Removing LPG
Author
Discussion

PetrolHeadSeb

Original Poster:

368 posts

200 months

Friday 26th March 2010
quotequote all
I'm currently looking at buying a Saxo VTS as a second / track car. I've just realised that one which I'm planning to go and see tomorrow has been LPG converted?! I've never had / driven an LPG car before but I'm not exactly a fan of it so was wondering what would be involved in getting rid of it, or would it just be best to completely avoid the car? I don't really want to have extra weight on the car!

sherman

15,338 posts

246 months

Friday 26th March 2010
quotequote all
Run away.

Why would you want to add all that extra weight to an already reasonably economical car.

Hedders

24,460 posts

278 months

Friday 26th March 2010
quotequote all
I would have thought you could get one without LPG for quite a but less!


ZesPak

26,164 posts

227 months

Friday 26th March 2010
quotequote all
How old is the LPG tank/system?
I can imagine it could still have some value...

Otherwise, run away! You will pay premium for the LPG and have the bother of removing it.

PetrolHeadSeb

Original Poster:

368 posts

200 months

Friday 26th March 2010
quotequote all
It's actually priced fairly competitively. Not sure how old it is / when it was fitted at the moment. Going to try and find out more from the owner today. If it's cheap / easy to get rid of then I'd probably buy it, but something seems wrong about it being there in the first place. Still can't understand why you'd do it to a Saxo VTS...

thinfourth2

32,414 posts

235 months

Friday 26th March 2010
quotequote all
Yes why would you want to run a car on really cheap 110octane fuel

entwisi

728 posts

222 months

Friday 26th March 2010
quotequote all
depends on teh type of system,

rem oving the tank shoudl be quite easy ( make sure its empty and assume its still got some gas in so vent it somewhere outside and windy and make sure you don't spark anything whilst it goes.

if its a mixer system then you just have an inline mixer that looks like a metal colar about 2 -3 " long. there will also be a vapourisor and potentially some electronics that emulate to teh ECU

Injection systems are more complex again

In all I wouldn't recommend DIY unless you are comfortable messing with electronics.

However, the only 'heavy' bit of the LPG is the tank so why not keep it and enjoy your track time at a lower petrol cost? BY teh time you strip the car of all unneccessary fluff you probably won;t be much different with or without it

Greg_D

6,542 posts

277 months

Friday 26th March 2010
quotequote all
what's the mileage? did they do it because they pounded the motorways with it, if you do go and look at it, make sure that you can verify the mileage to your satisfaction.

TBH, there are lots of cars available, why go for possible trouble

greg

PetrolHeadSeb

Original Poster:

368 posts

200 months

Friday 26th March 2010
quotequote all
It's an 03 plate with 82K on it, so it's slightly high for it's year, but not massively high in general, it's only had 2 owners so should be able to verify everything fairly easily. Thing is, I get that if the tank's empty it won't weight much and that if I want to use it it's cheap etc, etc. But I don't know anything about LPG and as I'm dubious about it, I reckon I'll have problems pushing it on again so I might go and look at it, but I suspect I'll give it a miss.

mcdjl

5,766 posts

226 months

Friday 26th March 2010
quotequote all
Or look at it this way: when you get to the track you'll have twice as much fuel for hooning round with and it'll cost you less. The tank often goes where the spare wheel would so often you don't lose much boot space though you'd need to look at the weight depending on how fast you want to go.

PetrolHeadSeb

Original Poster:

368 posts

200 months

Friday 26th March 2010
quotequote all
Very true, although I've got to consider servicing the LPG system, not sure how much that'd cost. But bottom line is, if you were looking for a cheap hatch for a bit of fun and to chuck around a track, would you buy one with an LPG conversion?

ZesPak

26,164 posts

227 months

Friday 26th March 2010
quotequote all
PetrolHeadSeb said:
Very true, although I've got to consider servicing the LPG system, not sure how much that'd cost. But bottom line is, if you were looking for a cheap hatch for a bit of fun and to chuck around a track, would you buy one with an LPG conversion?
confused
Did you just answer your own question?

PetrolHeadSeb

Original Poster:

368 posts

200 months

Friday 26th March 2010
quotequote all
ZesPak said:
confused
Did you just answer your own question?
Ummm, wobble I guess so. Oh well, looks like it's back to the search again for me!

If only there were more of these cars in the Norwich / East Anglia region...

louismchuge

1,644 posts

215 months

Friday 26th March 2010
quotequote all
dont some lpg systems have a cut out safety system if you have a slight bump? That wouldn't be too handy for track work

RV8

1,570 posts

202 months

Friday 26th March 2010
quotequote all
I can't see the problem myself. It competitively priced, the fuel is cheap so it would make for a cheap hobby as you could drive around a track all day for around half the cost of petrol.
If you wanted to loose the weight then you may need a new inlet manifold depending on how it's plumbed in = sell LPG system and buy throttle bodies / Or were you just thinking of a standard-ish car? Or are you competing? if not why are you worried about a little more weight, just carry a jerry can of fuel and don't fill the petrol tank?

PetrolHeadSeb

Original Poster:

368 posts

200 months

Friday 26th March 2010
quotequote all
Basically I'm just looking for a second car to use for a few track days. I've got about £1500 to spend and I'm looking for something new enough to not need too much work doing to get it ready. I'm thinking a VTS as they're cheap to buy, run, repair and tune, plus I had one about 5 years ago so know a bit about them.

I was trying to get a standard(ish) one with a view to gradually doing some gentle tuning on it. I don't know a lot about LPG, how it will affect the car's performance, what extra servicing costs it'll bring or what might go wrong with it. It's the concern of the unknown really.

Interestingly though, looks like Tom Chiltern's BTCC Focus is going to be running LPG this year.
http://www.autosport.com/news/report.php/id/82231

Greg_D

6,542 posts

277 months

Friday 26th March 2010
quotequote all
thinfourth2 said:
Yes why would you want to run a car on really cheap 110octane fuel
I may be way out here, but i understood that LPG has a lower energy density than petrol, and thus a lower power output like for like, not higher.

Greg

OnTheOverrun

3,965 posts

208 months

Friday 26th March 2010
quotequote all
If you just run it on lpg and remove the petrol tank, it will only weigh a tiny bit more and then you have the huge advantages of 114 octane fuel in a tuned car with heavily advanced ignition producing lots of power for the track. . . . . .

thinfourth2

32,414 posts

235 months

Friday 26th March 2010
quotequote all
Greg_D said:
thinfourth2 said:
Yes why would you want to run a car on really cheap 110octane fuel
I may be way out here, but i understood that LPG has a lower energy density than petrol, and thus a lower power output like for like, not higher.

Greg
Yep 100% correct

But as octane rating goes up you can run far higher compression ratios which means you can get more fuel and air in to burn therefore MORE power

If you build the engine to take advantage of this you are laughing

OnTheOverrun

3,965 posts

208 months

Friday 26th March 2010
quotequote all
Greg_D said:
thinfourth2 said:
Yes why would you want to run a car on really cheap 110octane fuel
I may be way out here, but i understood that LPG has a lower energy density than petrol, and thus a lower power output like for like, not higher.

Greg
It does, but much higher octane. On my V8 performance on lpg was slightly down on petrol when both were running petrol ignition settings. When an automatic ignition advance box was added to advance the ignition by 16 degrees (IIRC) performance on lpg was now noticeably superior to petrol. I suspect a correctly setup engine running on LPG would really suit a track car.