Online alternative to Google Adwords
Discussion
We have been using Google Adwords successfully for quite some time, however they have become increasingly expensive, and some combinations that we used to use @ £.70p a click have gone up to nearly £4.00 a click - which is too much as it does not bring in as much business as it used to, and is almost costing as much to advertise as it does to bring business in.
Aside from our other manual and local efforts, can anyone recommend an alternative or online advertising package that you have actually used for your business and had success with?
Aside from our other manual and local efforts, can anyone recommend an alternative or online advertising package that you have actually used for your business and had success with?
Yell.com gets us a good ROI
Infolinks is an alternative to adwords.
Affiliate advertising, where you allow websites to place banners on their sites for your product, when somebody orders you pay a % of the sale, or a flat rate ie £2, not sure what cut the affiliate companies take though, have a look at tradedoubler, DGM, Affiliate window etc.
Infolinks is an alternative to adwords.
Affiliate advertising, where you allow websites to place banners on their sites for your product, when somebody orders you pay a % of the sale, or a flat rate ie £2, not sure what cut the affiliate companies take though, have a look at tradedoubler, DGM, Affiliate window etc.
I don't have the specifics on me this evening as my business partner runs the campaign out of one of his accounts.
We have it geotargetted to a 20 or so mile radius from Reading I believe, the keyword "carpet cleaner" comes up at 3.74 a click or thereabouts.
Other more local keywords are cheaper but do not yield anywhere near the results.
I will try to post more specifics tomorrow when I meet up with him, it used to be about 70p to 1.00 for that keyword under our campaign which was fairly reasonable by comparison!
We have it geotargetted to a 20 or so mile radius from Reading I believe, the keyword "carpet cleaner" comes up at 3.74 a click or thereabouts.
Other more local keywords are cheaper but do not yield anywhere near the results.
I will try to post more specifics tomorrow when I meet up with him, it used to be about 70p to 1.00 for that keyword under our campaign which was fairly reasonable by comparison!
Bing is doing a deal at the moment, export your adwords campaign and send it to your rep to upload and they'll give you £40 free credit so there's no harm to try it. Although usually it's not much cheaper than adwords and has less volume (especially in the UK but advertising is changing that now). Yahoo can be quite a bit cheaper and can vary a lot in volume and quality.
Out of interest what's your QS on google? That can affect the bids by a huge amount.
Out of interest what's your QS on google? That can affect the bids by a huge amount.
I think people who use yahoo and bing (Usually via a toolbar or because it's the default in IE) are generally less internet savvy. This actually gives you higher quality traffic because the users are a lot less likely to suffer from ad blindness
Only problem being that you may never reach your target market because the volume is much lower.
Only problem being that you may never reach your target market because the volume is much lower.
Edited by Frankeh on Tuesday 27th April 10:56
Frankeh said:
I think people who use yahoo and bing (Usually via a toolbar or because it's the default in IE) are generally less internet savvy. This actually gives you higher quality traffic because the users are a lot less likely to suffer from ad blindness
I'm not as savvy about all the above, but I use yahoo because I like the results I get from it. I usually find I get more of what I'm actually looking for...was that what you meant?(bing is just s
t, though)Pothole said:
Frankeh said:
I think people who use yahoo and bing (Usually via a toolbar or because it's the default in IE) are generally less internet savvy. This actually gives you higher quality traffic because the users are a lot less likely to suffer from ad blindness
I'm not as savvy about all the above, but I use yahoo because I like the results I get from it. I usually find I get more of what I'm actually looking for...was that what you meant?(bing is just s
t, though)I will admit that they're better than they were, and they're still the 2nd most popular.
I think that at the moment the problem with google is people gaming it and degrading the results. No one's really trying that with yahoo, however generally the tactics they use work across search engines.
Generally I find the results are comparable, but the simple layout of google makes it a winner for me.
Unfortunately Google is getting more and more competitive, I wish most of my keywords were £4 let alone 70p!
The reality is Google's got the market cornered, yes MSN/Bing will bring you some extra traffic but don't expect more than 10% tops of the volume you get from Google. As mentioned previously, Yell.com PPC is worth a punt, but don't get talked into their other online offerings, they're a waste of time.
