Where would you advertise for a new bar manager?
Discussion
Hi folks
I'm helping my girlfriend, who owns a pub, to recruit a new bar manager.
Using the local Job Centre is out of the question, as the applicants usually apply only to satisfy the Job Centre that they're looking for work. In the past, all applicants taken on through this route have been a nightmare.
So... she's using Gumtree.com, but where else could she advertise?
Thanks.
I'm helping my girlfriend, who owns a pub, to recruit a new bar manager.
Using the local Job Centre is out of the question, as the applicants usually apply only to satisfy the Job Centre that they're looking for work. In the past, all applicants taken on through this route have been a nightmare.
So... she's using Gumtree.com, but where else could she advertise?
Thanks.
Thanks. She's asked around in her own pub. I think she's not outgoing enough to ask around in other pubs, but I don't want to start doing her work for her...
The trade journals are a good idea. I was wondering if there was anything between the likes of gumtree.com (surely only for aussies looking for bar jobs in London...?!) and sites for qualified professionals like monster.com...?
The pub's in Newcastle-upon-Tyne.
The trade journals are a good idea. I was wondering if there was anything between the likes of gumtree.com (surely only for aussies looking for bar jobs in London...?!) and sites for qualified professionals like monster.com...?
The pub's in Newcastle-upon-Tyne.
condor said:
The Caterer is the main trade magazine that has pub management vacancies in.
And also at www.caterer.comArese said:
condor said:
The Caterer is the main trade magazine that has pub management vacancies in.
And also at www.caterer.comI agree with the people who said approach prospective candidates directly but I'd do it in a more structured way. My answer is based on the premise that it's a decent bar, the vacancy is a reasonably 'attractive' one and your girlfriend is looking for a 'quality' manager. If that's not the case (i.e. if it's a 'rough' bar or the pay is below average) then please ignore. Otherwise...
First things first, I wouldn't advertise and I wouldn't use an agency.
The main problem associated with recruiting 'quality' staff through adverts or agencies is that the better someone is at their job, the less likely they are to be 'actively' looking for a new position (people tend to enjoy doing things they're good at and employers tend to make more of an effort to 'look after' people who are good at their jobs). Whilst it's certainly not impossible to hire someone good through an advert or an agency, it can be extremely hit and miss because the majority of applicants will always be unhappy/disaffected/unmotivated etc.
The way I would approach it is this:
1. Draw up a list of all other local bars that are vaguely comparable (don't include any that are significantly better or worse).
2. Phone them all up and ask for the names of both the manager and the assistant manager (it isn't too difficult to get names if you invent a decent 'cover story' e.g. say you work for XXX and you're sending out invitations to attend a local licensed trade suppliers exhibition or something like that). Might sound a bit underhand but it's a tactic commonly used throughout the entire 'search' profession.
3. Give it a few days and then make a discrete approach by telephone to each of the managers at a time of day when they're likely to be working but not too busy. All you have to say is "Hi, my name is X, I'm the owner of a bar in the local area, I'm looking for a new manager, I've heard you're good at what you do (try to ignore the fact that this is a lie because flattery at this stage is important), I realise you're probably not actively looking for a new position but I'd very much like to have a chat with you on the phone when you're not at work, just to see if the opportunity is something you might be interested in. Would that be OK? Great, can I take a mobile number from you? When would be the best time to call?"
4. If the manager is unreceptive, leave it a few days and call the assistant manager (or get a friend to). There might be some decent assistant managers ready for a step up.
5. Call people outside of work at the appointed time and have a chat with them about the opportunity. Tell them about your business, what the role entails, why it requires someone of their calibre etc. Don't 'blue sky' the opportunity (i.e. paint a picture that the job can't live up to) but work hard to emphasise the 'key selling points' of both you as an employer and the role itself. If the person is receptive, ask them a bit about their current job and work experience. To get someone talking all you need say is something like "You were recommended to me by a friend of a friend (make up a name if necassary) - I've heard you're good at what you do but I don't know much about you - how long have you been working at XX, what did you do before etc?" If they sound (broadly speaking) like what you're looking for, ask them if they'd like to meet up and have a chat.
6. Interview them in a similar way you'd interview someone who applied to an advert but work hard to continue 'selling' the opportunity.
If you follow this plan, you'll achieve 2 key things:
1. You'll find yourself meeting and interviewing a larger pool of higher calibre candidates than you could ever hope to find through an advert or an agency.
2. If someone who wasn't actively looking for a job accepts an offer, it'll be because they're genuinely motivated by the opportunity (always a much better bet than someone who is unhappy in their job, looking for an exit route and prepared to take pretty much any job that comes along, even if it's not exactly what they were looking for).
