Mystery Misfire
Author
Discussion

freakynessless

Original Poster:

473 posts

213 months

Saturday 27th March 2010
quotequote all
Any advice would be greatfully appreciated...

Mk4 golf 1.8T 2000 82K - Mrs left work yesterday reporting heavy vibrations in the car, down on power, cutting out and juddering.
Called out the AA who diagnosed a misfire in the third cylinder and more than likely a faulty coilpack. This morning I changed the coil pack, no joy. Then changed the spark plug, no joy - the old spark came out looking like a 40,000 mile old spark plug should do.
Then swapped the coil pack and spark plug from the first and third cylinder. The first cylinder worked fine with the coil and spark plug from the third cylinder, but the third cylinder still didnt work using the coil and spark from the fist cylinder.
Then stuck a volt meter on to the end of the HT lead (if thats what its called!? - the plug that you plug the coil pack into) and the reading was the same as all the others. Starting to get frustrated now.
I then checked the inlet manifold for air leaks but found nothing. Then thought that it might be a sticky injector so I took it for a hard run down the road to see if it would clear. After getting above 3500 RPM it seems to be okay and pulls normally but once your back down to the bottom end of the rev range its still miss firing. I then pulled out the injectors and swaped them over and still no difference at all. Finally as a last resort, I then turned the engine over while holding cylinder three spark plug and coil pack out of the engine to see if there was a spark. There was nothing.
The only other thing I can come up with would be an ECU fault.

Anyone got any ideas???

Thanks in advance


blaineuk

2,615 posts

278 months

Saturday 27th March 2010
quotequote all
have you got a ecu light on, wifes beetle had similar symptoms when the oxygen sensor went, was the plug clse to engine when you had it out to check.

Rich_W

12,548 posts

243 months

Saturday 27th March 2010
quotequote all
I'd be looking at a compression check next. Though I appreciate you may not have a tester.

*Al*

3,830 posts

253 months

Saturday 27th March 2010
quotequote all
I had this before, misfiring so i changed coil pack, plugs.Cut a long story short it was the injector.To diagnose put a volt meter across the injector terminals (engine not running). The injector with the fault gave a completely different reading to the other 3 (4 cyclinder engine)

wolf1

3,103 posts

281 months

Saturday 27th March 2010
quotequote all
I would say there's a break in the wiring for number 3 cylinder coil pack or a bad connection at a multiplug or the ecu. The vibrations when over 3500rpm may be just enough for it to make contact.

freakynessless

Original Poster:

473 posts

213 months

Saturday 27th March 2010
quotequote all
blaineuk said:
have you got a ecu light on, wifes beetle had similar symptoms when the oxygen sensor went, was the plug clse to engine when you had it out to check.
strangely, no dash lights at all. Not even an oxygen warning light/lambda sensor warning.