If I was you I'd look to strengthen the campaign, some questions to help give some more specific guidance:
Alternatively look up PHer DonnyMac as he does this for a living!
The reality is Google's got the market cornered, yes MSN/Bing will bring you some extra traffic but don't expect more than 10% tops of the volume you get from Google. As mentioned previously, Yell.com PPC is worth a punt, but don't get talked into their other online offerings, they're a waste of time.
If I was you I'd look to strengthen the campaign, some questions to help give some more specific guidance:
- Do you use broad, phrase or exact match?
- Are you targeting regional keywords eg "carpet cleaner reading", "carpet cleaner berkshire", etc?
- Have you considered widening the search radius for targeting? For instance I'm south of Guildford yet my IP puts me in Reading, users in Reading may find the opposite. I have other IPs based in Guildford that locate to London and Southsea.
- Are you running ads on the content network?
- How strong is your ad copy in relation to your competitors, in particular call to action?
- Does the landing page for your ad have a strong call to action?
- How do you track business that comes through Google?
Alternatively look up PHer DonnyMac as he does this for a living!
10JH said:
grumbas said:
Unfortunately Google is getting more and more competitive, I wish most of my keywords were £4 let alone 70p!
Just out of interest, how much is the highest you've heard of/experienced in cost per click?I've never done any PPC but am looking into doing it soon.
Google has a good tool for estimating costs, can't remember the link of hand though. I find it tends to over-estimate cost by 50% or so, but then my campaigns are highly optimised.
Adcuz said:
It may not be appropriate for your market, however Facebook Advertising can be really good for targetting the right people.
I did think about that, what put me off is that people on facebook generally are not there to look for services, however if anyone has got results from it, I would be happy to be proved wrong.TheCarpetCleaner said:
Adcuz said:
It may not be appropriate for your market, however Facebook Advertising can be really good for targetting the right people.
I did think about that, what put me off is that people on facebook generally are not there to look for services, however if anyone has got results from it, I would be happy to be proved wrong.Would be interested to see some results though as well.
10JH said:
TheCarpetCleaner said:
Adcuz said:
It may not be appropriate for your market, however Facebook Advertising can be really good for targetting the right people.
I did think about that, what put me off is that people on facebook generally are not there to look for services, however if anyone has got results from it, I would be happy to be proved wrong.Would be interested to see some results though as well.
OP, it is possible that your campaign could do with a bit of optimising by a pro but by the looks of your market it is very saturated.
Maybe you could try something a bit different like making up videos showing people how the pros clean? In a similar vein to "Will it Blend?", you could have "Will it Clean" and make videos of you cleaning off different stains....
Dick Dastardly said:
As the above post shows, MSN and Yahoo offer alternative PPC systems. The traffic figures are a lot lower, though often the traffic is of a higher quality.
Do you have solid results that traffic from other search engines is of a higher quality. Personally i cannot see how they could differ, i dont think different search engines would attract a different user, i think people who use yahoo or msn search engines are probably people who rely on yahoo or msn webmail accounts, so would have the site as their homepage.
You could argue you this point with more specific search engines (a function of a search engine could attract a group of people, who happen to be the sort of people who purchase your products/service, so you (But only your company)would get better results.), but i dont see how users of yahoo and msn would be better quality to the typical business who invest in ppc etc.
russy01 said:
Dick Dastardly said:
As the above post shows, MSN and Yahoo offer alternative PPC systems. The traffic figures are a lot lower, though often the traffic is of a higher quality.
Do you have solid results that traffic from other search engines is of a higher quality. Personally i cannot see how they could differ, i dont think different search engines would attract a different user, i think people who use yahoo or msn search engines are probably people who rely on yahoo or msn webmail accounts, so would have the site as their homepage.
You could argue you this point with more specific search engines (a function of a search engine could attract a group of people, who happen to be the sort of people who purchase your products/service, so you (But only your company)would get better results.), but i dont see how users of yahoo and msn would be better quality to the typical business who invest in ppc etc.
Interesting! As I think I've mentioned in the past, we find our ROI on MSN significantly higher than Google whereas we're constantly debating whether Yahoo is worth the effort (largely down to their insistence on not letting you opt out of their content network because it increases click volumes
)
)Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


