem. Wife too has never broken down and same goes for my parents with the one exception of a head gasket on a old renault 18 in the 1980's.

topless_mx5

Original Poster:

2,763 posts

249 months

Thursday 25th March 2010
quotequote all
Steve Smith said:
I suspect you have just had a bad one, generally most cars are very reliable these days, in my experience most unreliability comes from poor servcing, poor quality parts or driver abuse.

I am talking generally speaking. If you were to buy another Astra or Leon i am sure it would be fine. I can honestly say in the 13 years i have been driving i have only broken down once caused by a simple problem. Wife too has never broken down and same goes for my parents with the one exception of a head gasket on a old renault 18 in the 1980's.
To be honest I agree they have been unlucky with it. They drive it with a great deal of mechanical sympathy. The bits that have gone have been things like a full exhaust recently, electrical issues, and now an ABS problem which may cost hundreds just to diagnose.

I'm thinking something cheap and cheerful will be best.

Hub

7,171 posts

229 months

Friday 26th March 2010
quotequote all
For that price you can't buy reliability for certain, and it could be luck of the draw again. However the Focus is a reasonable bet, and should be cheap to run (1.6 not 1.8)

MG511

1,754 posts

272 months

Friday 26th March 2010
quotequote all
Nissan Almera. I've had mine 8 years, once had to pay £40 to get the drivers side window 'unstuck', apart from that routine items (tyres, pads, filters, battery) only, never failed to start, no strange noises, just 100% reliable.