I'm considering a V6 4Motion...
I'm considering a V6 4Motion...
Author
Discussion

SiR Si

Original Poster:

168 posts

240 months

Monday 26th April 2010
quotequote all
Hi all,

As per title, I am considering swapping my Volvo C70 T5 for a Mk4 V6 4Motion. I'm just looking for peoples thoughts on these as I have had no experience with Veedubs in the past. I love the Volvo. Its uber comfy and it has ooodles of power but it is auto and its just not got the fun factor on the twisties! What are the V6's like? Will this tick my fun to drive box, or will the decrease in power be a disappointment?? (Volvo is 310bhp, Golf 204bhp!)

Thanks in advance guys. Who knows...I may soon be frequenting this area of the forum!!

Seez

656 posts

211 months

Monday 26th April 2010
quotequote all
what sort of budget are you looking at, the V6 isnt bad, but won't be that quick especially when you consider the R32 which is a rung above.

The 4wd is not a permanent setup, which may or may not suit, if i was you and depending on budget I would be tempted with an S4 V6 biturbo or maybe the V8!

SiR Si

Original Poster:

168 posts

240 months

Monday 26th April 2010
quotequote all
Well my Volvo is for sale for £4200 so that ultimately would be my budget, but I have been offered the golf as a swap which is what is making it attractive. I've always loved R32s but I think that's definately outside my budget.

The majority of my driving is to and from work which is why I bought the auto volvo, but I do enjoy the odd b road hoon which is where I think the golf will cone into it's own, whilst still being comfy and smooth for the commute!

Seez

656 posts

211 months

Tuesday 27th April 2010
quotequote all
If you are getting a good deal it could be a good buy, it isn't that dynamic though, I have driven a fair few MK4 golfs including the V6 and none are especially sharp, but the V6 sounds nice, but could do with a bit more ooomph! It is a bit of a jack of all trades, comfy reasonably quick, but the fuel economy is a bit poor as you would probably expect.

If you can spend a bit more and aren't too worried about spending some dough looking after a car a V6 S4 is in a different league and can be tuned very easily to be very very quick. They are comfy too and can go down a country road very rapidly indeed. Insurance may not be that much more either as you are in sports car teritory anyway.

Golf will probably be less to run, but the S4 would be much more dynamic and faster but with the downside of lower fuel economy, (say 21mpg average), more to go wrong and it will be harder to find a nice one.

Plus look after an S4 and you will sell it easy when the time comes.

Difficult one and ultimately would come down to money, I would give up something else in your life and get the S4!!

Fourmotion

1,032 posts

251 months

Tuesday 27th April 2010
quotequote all
If you're looking for fun on the twisties, then it's probably not for you in original state. Some models came with sports suspension (typically those with the optional 17 inch alloys), but I've not driven one with it on so can't comment on the difference.

Mine is standard, and it's a comfortable setup. A lot, and I mean a lot of people change the suspension, the best advice can be found here. The V6 makes the car very nose heavy, and it doesn't give the feeling of agility through corners. Saying that, it's very planted, and will never struggle for grip.

Depending on your experience and inclination to get involved with upgrading components, the 1.8T is a better bet. For less than £500 you'll have more power than the V6, with a lighter, better balanced car. It will only be fwd, but then the 4motion is only fwd unless it loses traction.

SiR Si

Original Poster:

168 posts

240 months

Tuesday 27th April 2010
quotequote all
I am by no means expecting the golf to be a go kart. I don't think I'll get anything particularly dynamic or well balanced as standard for my budget! But with a few chassis and suspension tweaks I'd hope it'll be half respectable!?

aka_kerrly

12,506 posts

241 months

Tuesday 27th April 2010
quotequote all
most people agree the mk4 is way too soft in standard form. The 4mo especially isnt meant to handle like a GTI, it is more of a crusier BUT with a few tweeks to the suspension, geometry and crucially the anti roll bar set up you can drastically change them for the better and then they start turning into a pretty good package.

dave

bn9af

3,920 posts

211 months

Wednesday 28th April 2010
quotequote all
Fourmotion said:
If you're looking for fun on the twisties, then it's probably not for you in original state. Some models came with sports suspension (typically those with the optional 17 inch alloys), but I've not driven one with it on so can't comment on the difference.

Mine is standard, and it's a comfortable setup. A lot, and I mean a lot of people change the suspension, the best advice can be found here. The V6 makes the car very nose heavy, and it doesn't give the feeling of agility through corners. Saying that, it's very planted, and will never struggle for grip.

