WP Cam on a VXR8
Author
Discussion

djwilk

Original Poster:

1,693 posts

200 months

Friday 16th April 2010
quotequote all
As per title.
What do you think about this. Is it good for 500fwhp?

Talking about this:

www.walkinshawperformance.co.uk/wp/uk/products/default.asp?content=Vauxhall%20VXR8&id=66

Seems value for money. What gains am I expecting and what are your opinions?

I have a free flow de-cat, catback 2.5" exhaust and Wortec CAI.

cheers
Bart

ringram

14,702 posts

279 months

Friday 16th April 2010
quotequote all
Thats about 400rwhp in an LS2.
Id be wanting to know what the cam spec was and what the valve springs are, if they are replacing them at all. If its a 224/228 then that may well be right.
You realise on their spec that 15% on the normal 320rwhp from LS2 = 368rwhp, which is on a par with the MF Cam kit.
Thats not 500fwhp though. If you want 500fwhp, then you may well need a larger cam, which if retaining stock heads might be larger than you may like to get those numbers and might not pass emissions.
But if thats cam and springs fitted, then I dont think its a bad price. Id just want to know the cam specs.

V8NHH

437 posts

251 months

Friday 16th April 2010
quotequote all
It is for cam + springs also any map tweeks needed, eg flashed online from tuner not mapped individually.

It is something I have been looking into , but you will get same answer as to what cam specs are you won't know as to copy etc....

Obviously you can almost guarentee it won't damage car as it will be within specs and would of been developed and tested as per any other cam available form respectful tuners, I have searched and not found any before after dyno's to show improvements here or Aus forums.Walkinshaw have fitted several cams here but no one as yet has appeared to ackowledge work etc as yet..or results.....


djwilk

Original Poster:

1,693 posts

200 months

Friday 16th April 2010
quotequote all
Do you mean that WP would be selling junk under their name?

I thought they were a respectable tuner... And if the price is for cam + springs and map (was hoping it would be custom tuned) that is not a bad price.
Does anyone know what Monkfish would charge for the similar thing and I believe that the car has to be remapped to start and run at all.

By the way, why is it important to fit new springs as well? And is the mod an engine out job with heads to come off and all? Would they then skim the heads and put new set of bolts, gaskets etc, whatever applicable?

V8NHH

437 posts

251 months

Friday 16th April 2010
quotequote all
djwilk said:
Do you mean that WP would be selling junk under their name?

I thought they were a respectable tuner... And if the price is for cam + springs and map (was hoping it would be custom tuned) that is not a bad price.
Does anyone know what Monkfish would charge for the similar thing and I believe that the car has to be remapped to start and run at all.

By the way, why is it important to fit new springs as well? And is the mod an engine out job with heads to come off and all? Would they then skim the heads and put new set of bolts, gaskets etc, whatever applicable?
Who are you quoting?
If me then as follows
1) WP don't sell junk I use them and believe they are good products, and they have good service (never said else wise).
2) Monkfish works out similar in price, not sure how cams compare no posted specs obviously wouldn't want copy's or DIY's capitalising etc.. Also car can run straight off without map, but as with any changes you need to map to suite for best.
3) Yes springs are important to fit aswell lots of info on various forums regarding this, not very techie me but believe something to do with valve bounce?? not sure on this one --research forums for good answers.
Also not an engine out job to change cam see this for example of work
http://www.lsx-tuning.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=52...


ringram

14,702 posts

279 months

Friday 16th April 2010
quotequote all
Yeah springs are because of lift and valve control as mentioned. Also Im pretty sure Roger told me what the MF cam was. But as he doesnt advertise it I wont be repeating it.
If the cams meet your guys power requirements, then cool. But they only give a small uplift in power.

djwilk

Original Poster:

1,693 posts

200 months

Friday 16th April 2010
quotequote all
V8NHM, Sorry mate I was quoting you but must have misread one paragraph, hence my sudden confusion at the time.

Ringram, I thought you were a believer that an N/A Cammed engine is gonna make a better base than F/I. Am I misunderstanding something again? Or is there another value for money option I should consider?

ringram

14,702 posts

279 months

Friday 16th April 2010
quotequote all
You are correct. But not necessarily a better base FOR FI. If you want to build an NA which will later be used for FI. Then you should get forged pistons off the start. That will allow you to use almost any cam you like due to valve reliefs in the pistons. You will want lower compression than NA. See MadMax's build thread, he is around 9.8:1 IIRC
But you can build a good FI engine and run it NA. It will have way more power than stock, but not as much as a dedicated FI engine.
So once you choose your power requirement and work back you can run the engine NA for a while before you add FI. Loads more options around boost levels though which can vary power a lot.

djwilk

Original Poster:

1,693 posts

200 months

Saturday 17th April 2010
quotequote all
In that case I am not really aiming anywhere high. What I am really after is 500fwhp with decent torque down on the rev band (day to day use in midtown traffic), also I am not willing to fork out thousands of pounds, that is why I rule out an S/C it is just to expensive and I could not live with a whining noise. I want it to be civilized, a nice all-arounder. I don't need it to be the quickest one on the block and I would like to retain a fairly reasonable engine's lifespan with the fuel economy not worse than now.
So far I got a decat catback exhaust with Wortec CAI. The figures that Monkfish claim don't add up for their packages, but I am hoping that with a good cam and tune I might be able to touch the magic 500bhp, although I am more interested in torque than anything else. I would definitely not go for forged internals for the money reasons. I would also like the car to remain reliable, as to the emissions compliance... I guess the decat rules me out anyway.

