6k to spend. Alternatives to a BMW 330/530?
Discussion
Ok, So I have some cash and I want to buy a car that's fast, handles well but is also comfortable. I have a budget of around £6k
I've owned an E39 530 sport in the past and know this ticks all the boxes and I've test driven a 330 so I know this does too. However finding a decent manual 530 is hard work and looks wise the E46 fails to excite me.
I test drove a SAAB 9-3 Aero and although it was fast the steering feel wasn't great, the interior trim was cheap and the E39 is simply a better drivers car IMHO.
So what other alternatives are there?
Audis seem a little bit bland, The jag X type seems a bit old man and the C class is apparently not good in terms of reliability and build quality.
I could stretch to an 03 blob eye scooby WRX but not sure about the image.
£6k will get me into a decent E36 M3 but the running costs do concern me and once the miles rack up the reliability could be an issue.
I've seen some Alpina alternatives but for my budget your scraping the bottom of the barrel.
So if it was your money what would you buy?
I've owned an E39 530 sport in the past and know this ticks all the boxes and I've test driven a 330 so I know this does too. However finding a decent manual 530 is hard work and looks wise the E46 fails to excite me.
I test drove a SAAB 9-3 Aero and although it was fast the steering feel wasn't great, the interior trim was cheap and the E39 is simply a better drivers car IMHO.
So what other alternatives are there?
Audis seem a little bit bland, The jag X type seems a bit old man and the C class is apparently not good in terms of reliability and build quality.
I could stretch to an 03 blob eye scooby WRX but not sure about the image.
£6k will get me into a decent E36 M3 but the running costs do concern me and once the miles rack up the reliability could be an issue.
I've seen some Alpina alternatives but for my budget your scraping the bottom of the barrel.
So if it was your money what would you buy?
E46 330i M Sport coupe. Looks a bit nicer than the saloon. Loads of space for two kids in the back and a big boot.
156 GTA
I think the 6 cylinder B10 E39 Alpinas are attainable in your budget.
Impreza WRX wagon. IMHO these don't have as much of an image problem. Crap interiors though.
Audi S4 B5. Lot of car for the money.
If it were me though I'd have a 4-5k E36 M3 saloon and keep the rest as a safety net fund. Don't think they are horrendous to run.
156 GTA
I think the 6 cylinder B10 E39 Alpinas are attainable in your budget.
Impreza WRX wagon. IMHO these don't have as much of an image problem. Crap interiors though.
Audi S4 B5. Lot of car for the money.
If it were me though I'd have a 4-5k E36 M3 saloon and keep the rest as a safety net fund. Don't think they are horrendous to run.
Edited by mat59 on Friday 26th March 19:49
I do like the idea of an E36 M3. To be honest though it's an old car with lots of miles and if something does go wronmg it could effectively scrap the car. Still it's a possibility.
MGZT, no thanks.
530i is what I was after but I want a manual and they're like hens teath. 535/540 manual even more so.
My E39 was the best car I have ever owned.
Had an Accord Type-R before the E39 and it was fabulous for those times when the sun was shining, the road ahead was clear and you were just out for a drive. However for the daily comute and times when there were passengers in the car was very compromised. Lacking torque, noisey, unrefined and tiring to drive.
Alpina's are like manual 530s, not enough around. Also for my budget it's going to be a high miler.
S4 for 6k, again it will be very leggy and Audis are just a bit dull.
Alfa GTA. Not sure i'd get one on my budget and I have grave reservations about the quality.
MGZT, no thanks.
530i is what I was after but I want a manual and they're like hens teath. 535/540 manual even more so.
My E39 was the best car I have ever owned.
Had an Accord Type-R before the E39 and it was fabulous for those times when the sun was shining, the road ahead was clear and you were just out for a drive. However for the daily comute and times when there were passengers in the car was very compromised. Lacking torque, noisey, unrefined and tiring to drive.
Alpina's are like manual 530s, not enough around. Also for my budget it's going to be a high miler.
S4 for 6k, again it will be very leggy and Audis are just a bit dull.
Alfa GTA. Not sure i'd get one on my budget and I have grave reservations about the quality.
Edited by Devil2575 on Friday 26th March 22:36
Some to consider:
Galant/legnum VR4
http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/sales/1449590.htm
Accord Type-R
http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/sales/1530136.htm
Scooby bug-eye Wagon
http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/sales/1593035.htm
Legacy B4
http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/sales/1486382.htm
Audi S4 Avant
http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/sales/1527329.htm
Lots of cars that are very quick, in budget and easily fit more than one child with pushchair etc.
Edit to add - I didn't read your last post before writing this. Sorry.
Galant/legnum VR4
http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/sales/1449590.htm
Accord Type-R
http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/sales/1530136.htm
Scooby bug-eye Wagon
http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/sales/1593035.htm
Legacy B4
http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/sales/1486382.htm
Audi S4 Avant
http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/sales/1527329.htm
Lots of cars that are very quick, in budget and easily fit more than one child with pushchair etc.
Edit to add - I didn't read your last post before writing this. Sorry.
Edited by spanna123 on Friday 26th March 22:48
Devil2575 said:
Has anyone driven an X-type? Are they any good.
My missus has a diesel X-type estate sport, and it's a nice drive, steers nicely and feels pretty composed doing 10mph more everywhere round the twisties than me Golf (TDI SE). Wish now we had gone for the 3.0 AWD, as she doesn't actually do that many miles. The diesel is decent (for a diesel), but two diesels in the house is just too much these days as we don't get out on 2wheels enough anymore!
3.0 Premium Sport next time.
A 330Ci would be ideal, but the X-type (especially in estate form) is so much more practical.
Gassing Station | General Gassing [Archive] | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff





