Speccing Corporate Laptops?
Author
Discussion

paddyhasneeds

Original Poster:

68,479 posts

241 months

Sunday 18th April 2010
quotequote all
We currently use Dell for our desktops and laptops. We don't buy masses by the big boys standards but we buy sufficient to have an account manager and get some reasonable discounts off the prices on the Dell website.

Whilst we like the desktops, the current and new Lattitude's leave a bit to be desired - they're getting expensive and IMO the build quality isn't "up there" as I'd expect given what they cost.

So, we're looking at alternatives.

We only really deal with "box shifters" when it comes to kit other than Dell. What I could do with knowing (before the sales people get their claws into me) is, with HP and Lenovo, can you access a decent online configurator that lets you spec exactly the laptop that you want or if you want anything other than a boxed model are you left buying a trolley of parts and having to install them?

To be fair the only fairly (reasonably) unusual thing we'd want is an FDE hard drive.

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Sunday 18th April 2010
quotequote all
The way I understand it, with Dell corporates are buying the support rather than the quality of the PCs (which are commodity standard)

We went to Lenovo from Dell at my work about 18 months ago. suffice to say we went from Lenovo to Dell about 16 months ago. biggrin

lestag

4,614 posts

307 months

Monday 19th April 2010
quotequote all
paddyhasneeds said:
We currently use Dell for our desktops and laptops. We don't buy masses by the big boys standards but we buy sufficient to have an account manager and get some reasonable discounts off the prices on the Dell website.

Whilst we like the desktops, the current and new Lattitude's leave a bit to be desired - they're getting expensive and IMO the build quality isn't "up there" as I'd expect given what they cost.

So, we're looking at alternatives.

We only really deal with "box shifters" when it comes to kit other than Dell. What I could do with knowing (before the sales people get their claws into me) is, with HP and Lenovo, can you access a decent online configurator that lets you spec exactly the laptop that you want or if you want anything other than a boxed model are you left buying a trolley of parts and having to install them?

To be fair the only fairly (reasonably) unusual thing we'd want is an FDE hard drive.
No on the configuration for HP ( hp configuator for servers tho)
Just get the box droper to install the parts and include in price

neil_bolton

17,113 posts

295 months

Monday 19th April 2010
quotequote all
davepoth said:
The way I understand it, with Dell corporates are buying the support rather than the quality of the PCs (which are commodity standard)

We went to Lenovo from Dell at my work about 18 months ago. suffice to say we went from Lenovo to Dell about 16 months ago. biggrin
All I need to say is: yes to the above.

mph999

2,780 posts

251 months

Monday 19th April 2010
quotequote all
neil_bolton said:
davepoth said:
The way I understand it, with Dell corporates are buying the support rather than the quality of the PCs (which are commodity standard)

We went to Lenovo from Dell at my work about 18 months ago. suffice to say we went from Lenovo to Dell about 16 months ago. biggrin
All I need to say is: yes to the above.
Yep, my work has done exactly the same, move to Dell from Lenovo.

I have a Dell Latitude E6400 and I have to admit I am pleasently surprised - well, once I got the crappy company build off it and reinstalled it works fne. The best test, would I spend my own money on one, yes.

Not saying there isn't something better out there, but if I bought one myself I wouldn't be dissapointed.

Martin

TonyToniTone

3,929 posts

280 months

Monday 19th April 2010
quotequote all
neil_bolton said:
davepoth said:
The way I understand it, with Dell corporates are buying the support rather than the quality of the PCs (which are commodity standard)

We went to Lenovo from Dell at my work about 18 months ago. suffice to say we went from Lenovo to Dell about 16 months ago. biggrin
All I need to say is: yes to the above.
I would disagree with the above – last year I created an image and rolled out nearly 4 thousand M58\T400\X200 and rebuilt hundreds of M57\M56\T.. A single M500 was DOE, had no other problems and users loved the workstations.

A project running in parallel with a different image build had no end of problems using the same hardware.

The box shifter put about 500 dual head graphics cards in and all the PC came pre imaged - Very impressed with Lenovo kit.

neil_bolton

17,113 posts

295 months

Monday 19th April 2010
quotequote all
TonyToniTone said:
neil_bolton said:
davepoth said:
The way I understand it, with Dell corporates are buying the support rather than the quality of the PCs (which are commodity standard)

We went to Lenovo from Dell at my work about 18 months ago. suffice to say we went from Lenovo to Dell about 16 months ago. biggrin
All I need to say is: yes to the above.
I would disagree with the above – last year I created an image and rolled out nearly 4 thousand M58\T400\X200 and rebuilt hundreds of M57\M56\T.. A single M500 was DOE, had no other problems and users loved the workstations.

A project running in parallel with a different image build had no end of problems using the same hardware.

The box shifter put about 500 dual head graphics cards in and all the PC came pre imaged - Very impressed with Lenovo kit.
Sorry! That's what I meant; Dell to Lenovo.

Dell have massively nose dived quality wise since they ditched their well respected Latitude D series laptops for the plasticy over specced and complicated E series machines. Why one earth they have I do not know, but all I know is the Lenovo TP's are the bees knees nowadays - the Thinkpad Edge is an absolute barnstormer of a machine price wise too...

Sorry if I was confusing. I used to love Dell laptops, now I hate em. Lenovo have my business.

ETA: if we could stomach the costs, the Apple MacBook Pro's would be getting our money, as they are utterly superior in every way - just whack XP OL on, and away we go.

As someone mentioned above, the best test is 'would I buy one myself?' - well, I just brought a MacBook Pro - and I'm a devout Windows tech.

