Running on 7cyls with added hammering noises...
Running on 7cyls with added hammering noises...
Author
Discussion

speedtwelve

Original Poster:

3,547 posts

304 months

Monday 12th April 2010
quotequote all
Drove my 46k mile Chim 400 to work this morning. Midway through the journey I realised it started running on only 7 cyls; exhaust note 'offbeat' and out-of-balance vibration when parked at idle. At high engine loads there's also a metallic knocking/hammering that sounds like big-end bearing failure but a bit lighter and more 'tappety' (yet still bloody loud). This rattle is engine load/throttle dependant and is not related to revs. I could take the car to high revs but light load and it felt and sounded fine, but give it more gas and the knocking starts and stops with throttle presses. Oil press & temp is fine, I haven't lost any fluids.

I initially thought it might be a localised exhaust gasket/manifold failure, giving a raspy rattle at high gas flow pressure/speed, but why running on only 7? Spark plug semi-backed out giving a loss of compression, and noise when gas leaking past the gap? Rocker failure? Why if it is a valve-gear failure would the noise only come at high throttle/engine load settings as opposed to just high rpms?

Any advice would be gratefully received!

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Monday 12th April 2010
quotequote all
Plug lead come loose?

Simple checks first - the exhaust manifold on the miscreant cylinder wont be as hot as the other 7...

darkcat

2,354 posts

201 months

Tuesday 13th April 2010
quotequote all
i had this, was a lead not on properly. I wouldnt suggest touching the exhaust manifolds to find out which it is!!! (use an IR thermometer, about £10 from maplins)

haircutmike

22,511 posts

235 months

Tuesday 13th April 2010
quotequote all
Rattly under load is pre-ignition, (pinking).

Get your ignition timing checked as it will only cause damage!

Pull of the plug extenders one at a time with an insulated pair of pliers to isolate The non igniter!

HCM.


JKY

358 posts

223 months

Tuesday 13th April 2010
quotequote all
You can sometimes get piston slap on a cylinder that is not firing.

Edited by JKY on Tuesday 13th April 16:37

speedtwelve

Original Poster:

3,547 posts

304 months

Tuesday 13th April 2010
quotequote all
Thanks for all the replies, chaps.

Peter, I don't think it's pinking I hear, it's more a loud, hard-edged mechanical clatter that sounds ominously like it may be a conrod bearing, yet seems to be slightly louder from the driver's side bank. Any pinking I've heard before was more a ticking or tinkling. It actually sounds similar to the problem you're encountering on your own Chim at the moment.

I may be able to blag an IR spot-temp doofer at work to check for a non-firing cyl without going on a plug-lead pulling frenzy. I'll try and isolate an ignition fault first then take things from there.

only me

353 posts

300 months

Wednesday 14th April 2010
quotequote all
I hope not, but sounds like a cracked piston ?

speedtwelve

Original Poster:

3,547 posts

304 months

Wednesday 14th April 2010
quotequote all
Wouldn't a cracked piston cause large amounts of oil smoke out the back? Exhaust is clean, and there's no oil or coolant disappeared anywhere. Yet...!

Probably won't have time to investigate further until Friday.

only me

353 posts

300 months

Wednesday 14th April 2010
quotequote all
Could be any number of things but what you describe sounds very much like what happened to me about 7 years ago, it did not smoke just rattled/knocked loud under load, did not seem to loose much power either and to be honest i could not say it made it run lumpy and stopped it firing just made the noise you describe, was sorted by David Batty who noticed wear on bottom shells as well, has been fantastic ever since!! (but was a cracked piston). But could be caused by any of the other posts as well, dont think i would want to drive it until i knew for sure though !!!

Edited by only me on Wednesday 14th April 19:35

rev-erend

21,624 posts

315 months

Wednesday 14th April 2010
quotequote all
My money is on a slipper liner.

Do a compression and leak down test.

roysum

961 posts

220 months

Wednesday 14th April 2010
quotequote all
haircutmike said:
Rattly under load is pre-ignition, (pinking).

Get your ignition timing checked as it will only cause damage!

Pull of the plug extenders one at a time with an insulated pair of pliers to isolate The non igniter!

HCM.
Pinking, I bet he wishes !

Edited by roysum on Wednesday 14th April 21:11

Barreti

6,689 posts

268 months

Wednesday 14th April 2010
quotequote all
My money would be on a duff HT lead or a plug extender.

Don't be a poof, start the car and wiggle each lead in turn. If its a duff lead it'll soon find you.
If you don't have curly hair after checking the leads, pull them off in turn and see if the car runs noticibly worse when the lead is removed you've found the extender or plug thats knacked.

It all warms up quickly, so don't piss around, and take the opportunity when you get zapped to practice your dad-dancing. Its loads of fun biggrin

Bensonv8

470 posts

240 months

Wednesday 14th April 2010
quotequote all
The first thing i would do is remove the spark plugs looking for damage or a different colour.

