Steve Jobs - Thoughts on Flash
Author
Discussion

Leithen

Original Poster:

14,164 posts

298 months

Thursday 29th April 2010
quotequote all
Thoughts On Flash by Steve Jobs.

Stablelad

3,815 posts

235 months

Thursday 29th April 2010
quotequote all
Thinks it's shyte then? hehe

beakr

1,405 posts

242 months

Thursday 29th April 2010
quotequote all
"Perhaps Adobe should focus more on creating great HTML5 tools for the future, and less on criticizing Apple for leaving the past behind."

jesta1865

3,453 posts

240 months

Thursday 29th April 2010
quotequote all
mans an idiot, doesn't he know how much p0rn he is missing out on smile

HiRich

3,337 posts

293 months

Thursday 29th April 2010
quotequote all
Though Apple have now made the graphics APIs available on the Mac OS (what MS did about a year ago, and the thing that appears to have dramatically improved Flash performance on Windows).

Whilst I dislike Flash, I struggle with Apple's attempts to kill it. Let it die naturally as/if html5 is better. It's a huge and I think unnecessary gamble by Apple - not least with Google apparently flipping and allowing Flash for Android. Suddenly the iPhone & iPad could be the odd men out.

johna

2,328 posts

201 months

Thursday 29th April 2010
quotequote all
Doubt il be gettin a new iphone until flash is available, im sure if every one started buyin android devices instead of iphones then apple would change there view.

Ordinary_Chap

7,520 posts

274 months

Thursday 29th April 2010
quotequote all
HiRich said:
Though Apple have now made the graphics APIs available on the Mac OS (what MS did about a year ago, and the thing that appears to have dramatically improved Flash performance on Windows).

Whilst I dislike Flash, I struggle with Apple's attempts to kill it. Let it die naturally as/if html5 is better. It's a huge and I think unnecessary gamble by Apple - not least with Google apparently flipping and allowing Flash for Android. Suddenly the iPhone & iPad could be the odd men out.
Flash seems to be gaining massive popularity on devices been supported by Android, Blackberry, Nokia and Microsoft.

It appears the rest of the industry doesn't support his views.

I'm a neutral on flash, when used well there is nothing wrong with it but when in the hands of useless developers it can be quite bad, particularly those who make an entire site from it.

tinman0

18,231 posts

271 months

Thursday 29th April 2010
quotequote all
Ordinary_Chap said:
HiRich said:
Though Apple have now made the graphics APIs available on the Mac OS (what MS did about a year ago, and the thing that appears to have dramatically improved Flash performance on Windows).

Whilst I dislike Flash, I struggle with Apple's attempts to kill it. Let it die naturally as/if html5 is better. It's a huge and I think unnecessary gamble by Apple - not least with Google apparently flipping and allowing Flash for Android. Suddenly the iPhone & iPad could be the odd men out.
Flash seems to be gaining massive popularity on devices been supported by Android, Blackberry, Nokia and Microsoft.

It appears the rest of the industry doesn't support his views.

I'm a neutral on flash, when used well there is nothing wrong with it but when in the hands of useless developers it can be quite bad, particularly those who make an entire site from it.
Nah, Flash is over. It's a corpse, just that no one has pronounced it dead quite yet.

The iPad will be the death of Flash for the simple reason that the punter on the street doesn't care about what Flash is. Nor does the owner of the website when he views it on his iPad at home when he shows the wife.

Flash is a geek dead end.

Ordinary_Chap

7,520 posts

274 months

Thursday 29th April 2010
quotequote all
tinman0 said:
Ordinary_Chap said:
HiRich said:
Though Apple have now made the graphics APIs available on the Mac OS (what MS did about a year ago, and the thing that appears to have dramatically improved Flash performance on Windows).

Whilst I dislike Flash, I struggle with Apple's attempts to kill it. Let it die naturally as/if html5 is better. It's a huge and I think unnecessary gamble by Apple - not least with Google apparently flipping and allowing Flash for Android. Suddenly the iPhone & iPad could be the odd men out.
Flash seems to be gaining massive popularity on devices been supported by Android, Blackberry, Nokia and Microsoft.

It appears the rest of the industry doesn't support his views.

I'm a neutral on flash, when used well there is nothing wrong with it but when in the hands of useless developers it can be quite bad, particularly those who make an entire site from it.
Nah, Flash is over. It's a corpse, just that no one has pronounced it dead quite yet.