Edited by neil_bolton on Monday 19th April 10:18

paddyhasneeds

Original Poster:

68,479 posts

241 months

Monday 19th April 2010
quotequote all
So what is the support and level of cusomization like with Lenovo?

As I said we don't tend to tinker too much, but at least with Dell you're dealing direct and they build to order.

I guess what I'm trying to work out is the pros and cons of approaching Lenovo direct over a reseller?

Tallbut Buxomly

12,254 posts

247 months

Monday 19th April 2010
quotequote all
Be aware hp kit is very expensive long term.

lestag

4,614 posts

307 months

Tuesday 20th April 2010
quotequote all
Tallbut Buxomly said:
Be aware hp kit is very expensive long term.
Um? how ?

neil_bolton

17,113 posts

295 months

Tuesday 20th April 2010
quotequote all
paddyhasneeds said:
So what is the support and level of cusomization like with Lenovo?

As I said we don't tend to tinker too much, but at least with Dell you're dealing direct and they build to order.

I guess what I'm trying to work out is the pros and cons of approaching Lenovo direct over a reseller?
Well we're speccing Edge 13's and they're coming in at £550 with 3yr accidental damage warranty.

And we just buy them from whoever we need, but support comes from Lenovo. Slightly annoying to deal with India, but then Dell is the same unless you're uber huge.

paddyhasneeds

Original Poster:

68,479 posts

241 months

Tuesday 20th April 2010
quotequote all
Hmm interesting. We're not "uber huge" but I believe we get "gold" support so don't usually have to go through India and support is something we'd want to have some re-assurances about (I say this as 9/10 times we're phoning because the HDD sounds like a bag of spanners but still they ask "Have you ran the diags?" etc.

So does anyone know if you can get discounts from Lenovo unless you're buying loads?

I'm trying to work out if there's a benefit going direct vs. just picking a reseller.

Tallbut Buxomly

12,254 posts

247 months

Tuesday 20th April 2010
quotequote all
lestag said:
Tallbut Buxomly said:
Be aware hp kit is very expensive long term.
Um? how ?
Maintenance costs seem to be a fair bit higher than most other kit.

paddyhasneeds

Original Poster:

68,479 posts

241 months

Sunday 25th April 2010
quotequote all
OK well from speaking to Lenovo and a few resellers it appears they're pretty rubbish or plain disinterested in trying to provide similar functionality to Dell in terms of "go to online portal, spec laptop and get price, order laptop via company ordering process".

We don't tend to deviate our spec too much tbh, however there's a few things we'd want i.e. Office, on-site warranty and FDE hard drive that Lenovo don't offer on anything other than a customized spec.

Any suggestions on brands or resellers that are able to accomodate this sort of thing?

jammy_basturd

29,778 posts

243 months

Sunday 25th April 2010
quotequote all
We had a number of HP laptops last year in our relatively small business (we probably bought about 7-10). All of them were rubbish. They were the dv6700 series IIRC. Needless to say one development team had HPs forced on them again by a client, which keep breaking, my development team went to Dell XPS Studios which are, for the money, a good laptop.

MilnerR

8,273 posts

289 months

Sunday 25th April 2010
quotequote all
We've just been Vista'd from Win 2K (I know, don't ask), and we've all got shiney new lenovo kit. I have to admit, apart from the OS, they seem very well put together bits of equipment and do everything we ask of them. The whole company (Big Pharma) has upgraded, so the powers-that-be saw fit to buy thousands of Lenovo laptops and desktops (company employs about 60,000 people worldwide).

Funk

27,807 posts

240 months

Sunday 25th April 2010
quotequote all
We've just gone from XPP on Thinkpad X60/61 to Dell Latitude E4300s. They're ste and I'd give anything to go back to the X60. The fact we've got Vista on the Dells doesn't help much either.

As an end user, please don't inflict the above on your users. The number of BSODs, crashes, lockups and glitches we're having have been unbelievable.

paddyhasneeds

Original Poster:

68,479 posts

241 months

Sunday 25th April 2010
quotequote all
Tbh the Dell's have been fine in terms of reliability, I think that's more to do with the image used than it is a reflection on the hardware.

Dell, despite their faults to make it very simple to order a custom config - Lenovo and HP seem to make it pretty fking difficult from what I'm seeing so far.

lestag

4,614 posts

307 months

Monday 26th April 2010
quotequote all
paddyhasneeds said:
Lenovo and HP seem to make it pretty fking difficult from what I'm seeing so far.
That is correct, period.
The only way is really as I suggested previously, get the box dropepr to install teh bits and include in the price quoted.

XJSJohn

16,152 posts

250 months

Monday 26th April 2010
quotequote all
Paddy, don't know much about the support packs at your level, especially UK based but i can say one thing, having spent the past 9 months working for my first ever DELL shop (after nigh on 20 years working with most everything else from IBM/Lenovo to HP/Compaq to Fujitsu, Acer, Sony etc etc) The Dell Laptops (at least the E series) are pieces of crap. Shocking build quality and poor performance (with or without a corporate build)

Having seen some collegues with the older D series, i can see where they get praise from, they are a bit of a warhorse getting close to the old IBM T series.

From recient experiance on the HW alone, i would be praising the Lenovo units.

Ohh and if you regularly suffer from HD's sounding like a bag of spanners, can i suggest perhaps a simpler insurance method would be some USB HD's and a backup / replicator software then try and teach your users to run that once every few days. When the disk blows up just throw a new one in and restore! Self support with some basic common sense can often be the cheepest form of support for an SME.