Don't Want an Iphone - Help Me !!!!
Don't Want an Iphone - Help Me !!!!
Author
Discussion

Pickled Piper

Original Poster:

6,452 posts

266 months

Friday 30th April 2010
quotequote all
OK, I have nothing against the Iphone . We have a couple of Macs at home so quite comfortable with the whole Apple thing, however, the pricing plans that accompany the Iphone gave me a shock.

Her indoors has stipulated that she must be able to Ocado online shop using the phone (is that a unique Iphone app?) would like to have some sort of satnav and be able to pick up her emails and hopefully synch calenders with a mac. Video and good stills camera is expected. Several of her work colleagues have Iphones - I don't want her to suffer from phone envy.

Probably looking at a Vodafone contract.

Can the good people of PH help me?

Thanks in advance.

pp

marctwo

3,666 posts

291 months

Friday 30th April 2010
quotequote all
HTC Desire or Legend.

HellDiver

5,708 posts

213 months

Friday 30th April 2010
quotequote all
Nokia X6.

I got one to replace an iPhone 3G, and the X6 is better in almost every way. The screen is smaller, which would be my only gripe.

MuffDaddy

1,507 posts

236 months

Friday 30th April 2010
quotequote all
The new BlackBerry Pearl launched this week is nice, size wise it is a lot smaller than an iPhone. Not sure the ocodo app works for it though.

Beefmeister

16,482 posts

261 months

Friday 30th April 2010
quotequote all
Pickled Piper said:
We have a couple of Macs at home...

Her indoors has stipulated that she must be able to Ocado online shop using the phone

would like to have some sort of satnav and be able to pick up her emails

hopefully synch calenders with a mac.

Video and good stills camera is expected.

Probably looking at a Vodafone contract.

Can the good people of PH help me?
Yes, buy an iPhone on Vodaphone.



Sorry to be obnoxious, but if she wants all those features, just get her an iPhone. Seriously.

There's a reason why everyone has one. It's not because its fashionable, its not because its Apple, its because it's a damn good smartphone.

HellDiver

5,708 posts

213 months

Friday 30th April 2010
quotequote all
Beefmeister said:
because it's a damn good smartphone.
As long as you can cope with it sucking as an actual phone, and don't mind charging it every 6 hours if you use it as a phone, and can manage with the rubbish signal.

Beefmeister

16,482 posts

261 months

Friday 30th April 2010
quotequote all
HellDiver said:
Beefmeister said:
because it's a damn good smartphone.
As long as you can cope with it sucking as an actual phone, and don't mind charging it every 6 hours if you use it as a phone, and can manage with the rubbish signal.
I find it excellent as a phone. Lots of contacts - dial, can use other functions whilst on a call etc. Don't see the problem.

Every 6 hrs? Don't be soft. I call a lot, and use t'internet a lot, and i charge my 3GS every 2 days.

Rubbish signal - i'll give you that one.

Pickled Piper

Original Poster:

6,452 posts

266 months

Friday 30th April 2010
quotequote all
Beefmeister said:
Pickled Piper said:
We have a couple of Macs at home...

Her indoors has stipulated that she must be able to Ocado online shop using the phone

would like to have some sort of satnav and be able to pick up her emails

hopefully synch calenders with a mac.

Video and good stills camera is expected.

Probably looking at a Vodafone contract.

Can the good people of PH help me?
Yes, buy an iPhone on Vodaphone.



Sorry to be obnoxious, but if she wants all those features, just get her an iPhone. Seriously.

There's a reason why everyone has one. It's not because its fashionable, its not because its Apple, its because it's a damn good smartphone.
No need to apologise. You are not being obnoxious. I, however, am a tightwad and just can't stomach the price plans and 18 month contracts being offered on the Iphone.

pp

HellDiver

5,708 posts

213 months

Friday 30th April 2010
quotequote all
Beefmeister said:
Every 6 hrs? Don't be soft. I call a lot, and use t'internet a lot, and i charge my 3GS every 2 days.

Rubbish signal - i'll give you that one.
My 3G needed charged after 6 hours. Came off the charger at 8am, by lunch time it was complaining about 20% battery, stuck it on charge a few hours during lunch, and by the time I get home it's gurning about 20% battery again. Was like that from new, didn't improve in the year I had it.