This probably sounds like a lot of hard work and effort but the result is likely to be worth it in the long run (less time spent fixing problems created by a crap manager, or having to replace someone who leaves quite quickly).
First things first, I wouldn't advertise and I wouldn't use an agency.
The main problem associated with recruiting 'quality' staff through adverts or agencies is that the better someone is at their job, the less likely they are to be 'actively' looking for a new position (people tend to enjoy doing things they're good at and employers tend to make more of an effort to 'look after' people who are good at their jobs). Whilst it's certainly not impossible to hire someone good through an advert or an agency, it can be extremely hit and miss because the majority of applicants will always be unhappy/disaffected/unmotivated etc.
The way I would approach it is this:
1. Draw up a list of all other local bars that are vaguely comparable (don't include any that are significantly better or worse).
2. Phone them all up and ask for the names of both the manager and the assistant manager (it isn't too difficult to get names if you invent a decent 'cover story' e.g. say you work for XXX and you're sending out invitations to attend a local licensed trade suppliers exhibition or something like that). Might sound a bit underhand but it's a tactic commonly used throughout the entire 'search' profession.
3. Give it a few days and then make a discrete approach by telephone to each of the managers at a time of day when they're likely to be working but not too busy. All you have to say is "Hi, my name is X, I'm the owner of a bar in the local area, I'm looking for a new manager, I've heard you're good at what you do (try to ignore the fact that this is a lie because flattery at this stage is important), I realise you're probably not actively looking for a new position but I'd very much like to have a chat with you on the phone when you're not at work, just to see if the opportunity is something you might be interested in. Would that be OK? Great, can I take a mobile number from you? When would be the best time to call?"
4. If the manager is unreceptive, leave it a few days and call the assistant manager (or get a friend to). There might be some decent assistant managers ready for a step up.
5. Call people outside of work at the appointed time and have a chat with them about the opportunity. Tell them about your business, what the role entails, why it requires someone of their calibre etc. Don't 'blue sky' the opportunity (i.e. paint a picture that the job can't live up to) but work hard to emphasise the 'key selling points' of both you as an employer and the role itself. If the person is receptive, ask them a bit about their current job and work experience. To get someone talking all you need say is something like "You were recommended to me by a friend of a friend (make up a name if necassary) - I've heard you're good at what you do but I don't know much about you - how long have you been working at XX, what did you do before etc?" If they sound (broadly speaking) like what you're looking for, ask them if they'd like to meet up and have a chat.
6. Interview them in a similar way you'd interview someone who applied to an advert but work hard to continue 'selling' the opportunity.
If you follow this plan, you'll achieve 2 key things:
1. You'll find yourself meeting and interviewing a larger pool of higher calibre candidates than you could ever hope to find through an advert or an agency.
2. If someone who wasn't actively looking for a job accepts an offer, it'll be because they're genuinely motivated by the opportunity (always a much better bet than someone who is unhappy in their job, looking for an exit route and prepared to take pretty much any job that comes along, even if it's not exactly what they were looking for).
This probably sounds like a lot of hard work and effort but the result is likely to be worth it in the long run (less time spent fixing problems created by a crap manager, or having to replace someone who leaves quite quickly).
1PMA said:
I agree with the people who said approach prospective candidates directly but I'd do it in a more structured way. My answer is based on the premise that it's a decent bar, the vacancy is a reasonably 'attractive' one and your girlfriend is looking for a 'quality' manager. If that's not the case (i.e. if it's a 'rough' bar or the pay is below average) then please ignore. Otherwise...
First things first, I wouldn't advertise and I wouldn't use an agency.
The main problem associated with recruiting 'quality' staff through adverts or agencies is that the better someone is at their job, the less likely they are to be 'actively' looking for a new position (people tend to enjoy doing things they're good at and employers tend to make more of an effort to 'look after' people who are good at their jobs). Whilst it's certainly not impossible to hire someone good through an advert or an agency, it can be extremely hit and miss because the majority of applicants will always be unhappy/disaffected/unmotivated etc.
The way I would approach it is this:
1. Draw up a list of all other local bars that are vaguely comparable (don't include any that are significantly better or worse).
2. Phone them all up and ask for the names of both the manager and the assistant manager (it isn't too difficult to get names if you invent a decent 'cover story' e.g. say you work for XXX and you're sending out invitations to attend a local licensed trade suppliers exhibition or something like that). Might sound a bit underhand but it's a tactic commonly used throughout the entire 'search' profession.
3. Give it a few days and then make a discrete approach by telephone to each of the managers at a time of day when they're likely to be working but not too busy. All you have to say is "Hi, my name is X, I'm the owner of a bar in the local area, I'm looking for a new manager, I've heard you're good at what you do (try to ignore the fact that this is a lie because flattery at this stage is important), I realise you're probably not actively looking for a new position but I'd very much like to have a chat with you on the phone when you're not at work, just to see if the opportunity is something you might be interested in. Would that be OK? Great, can I take a mobile number from you? When would be the best time to call?"