The iPad will be the death of Flash for the simple reason that the punter on the street doesn't care about what Flash is. Nor does the owner of the website when he views it on his iPad at home when he shows the wife.

Flash is a geek dead end.
Ridiculous.

You may want it dead but clearly it isn't going anywhere for a long time.

Why is it a geek dead end? Bizarre.

tinman0

18,231 posts

271 months

Thursday 29th April 2010
quotequote all
Ordinary_Chap said:
Ridiculous.

You may want it dead but clearly it isn't going anywhere for a long time.

Why is it a geek dead end? Bizarre.
Geek dead end - because people who commission websites aren't geeks. Businessmen (and women) aren't interested in Apple or Adobe or Flash. All they will want is to see their website on a device, which sooner than later will be an iPad or iPhone, or something that doesn't support flash.

And even if they do care about the Apple/Adobe/Flash thing, they won't want to lose a sale to their competitors who will support the same user.

Hence Flash will become a geek dead end, very very quickly.

Ordinary_Chap

7,520 posts

274 months

Thursday 29th April 2010
quotequote all
tinman0 said:
Ordinary_Chap said:
Ridiculous.

You may want it dead but clearly it isn't going anywhere for a long time.

Why is it a geek dead end? Bizarre.
Geek dead end - because people who commission websites aren't geeks. Businessmen (and women) aren't interested in Apple or Adobe or Flash. All they will want is to see their website on a device, which sooner than later will be an iPad or iPhone, or something that doesn't support flash.

And even if they do care about the Apple/Adobe/Flash thing, they won't want to lose a sale to their competitors who will support the same user.

Hence Flash will become a geek dead end, very very quickly.
Flash is on 98% of all computers have flash so websites aren't going to dump flash any time soon, not to mention the cost and expense.

This flash is a geek dead end stuff is just silly and you'll be seeing flash for many years to come like it or not. HTML5 doesn't even have agreed standards for things like video (where flash is most heavily used) so if different developers choose different technologies you'll just end up in the same boat.

I personally don't care if it's flash and/or HTML as long as it's pleasant to use which flash certainly is when programmed correctly but calling it a geek dead end is like calling every technology a geek something or other and makes no sense whatsoever.

The fact all of the other major mobile manufacturers are or have implemented flash on their devices tells you that the industry doesn't agree with Apple.

tinman0

18,231 posts

271 months

Thursday 29th April 2010
quotequote all
Ordinary_Chap said:
The fact all of the other major mobile manufacturers are or have implemented flash on their devices tells you that the industry doesn't agree with Apple.
This isn't about technology.

This is about money and websites making sales. If your website has content that an increasing number of devices (albeit made by Apple) cannot see, then your competitors will get the business. When some CEO shows his new device off to his mate at the golf course, and his mate is sitting there with an iPhone and the site doesn't work, that be when the web designer is paid to remove the Flash components.

No company owner or director gives a toss about the technology that is Flash. All they want is the sale. And that's what will kill Flash. Quicker than you think.

And it's not about "98% of devices can show Flash" either. There is a growing number of devices that can't, and in this case, won't.

Dracoro

9,038 posts

276 months

Thursday 29th April 2010
quotequote all
Ordinary_Chap said:
Flash is on 98% of all computers have flash so websites aren't going to dump flash any time soon, not to mention the cost and expense.
I assume "98%" doesn't include "all" computers such as mobile devices!

Ordinary_Chap said:
The fact all of the other major mobile manufacturers are or have implemented flash on their devices tells you that the industry doesn't agree with Apple.

How do other touch screens deal with flash rollovers for example?

I suspect a lot of the idustry DO agree with Apple, however they have made the market decision to support flash regardless (rightly or wrongly) and this will most likely have been at extra cost. I bet a lot of them would like to have only to deal with H.264 for video.

At the end of the day, the market rules. People want devices such as iPods/iPads etc. more than they want Flash websites. Owners with flash integrated websites have to make the decision as to whether they can live without the catchment market of those using such devices or whether to go with more modern (and arguably a lot better) technologies that ALL webusers can access. This is now more pertinent with people moving towards mobile devices for web browsing.

cs02rm0

13,966 posts

222 months

Thursday 29th April 2010
quotequote all
I agree with Steve, unusually.

Roop

6,018 posts

315 months

Thursday 29th April 2010
quotequote all
Thoughts on Steve Jobs : He's a fücking plank and the sooner he pisses off the better. There's a LOT of content on the web that won't display on my iPhone because of a lack of flash support and I'm sodding well fed up of it. This is Apple arrogance at it's finest...