That's using it on Bluetooth in the car, Wi-Fi on in work, playing music, Bluetooth headset.

Beefmeister

16,482 posts

261 months

Friday 30th April 2010
quotequote all
I think you had a dud battery in there.

I use bluetooth most of the day, along with Wifi and 3G netting when outside.

On a really bad day it's been down to 10% by bedtime.


On the way to Delhi last week i watched 7hrs of movies on it.

3GS, about 3months old.

Russ T Bolt

1,779 posts

314 months

Friday 30th April 2010
quotequote all
Beefmeister said:
I think you had a dud battery in there.

I use bluetooth most of the day, along with Wifi and 3G netting when outside.

On a really bad day it's been down to 10% by bedtime.


On the way to Delhi last week i watched 7hrs of movies on it.

3GS, about 3months old.
I've not owned one or used one except 'playing' in an O2 shop when they first came out.

But lots of people at work have them and without exception they all have chargers at work because the phones won't last the day apparently. Not sure how old most of them are, but guy who works for me bought one about a month ago, loves it but says the battery life is appalling. It is frequently sat on his desk on charge.

Lefty 200 Drams

21,589 posts

233 months

Friday 30th April 2010
quotequote all
Blackberry. I've had lots of smartphones and none come close.

Aiten

540 posts

221 months

Friday 30th April 2010
quotequote all
HTC Desire
HTC Legend
SE X10
Nokia X6

iPhone is a good piece of kit, but its not worth hundreds more than a HTC Desire.

You really want an Android phone. Its the only operating system that has an app store than is remotely competitve with Apple's, with about 1/3 the apps avaliable - this will grow though.

To avoid the sheep look, the new iPhone will be announced over the summer (see the Gizmodo news at the moment), so perhaps being ahead of the crowd with a new shape iPhone as soon as they are released avoid that look for a few months?

I would still suggest a HTC Desire, but watch out for the FUP on networks.

Beefmeister

16,482 posts

261 months

Friday 30th April 2010
quotequote all
Lefty 200 Drams said:
Blackberry. I've had lots of smartphones and none come close to being as useless as anything other than an email device...
EFA

Emeye

9,781 posts

254 months

Friday 30th April 2010
quotequote all
Don't buy a HTC Hero - I have one and it is useless - it is too sluggish - my mate has a HTC Desire and that seems much better.

Pickled Piper

Original Poster:

6,452 posts

266 months

Friday 30th April 2010
quotequote all
marctwo said:
HTC Desire or Legend.
How are Mac people getting on with these phones. I have read there are compatibility issues?

pp

sadako

7,080 posts

269 months

Friday 30th April 2010
quotequote all
Pickled Piper said:
marctwo said:
HTC Desire or Legend.
How are Mac people getting on with these phones. I have read there are compatibility issues?

pp
There are issues that are being worked on, however, you don't need to connect android phones to computers very often if at all. When I do I almost always use USB mass storage mode on the phone anyway which makes the computer pick it up as a pen drive, and you just copy pictures and music to the phone.

I am currently looking at a Desire but it will be summer before I can renew my contract anyway. I would agree that the 600mhz chip on the older android phones is a bit slow so at the moment you are looking at a a nexus one, a desire, or something nokia/symbian/maemo.

There is an "Ocado on the go" application on Android which has a 4.5 star (of 5) rating and good reviews.

MaximumJed

745 posts

263 months

Friday 30th April 2010
quotequote all
I have a Hero and the wife has a Desire, never connect them to a computer unless I want to transfer files as a usb drive. Hero isn't that slow with the updates and if you occasionally use a task killer to clear some memory, however the Desire is much better.

The Hero was also recently replaced by the Legend, which has a little more power and is made from a single piece of aluminium, so it looks good and is pretty sturdy too.

off_again

13,917 posts

265 months

Friday 30th April 2010
quotequote all
Nexus One coming to Voda shortly - so maybe look at one of those? Android phones have the ability to be VERY successful, but they are not quite there yet. But they are cheap, constantly upgrade / updated and there are lots of personalisation options. iPhones are good, but clearly not for everyone.