Depending on your experience and inclination to get involved with upgrading components, the 1.8T is a better bet. For less than £500 you'll have more power than the V6, with a lighter, better balanced car. It will only be fwd, but then the 4motion is only fwd unless it loses traction.
Why not go for a 8L A3 1.8T quattro? plenty about and very tunable.

Fourmotion

1,032 posts

251 months

Wednesday 28th April 2010
quotequote all
bn9af said:
Why not go for a 8L A3 1.8T quattro? plenty about and very tunable.
There are plenty of cars in the OP's price range, I was giving perspective on the Golf variants.

I would think the Leon would offer better value and 'chuckability' over the A3 anyway...

bn9af

3,920 posts

211 months

Wednesday 28th April 2010
quotequote all
i appreciate you were answering the OP question, i was just trying to put a spin on it!

Yeah i agree the leon probably does drive better for being lighter, and is probably specced better for the same money, but just thought I'd recommend the 1.8T quattro as its 4WD and the OP is looking for a 4motion. granted he wants a V6, but as you said they are bloody tunable!

GreenMan

159 posts

244 months

Thursday 29th April 2010
quotequote all
Having owned one for 8 months a few years back I'd agree with most of what's been said above. Mine didn't have the sports suspension and was certainly no track-day weapon, but at the same time it did have a nicely cushioned ride and felt extremely planted at speed.

The V6 made a lovely noise and was decently (but not ridiculously) quick, but fuel consumption rarely bettered about 27mpg even on long runs. Around town saw late teens or early twenties.

It's not unusual to see these with an illuminated engine emissions light, which could just point to a faulty MAF, but don't discount the coil which is also temperamental on the V6 (especially if accompanied by lumpy running). In the 8 months of my ownership mine needed both, and the coil is quite pricey (~£400 iirc).

SiR Si

Original Poster:

168 posts

240 months

Thursday 29th April 2010
quotequote all
Thanks everyone for your very helpful comments, but after alot of thought, I've decided against the golf. The general opinion seems to be that it's 'OK' but nothing special. Well the Volvo is 'very good' but nothing special, with oodles more power than the golf with similar economy so it's a no brainer for me!

The leon sounds good but I'd ONLY have the R and they seem out of my price range...around £6-7k?

Daynsie

13 posts

199 months

Monday 3rd May 2010
quotequote all
This v6 you have been offered as p x on your volvo, isn't by any chance from a guy from Scotland is it?

SiR Si

Original Poster:

168 posts

240 months

Monday 3rd May 2010
quotequote all
It most certainly is!! What do you know of him then??

snout1

3 posts

198 months

Monday 3rd May 2010
quotequote all
the v6 in scotland. is it silver with a r32 exhaust system by any chance

SiR Si

Original Poster:

168 posts

240 months

Monday 3rd May 2010
quotequote all
Yes it is, why do you guys ask? I'm not going for it anyway, but I'm still intrigued!!

Daynsie

13 posts

199 months

Tuesday 4th May 2010
quotequote all
Don't know much about the golf, its just that we have an EVO 6 for sale, the guy wants to px. Have you seen this golf, if so whats it like. I understand its had about 9 owners, and wonder why?

SiR Si

Original Poster:

168 posts

240 months

Tuesday 4th May 2010
quotequote all
Well that's interesting as the reason he wanted the Volvo is because it's auto and he can't handle manual anymore!! ... I'm damn sure your evo isn't auto!! Ha ha. The 9 owners bit rang alarm bells to me too!

Sounds very suspect to me and I'd be cautious! Fully ispect the car before committing to a deal, and make him drive to you rather than meeting half way, that way your time and fuel isn't wasted if it does turn out to be a stter!

Daynsie

13 posts

199 months

Tuesday 4th May 2010
quotequote all
Cheers Si, a totally different reason to what he told us, his lads have an Evo and Scooby, the golf wont keep up with them!!
I too think we may give it a miss. With reference to meeting half way, even if we do want to take a look, I think he should come to us, don't you? we are in Suffolk, so to meet half way to Bonnie Scotland is a few tanks of fuel there and back, in any case, he wants the deal, not necessarily us, so he should come all the way don't you think??? 9 owners sounds a bit iffy.

SiR Si

Original Poster:

168 posts

240 months

Tuesday 4th May 2010
quotequote all
Yea, if I were you, I think I'd let him keep it! Sounds like hassle. And yes, he should really be making the full journey as he has made the approach, but I actually offered to meet halfway believing he was genuine, and at the time I was quite up for the Golf!