ringram

14,702 posts

279 months

Saturday 17th April 2010
quotequote all
What car mate?
If its a manual LS2 then cam, exhaust and intake can get you 400rwhp, which is about 500fwhp. No heads needed. but IIRC you need a fairly healthy cam. Something like a 228/232 or similar. Not likely to pass emissions.
You cant have your cake and eat it too all the time. You have to pay to play. To do NA properly will be close to FI costs and cam will dictate driveability. You can use a smaller cam and get more power, but your heads, intake and exhaust need to be the best they can be. That means spending more on them to make up for it.
On a LS2 you can look at L92 heads as a cheap mod. One other guy here did that. You will need the ls3 intake. But thats a good budget combo, maybe with the new LSR 223/231 cam or similar.
With an LS1 then you will definately need heads IMO. A good set will cost you £2k easy. MadMax got a set of AFR's recently for around that.




djwilk

Original Poster:

1,693 posts

200 months

Saturday 17th April 2010
quotequote all
Sorry, it is LS2 manual. Carry on please, coz I'm listening interested.

SOULCREW

293 posts

208 months

Saturday 17th April 2010
quotequote all
me interested too.

wasgoing for a remap by walki but this sounds good.

djwilk

Original Poster:

1,693 posts

200 months

Saturday 17th April 2010
quotequote all
Another question arises... Knowing that the car has a CAI, decat and bits would it not need a custom remap rather than an off the shelf one? And where would I go to get it done? Would WP do it? Or would seek advice with another specialist? (I know there are not many). And would it be ok to get the custom tune on the road rather than on the Rolling Road?

V8NHH

437 posts

251 months

Saturday 17th April 2010
quotequote all
djwilk said:
Another question arises... Knowing that the car has a CAI, decat and bits would it not need a custom remap rather than an off the shelf one? And where would I go to get it done? Would WP do it? Or would seek advice with another specialist? (I know there are not many). And would it be ok to get the custom tune on the road rather than on the Rolling Road?
Most of the shelf maps would have been developed depending on set of mods eg, walkinshaw powerpack map assumes 2.5 cat back exhaust, filter then comes with a map, which does improve over standard, reckon it would suit more a CAI or OTR CAI more than just panel filter as mine showed quite rich after map (had a look a AFR on dyno) as for others not sure, I know Mark ex Rapid GB now LS power I think will map on dyno and had done my last HSV and was great.... others such as Monkfish not sure but believe they have standard tunes and then test car afterwards and tweek as required, mass production there are always some subtle differences between same mods on different cars.. so individual customisation would benefit more than generic map eg generic map then dyno or road tuning session to get spot on...

djwilk

Original Poster:

1,693 posts

200 months

Saturday 17th April 2010
quotequote all
So I assume by going to WP and getting the cam done naturally they would upload the map and still test the car on the road and tweak it if needed?
I guess the only difference with mine is that it's running no CATs.

007 VXR

64,187 posts

218 months

Saturday 17th April 2010
quotequote all
djwilk said:
So I assume by going to WP and getting the cam done naturally they would upload the map and still test the car on the road and tweak it if needed?
I guess the only difference with mine is that it's running no CATs.
they would not remap mine last summer after fitting an exhurst
because mine was running a wortec map ??????


Aeroresh

1,429 posts

263 months

Thursday 1st July 2010
quotequote all
Is there a definitive view on this upgrade?

Spoke with Ken at WP and he said there was no loss in driveability low down.

Seems like very good value at £2k all in for 15-20% FWHP?

Got my 1st service coming up and was considering using it as an excuse to have it done at WP (and getting it past the misses' radar! wink )

ringram

14,702 posts

279 months

Thursday 1st July 2010
quotequote all
15-20% more fwhp should also mean 15-20% rwhp.
A stout LS2 stock is about 320rwhp ish.
So in theory you want 368rwhp afterwards. Which as mentioned is a mild cam.
Only 8rwhp more than £500 worth of mods in my LS2 which had no cam OR exhaust mods!
So if you only want 370rwhp odd, then by all means go for it.

If you want more, then you will need a bigger cam and/or heads as well, possibly even an uprated intake, proper headers etc.


mystvxr

427 posts

229 months

Thursday 1st July 2010
quotequote all
Rich, what's your opinion on this package and what would be the right options for my FI LS2..

www.texas-speed.com/shop/item.asp?itemid=831&catid=47

cheers.

after_shock

8,751 posts

251 months

Thursday 1st July 2010
quotequote all
mystvxr said:
Rich, what's your opinion on this package and what would be the right options for my FI LS2..

www.texas-speed.com/shop/item.asp?itemid=831&catid=47

cheers.


Doesnt seem a bad price for heads and cam, although to me isnt exactly clear what spec heads you would be getting? Also I wouldnt know where to start on specifying the cam!!