4. If the manager is unreceptive, leave it a few days and call the assistant manager (or get a friend to). There might be some decent assistant managers ready for a step up.
5. Call people outside of work at the appointed time and have a chat with them about the opportunity. Tell them about your business, what the role entails, why it requires someone of their calibre etc. Don't 'blue sky' the opportunity (i.e. paint a picture that the job can't live up to) but work hard to emphasise the 'key selling points' of both you as an employer and the role itself. If the person is receptive, ask them a bit about their current job and work experience. To get someone talking all you need say is something like "You were recommended to me by a friend of a friend (make up a name if necassary) - I've heard you're good at what you do but I don't know much about you - how long have you been working at XX, what did you do before etc?" If they sound (broadly speaking) like what you're looking for, ask them if they'd like to meet up and have a chat.
6. Interview them in a similar way you'd interview someone who applied to an advert but work hard to continue 'selling' the opportunity.
If you follow this plan, you'll achieve 2 key things:
1. You'll find yourself meeting and interviewing a larger pool of higher calibre candidates than you could ever hope to find through an advert or an agency.
2. If someone who wasn't actively looking for a job accepts an offer, it'll be because they're genuinely motivated by the opportunity (always a much better bet than someone who is unhappy in their job, looking for an exit route and prepared to take pretty much any job that comes along, even if it's not exactly what they were looking for).
This probably sounds like a lot of hard work and effort but the result is likely to be worth it in the long run (less time spent fixing problems created by a crap manager, or having to replace someone who leaves quite quickly).
What a fulsome and helpful response! Thanks very, very much indeed.First things first, I wouldn't advertise and I wouldn't use an agency.
The main problem associated with recruiting 'quality' staff through adverts or agencies is that the better someone is at their job, the less likely they are to be 'actively' looking for a new position (people tend to enjoy doing things they're good at and employers tend to make more of an effort to 'look after' people who are good at their jobs). Whilst it's certainly not impossible to hire someone good through an advert or an agency, it can be extremely hit and miss because the majority of applicants will always be unhappy/disaffected/unmotivated etc.
The way I would approach it is this:
1. Draw up a list of all other local bars that are vaguely comparable (don't include any that are significantly better or worse).
2. Phone them all up and ask for the names of both the manager and the assistant manager (it isn't too difficult to get names if you invent a decent 'cover story' e.g. say you work for XXX and you're sending out invitations to attend a local licensed trade suppliers exhibition or something like that). Might sound a bit underhand but it's a tactic commonly used throughout the entire 'search' profession.
3. Give it a few days and then make a discrete approach by telephone to each of the managers at a time of day when they're likely to be working but not too busy. All you have to say is "Hi, my name is X, I'm the owner of a bar in the local area, I'm looking for a new manager, I've heard you're good at what you do (try to ignore the fact that this is a lie because flattery at this stage is important), I realise you're probably not actively looking for a new position but I'd very much like to have a chat with you on the phone when you're not at work, just to see if the opportunity is something you might be interested in. Would that be OK? Great, can I take a mobile number from you? When would be the best time to call?"
4. If the manager is unreceptive, leave it a few days and call the assistant manager (or get a friend to). There might be some decent assistant managers ready for a step up.
5. Call people outside of work at the appointed time and have a chat with them about the opportunity. Tell them about your business, what the role entails, why it requires someone of their calibre etc. Don't 'blue sky' the opportunity (i.e. paint a picture that the job can't live up to) but work hard to emphasise the 'key selling points' of both you as an employer and the role itself. If the person is receptive, ask them a bit about their current job and work experience. To get someone talking all you need say is something like "You were recommended to me by a friend of a friend (make up a name if necassary) - I've heard you're good at what you do but I don't know much about you - how long have you been working at XX, what did you do before etc?" If they sound (broadly speaking) like what you're looking for, ask them if they'd like to meet up and have a chat.
6. Interview them in a similar way you'd interview someone who applied to an advert but work hard to continue 'selling' the opportunity.
If you follow this plan, you'll achieve 2 key things:
1. You'll find yourself meeting and interviewing a larger pool of higher calibre candidates than you could ever hope to find through an advert or an agency.
2. If someone who wasn't actively looking for a job accepts an offer, it'll be because they're genuinely motivated by the opportunity (always a much better bet than someone who is unhappy in their job, looking for an exit route and prepared to take pretty much any job that comes along, even if it's not exactly what they were looking for).
This probably sounds like a lot of hard work and effort but the result is likely to be worth it in the long run (less time spent fixing problems created by a crap manager, or having to replace someone who leaves quite quickly).
Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