If you start it from cold and let run for 10 - 15 seconds, you should be able to tell which exhaust manifold is NOT getting hot (indicating the faulty cylinder, assuming 1 is not firing) with out too much risk of burning the skin off your hands.

Camshaft wear ??
mine almost completely wore away one lobe so that the exhaust valve hardly opened.
Under light load the small valve opening was just enough to run ok'ish.
But under heavy load it soon started complain.
When i tried to drive it under load, it sounded like it was pinking except 50 time worse with a metallic sound to it.
It went from
"not running very well" and bad pinking!! under load at 5k rpm.
to
"barely runs at all" and bad pinking!! under load at less than 2k rpm.
in just a couple of weeks of daily use.

Or possibly, you have a rocker arm that has lost the steel pad that pushed the valve down, which sound like hammering noise you mentioned and if the steel pad found it's way past a valve it would of pinged around the cylinder until it hits the spark plug.

i hope it's not either of these, but i think they are worth considering.
good luck
Steve

edited so it makes sense, hopefully !!

Edited by Bensonv8 on Wednesday 14th April 22:56

haircutmike

22,511 posts

235 months

Wednesday 14th April 2010
quotequote all
Bensonv8 said:
The first thing i would do is remove the spark plugs looking for damage or a different colour.

If you start it from cold and let run for 10 - 15 seconds, you should be able to tell which exhaust manifold is NOT getting hot (indicating the faulty cylinder, assuming 1 is not firing) with out too much risk of burning the skin off your hands.

Camshaft wear ??
mine almost completely wore away one lobe so that the exhaust valve hardly opened, effectively running on 7. and when i tried to drive it, it sounded like it was pinking except 50 time worse. it went from "not running very well" to "barely runs at all" in just a couple of weeks of daily use.

Or possibly, you have a rocker arm that has lost the steel pad that pushed the valve down, which sound like hammering noise you mentioned and if the steel pad found it's way past a valve it would of pinged around the cylinder until it hits the spark plug.

i hope it's not either of these, but i think they are worth considering.
good luck
Steve
Good post!

Bensonv8

470 posts

240 months

Wednesday 14th April 2010
quotequote all
haircutmike said:
Bensonv8 said:
The first thing i would do is remove the spark plugs looking for damage or a different colour.

If you start it from cold and let run for 10 - 15 seconds, you should be able to tell which exhaust manifold is NOT getting hot (indicating the faulty cylinder, assuming 1 is not firing) with out too much risk of burning the skin off your hands.

Camshaft wear ??
mine almost completely wore away one lobe so that the exhaust valve hardly opened, effectively running on 7. and when i tried to drive it, it sounded like it was pinking except 50 time worse. it went from "not running very well" to "barely runs at all" in just a couple of weeks of daily use.

Or possibly, you have a rocker arm that has lost the steel pad that pushed the valve down, which sound like hammering noise you mentioned and if the steel pad found it's way past a valve it would of pinged around the cylinder until it hits the spark plug.

i hope it's not either of these, but i think they are worth considering.
good luck
Steve
Good post!
Thanks spin
(Great Chim in your profile thumbup )

speedtwelve

Original Poster:

3,547 posts

304 months

Wednesday 14th April 2010
quotequote all
Thanks guys. I don't think it's camshaft wear as the car idled smoothly and revved very freely all the way until 6250 rpm until Monday morning! It also seems to go pull pretty well for a 400.

I think I'll give pulling HT leads off when it's running a miss. Call me a big girl's blouse, but I don't fancy doing the funny wiggly dance wink

The plan is to see if it's missing due to an electrical ignition fault first of all, then I'll take the rocker covers off and look for a missing pad/damaged rocker arm/broken rocker shaft spring. Incidentally, the rocker cover bolts seem to be multi-faceted star-headed bolts that look like male torx. Are those standard does anyone know? Buggered if I know what I'll use to get them off...

Edit: Just had a look at BensonV8's other post regarding spline-headed rocker cover bolts. Looks like that's what I have.

Edited by speedtwelve on Wednesday 14th April 23:46

Bensonv8

470 posts

240 months

Wednesday 14th April 2010
quotequote all
and i've just come back from that post to see this one laugh

Bensonv8

470 posts

240 months

Wednesday 14th April 2010
quotequote all
i see your in Berkshire, any where near Bracknell / Camberley area ?

you welcome to borrow spline bit set ?

Bensonv8

470 posts

240 months

Thursday 15th April 2010
quotequote all
Does it look like this ?


speedtwelve

Original Poster:

3,547 posts

304 months

Thursday 15th April 2010
quotequote all
That's the fella.

Thanks for the offer of tools, BensonV8; the car's down near Wiltshire at the moment, so I may just buy my own so that I have them in reserve for future rocker cover fun. Laser universal spline drive set was it? Might give Camberley Auto Factors a phone.

Cheers.