Dracoro

9,038 posts

276 months

Thursday 29th April 2010
quotequote all
Roop said:
Thoughts on Steve Jobs : He's a fücking plank and the sooner he pisses off the better. There's a LOT of content on the web that won't display on my iPhone because of a lack of flash support and I'm sodding well fed up of it. This is Apple arrogance at it's finest...
Why did you buy an iPhone in the first place then? It's always been pretty well documented and reported that they don't support flash.

Pentoman

4,837 posts

294 months

Thursday 29th April 2010
quotequote all
Flash is rubbish. Not sure this is the way to deal with it for Apple - it's throwing its weight around a bit surely. But I do agree with them - it can be pants sometimes. I would be interested to see if it has to be require so much CPU to decode a simple low res youtube video (more than my PIII 650mhz can handle anyway) or if it's just lazily written and we're stuck with its monopoly.
Don't get me started on Adobe Reader..........
It could be worse, it could be Real Player. Remember when that was more popular than flash or media player? Then they royally screwed it up by turning it into the most bloated, adware ridden utter piece of crap you have ever seen the moment they realised that is was popular and you pretty much had to have it if you were on the net and so they had a captive market. Words can't describe how beastly it was. But now you don't see Real Player anywhere on the web...

tinman0

18,231 posts

271 months

Thursday 29th April 2010
quotequote all
Pentoman said:
It could be worse, it could be Real Player. Remember when that was more popular than flash or media player? Then they royally screwed it up by turning it into the most bloated, adware ridden utter piece of crap you have ever seen the moment they realised that is was popular and you pretty much had to have it if you were on the net and so they had a captive market. Words can't describe how beastly it was. But now you don't see Real Player anywhere on the web...
I'll see your Real Player and raise you Netscape!

There are plenty of innovations on the web that are no more today. Flash will be joining them.

cho

927 posts

306 months

Thursday 29th April 2010
quotequote all
really depends on how people use their mobile devices and what they consider important viewing. A lot of sites i look at (car related) cannot be viewed properly on my iPhone but it doesn't bother me because i'm just passing the time and know i can view the page properly on my pc later. When it gets to the point where i can't perform certain web related functions using my iphone which i can at the moment because of the unavailability of flash (and i don't really see that day coming soon) then i will ditch it for a device that does.

My long winded point is that at the moment all the important web related stuff i do on the iPhone is not flash related so the two are mutually exclusive. In reference to Apple saying that flash eats batteries, at the moment i can't watch youtube on my phone for too long before the batteries go dead so whatever they are doing now is not perfect!

The only reason i won't switch to another phone now is because of the apps i have and the knowledge that more apps are available for the iPhone at the moment. I actually think that the Nexus one (from a non tech persons point of view) is a better phone. Will wait until Iphone 4 comes ot to see if that view changes.

Roop

6,018 posts

315 months

Thursday 29th April 2010
quotequote all
Dracoro said:
Roop said:
Thoughts on Steve Jobs : He's a fücking plank and the sooner he pisses off the better. There's a LOT of content on the web that won't display on my iPhone because of a lack of flash support and I'm sodding well fed up of it. This is Apple arrogance at it's finest...
Why did you buy an iPhone in the first place then? It's always been pretty well documented and reported that they don't support flash.
It might be well documented if you ready technology publications and geeky weblogs and stuff but I don't. I went into the Swisscom shop and bought an upgrade for my ageing Nokia 95. I thought it reasonable to assume the all-singing-all-dancing absolute latest piece of kit would do more than the 2 year old high-end Nokia I had. I am still reeling from the fact that the upgrade included ungraceful app exits at least once a day, random crashes, removal of virtually all multitasking and being tied to possibly the worst piece of software ever written for Windows - namely iTunes. The bloke that sold me the phone mentioned none of this.

I don't want this to become iPhone bashing as we've had enough threads on this but Flash is a given. Not offering it is like selling a car with no windscreen wipers because within 5 years everybody will use some sort of super laser to clear the water off the screen that is miles better that a crappy outdated strip of rubber. Well that's in 5 years, meanwhile I have a bloody half useless piece of kit...!!!

It reminds me of Apple's response to report of a high risk of mugging if seen wearing trademark white-coloure iPod headphones : "People would rather be robbed than wear something less stylish". Unbelievable arrogance.

Edited by Roop on Thursday 29th April 20:33