Cracked alloys
Cracked alloys
Author
Discussion

briers

Original Poster:

873 posts

210 months

Wednesday 5th May 2010
quotequote all
Just about to plump some cash on a 335d which as 19inch alloys

Are these cracking alloys really a significant issue. Car hasn't had MOT yet, so the cracks could be lying in wait / unknown.


Whats the policy these days with BMW. Last thing i want to do is pay out a lot of cash for the car and end up with a massive wheel bill.



ta

briers

Original Poster:

873 posts

210 months

Wednesday 5th May 2010
quotequote all
I must admit the dealers service were a bit cagey about the wheel issue when I phoned earlier.

They explained it was down to BMW HQ but its still a possible 2k bill. Apparently 30 cars a day at local dealer with 2 historical claims. 30 a day. ... really!

I have found one but the deals not closed yet. Fingers crossed. But mot not due yet and don't like the thought of a big bill like that. Must admit, has made me think twice. Which disappoints me because its a superb car.

briers

Original Poster:

873 posts

210 months

Wednesday 5th May 2010
quotequote all
Cheers, yea it's an e92 - i just got home and had a look around for this issue and it's quite prominent.

This worried me especially: http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/watchdog/2009/10/bmw_al...


Now i've got to seriously think about this. I'm amazed that they could compromise such an epic car with the very thing that connects us to the road. And it's not like i have much choice. Most 2nd hand, well specc-ed 335d's come with 19's.



liquidken

1,816 posts

272 months

Wednesday 5th May 2010
quotequote all
I can't think of any machine where the bead breakers even come into contact with the wheel.

The main issues are the weight of the cars, the size of the alloys, suspension stifness,the lack of deflection in very stiff run-flat tyres and the state of the UK roads.
The single largest complaint for damaged tyres in the UK is for impact damage. On standard tyres, this is normally manifested as a bulge which is easy to see. Not so easy on a run-flat tyre.

When you consider the above, it's not hard to understand why wheels are suffering the way they do. Vauxhall have had issues on their 19" rims, too. If you do a bit of digging around, you'll find the UK appears to have more complaints compared to other areas of Europe which does re-inforce the road quality argument to boot.

The bottom line is that you're asking a lot from the wheels and tyres given the influences acting upon them.

briers

Original Poster:

873 posts

210 months

Wednesday 5th May 2010
quotequote all
I agree, 19's are unsuitable for UK roads. The side wall hight is so small. They don't offer any performance benefits and in fact weight more and i think increase resistance. The RF's don't give natural flex and therefore dissipate quite a lot of energy into the alloy.

I drove a 330i with 19's on a 59 plate and the car was weaving from side to side at high speeds on the test drive. The bloke put it down to the RF's and the bumpy road. I've never experienced that before. I had to fight the wheel whilst i slowed down. God knows what its like in the wet.

I drove a m-sport 335d with standard 18's in the wet and didn't get any issues.


Now i'm thinking of holding out for a 335d with 18's, SE trim too, if what i read is true about the SE 335d having the same suspension but different springs and dampers.

GTEYE

2,510 posts

241 months

Wednesday 14th December 2016
quotequote all
briers said:
I agree, 19's are unsuitable for UK roads. The side wall hight is so small. They don't offer any performance benefits and in fact weight more and i think increase resistance. The RF's don't give natural flex and therefore dissipate quite a lot of energy into the alloy.

I drove a 330i with 19's on a 59 plate and the car was weaving from side to side at high speeds on the test drive. The bloke put it down to the RF's and the bumpy road. I've never experienced that before. I had to fight the wheel whilst i slowed down. God knows what its like in the wet.

I drove a m-sport 335d with standard 18's in the wet and didn't get any issues.


Now i'm thinking of holding out for a 335d with 18's, SE trim too, if what i read is true about the SE 335d having the same suspension but different springs and dampers.
Whilst there are horror stories out there, people that have had problems are the ones you hear about.

I've got an E93 330d m Sport Convertible with the 19s and I haven't had a problem - certainly if the car you drove was weaving from side to side I'd say there was some other issue with that example as they shouldn't be like that. Mine is just as stable as its E92 330d Coupe predecessor (which had 18s).

I guess it might depend on locally how bad your roads are - if you are repeatedly hitting potholes you'll crack alloys on any brand of car, not just BMWs.

But the main point is - not everyone has a problem...

GTEYE

2,510 posts

241 months

Wednesday 14th December 2016
quotequote all
BMWCrackedAlloys said:
32,000 miles 320d M sport convertible - Both back alloys have failed. 6 cracks on the off side and now a crack appearing on the nearside. Spent >£2,000 in 10 months on tyres, welding and replacement alloy. Been through 5 tyres on the back axel alone since February 2016 - one tyre (few months old) disconnected itself from the alloy wheel whilst I was driving (August 16). Thank God I'm an experienced driver and managed to control the car. Purchased a new rear alloy for £630 in August 2016 from BMW Broad Oak in Ashford, Kent. Now the other wheel has developed it's first crack - failing it's MOT - Spoke to BMW Customer service and they said speak to the dealer so I did...Service Manager at Broad Oak wants £78.00 just to inspect the wheel. Took it up with BMW customer services but the nice young lady was unable to get her manager to waive the inspection fee. In my view being asked to pay £78.00 to just assess the problem is adding insult to injury - heads should be hung in shame! It's not just me, I know someone else who got rid of their BMW 3 series coupe with the same 19 inch wheels for exactly the same reason.
I hope looking at your user name that this experience hasn't ruined your life...


Edited by GTEYE on Wednesday 14th December 15:20