Who can sign a direct debit mandate for a limited company?
Who can sign a direct debit mandate for a limited company?
Author
Discussion

teapea

Original Poster:

693 posts

217 months

Tuesday 4th May 2010
quotequote all
We are having a bit of an issue at work where as one of our staff was miss sold a service, and were basically conned into singing up for it.
The jist is, they have singed a form on a computer screen,
Within a few seconds of doing this an email was received by me showing that this had been singed up for and i immediately emailed and telephoned them saying we do not want this service.

However they refused to cancel it and are now demanding money.
I have informed them that as far as I am concerned the product has been miss sold and further more, the signature they are using on their "contract" and direct debit is not that of a director or anyone authorised to sign for this.
Their response is that in a limited company it does not matter who signs the direct debit, all that matters is they have a signature from a member of staff, and it doesn't matter if it's the tea boy or whoever, as long as they have a signature of someone who works there.
Is this correct? As I was under the impression that they would have to be a director, but they say this is not the case with a limited company and that it's a training issue with us and are demanding money from us for a service we do not want or intend to use.
Thanks for your help smile

RYH64E

7,960 posts

275 months

Tuesday 4th May 2010
quotequote all
The bank should only accept the instruction from an approved signatory to the bank account, the same people who are authorised to sign Company cheques. I suppose that other people within the organisation would be able to enter into a contract with a supplier, but they should have no authority to instruct the bank to make a payment.

xllifts

3,724 posts

234 months

Tuesday 4th May 2010
quotequote all
We had a similar issue a while back and discovered that it is only the people who have banking authorisation and are named at the bank ie cheque signers, not nessecarily all director, who can sign a mandate. Your bank should have rejected the direct debt as it was not signed by an 'authorised' person, if they have let it through you need to be asking your bank some serious questions. As for the company demanding money, remind them they have commited 'fraud' and 'gaining monies by deception' and would they like you to take them to court, never failed yet on the scare/hound you style companies.

HTH

Powderpuff

355 posts

280 months

Tuesday 4th May 2010
quotequote all
A direct debit mandate should only be signable by an 'authorised signatory' with the bank, that person could be a director or anyone else who has been given the authority. The bank should not accept a signature from anyone who isn't authorised.

A contract however can be signed by anyone who 'holds themselves out' as having the authority to sign the agreement, if the other party is acting in good faith then they may have a binding contract, so the answer is no, it doesn't have to be a director.

Have a look
here

As for whether they are acting in good faith....if it's being mis-sold maybe not!


miniman

30,238 posts

293 months

Tuesday 4th May 2010
quotequote all
How was the service sold? Over the phone or web? Surely in that case distance selling regs would come into play with their statutory cooling off period (14 days IIRC)?

Powderpuff

355 posts

280 months

Tuesday 4th May 2010
quotequote all
Distance selling regs don't apply to business to business contracts, only business to consumer.

miniman

30,238 posts

293 months

Tuesday 4th May 2010
quotequote all
Powderpuff said:
Distance selling regs don't apply to business to business contracts, only business to consumer.
Interesting, didn't know that.

teapea

Original Poster:

693 posts

217 months

Tuesday 4th May 2010
quotequote all
The sales guy came in and tried to flog the product, he was told by the member of staff they had no authority to sign up for the product as they were not a director, the chap said that was fine, and could he sign the computer screen to say that he had been in, which they did, the rest is history.

Hm oh well will fight it out, thanks for the info. guys, I was always under the impressions only someone authorised to sign cheques etc by the bank was authorised to sign into a contract (which is £50 a week for the service) which we don't want, and is a complete rip off !


pugwash4x4

7,684 posts

252 months

Tuesday 4th May 2010
quotequote all
cancel the direct debit- tell them to start court proceedings

the end.

biggrin

Great Pretender

26,140 posts

245 months

Tuesday 4th May 2010
quotequote all
Powderpuff said:
A direct debit mandate should only be signable by an 'authorised signatory' with the bank, that person could be a director or anyone else who has been given the authority. The bank should not accept a signature from anyone who isn't authorised.

A contract however can be signed by anyone who 'holds themselves out' as having the authority to sign the agreement, if the other party is acting in good faith then they may have a binding contract, so the answer is no, it doesn't have to be a director.

Have a look
here

As for whether they are acting in good faith....if it's being mis-sold maybe not!
Correct.

Sounds like the company concerned is in hot water.

ClassicMercs

1,703 posts

212 months

Tuesday 4th May 2010
quotequote all
bds

It wasn't a photocopier - franking machine - telephone type company by chance.

Also - contact your local trading standards office through your County Council - they like to list events from the same company on a national database and use the catalogue to take action.

john_p

7,073 posts

281 months

Tuesday 4th May 2010
quotequote all
No question that the direct debit can't go through without the signatories signing a mandate

BUT say as an employee I sign a contract saying the company will pay money for something - can the company be taken to court if it doesn't pay up ?

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Tuesday 4th May 2010
quotequote all
pugwash4x4 said:
cancel the direct debit- tell them to start court proceedings

the end.

biggrin
That may sound simple, but that is the answer.

Possession is 9 tenths of the law. You have your money. There is nothing they can do apart from sue you to get it.

Cancel the direct debit, and write a short letter explaining that you have been missold and on that basis you are cancelling the contract.

You will hear no more.

teapea

Original Poster:

693 posts

217 months

Tuesday 4th May 2010
quotequote all
It was a company selling google adwords type advertising basically, what they were saying is they will guarantee "2400 sales leads" a year for £47 a week.
But what they class as a "sales lead" can be either a phone call or a click onto your site. i.e. a click onto your site.
So just very expensive and also irrelevant from the "order" they have sent through the the words they have "picked" for us google adwords,
Cheers.

11SJC

643 posts

275 months

Wednesday 5th May 2010
quotequote all
ClassicMercs said:
bds

It wasn't a photocopier - franking machine - telephone type company by chance.

Also - contact your local trading standards office through your County Council - they like to list events from the same company on a national database and use the catalogue to take action.
not all photocopy agents are that bad

jon-

16,534 posts

247 months

Wednesday 5th May 2010
quotequote all
teapea said:
It was a company selling google adwords type advertising basically, what they were saying is they will guarantee "2400 sales leads" a year for £47 a week.
But what they class as a "sales lead" can be either a phone call or a click onto your site. i.e. a click onto your site.
So just very expensive and also irrelevant from the "order" they have sent through the the words they have "picked" for us google adwords,
Cheers.
That's just under a pound a click so most likely a rip off.

Alternatively you could let them honour the traffic, but setup a new target website advertising something like lawyers or gambling (or both) where the cost per click can be upwards of a fiver.

teapea

Original Poster:

693 posts

217 months

Wednesday 5th May 2010
quotequote all
Cheers Jon, that crossed my mind also, we sell staircases, I already use google adwords and it costs me between 25p and 40p per click, and we come 3rd usually, a little bit of a rip off to go from that to £1 per click and to loose all control over the adverts so one of their "experts" can write them for us smile