Catch22 - Corp tax
Discussion
Hi,
I thought I should change my username for this one.. I have been running a ltd company for just over two years and I hold my hands up from the start that it has been badly managed to the extent that I now owe £20,000 Corporation tax plus around £6,0000 from my self assessment in tax from dividends paid. I have been too busy keeping the company going and not spent enough time keeping the books up to date and working with my accountant which is how this figure has come out of the blue.
I think I am in a catch 22 situation as I have paid out too much in dividends and therefore there is not enough money in the account to pay what is due (CT plus a little Vat) and I cannot pay back the dividends as that is spent. I want to pay back the money back but I believe the company is now (technically) insolvent and no longer allowed to trade?? Will I have to open a new company to carry on earning and to live and pay back what I owe?
I thought I should change my username for this one.. I have been running a ltd company for just over two years and I hold my hands up from the start that it has been badly managed to the extent that I now owe £20,000 Corporation tax plus around £6,0000 from my self assessment in tax from dividends paid. I have been too busy keeping the company going and not spent enough time keeping the books up to date and working with my accountant which is how this figure has come out of the blue.
I think I am in a catch 22 situation as I have paid out too much in dividends and therefore there is not enough money in the account to pay what is due (CT plus a little Vat) and I cannot pay back the dividends as that is spent. I want to pay back the money back but I believe the company is now (technically) insolvent and no longer allowed to trade?? Will I have to open a new company to carry on earning and to live and pay back what I owe?
HMRC are being surprisingly helpful when it comes to arranging payment terms for overdue tax at the moment, have you given them a ring to discuss paying the arrears in instalments?
Do you have significant other creditors (suppliers, employees etc.)? These will have a bearing on how easy it is to wrap up the old company and start a new one.
Do you have significant other creditors (suppliers, employees etc.)? These will have a bearing on how easy it is to wrap up the old company and start a new one.
Notwhoyouthink said:
Hi,
I have paid out too much in dividends and therefore there is not enough money in the account to pay what is due (CT plus a little Vat) and I cannot pay back the dividends as that is spent. I want to pay back the money back but I believe the company is now (technically) insolvent and no longer allowed to trade?? Will I have to open a new company to carry on earning and to live and pay back what I owe?
How can you take a dividend when the profits (after CT) were not there to generate them?I have paid out too much in dividends and therefore there is not enough money in the account to pay what is due (CT plus a little Vat) and I cannot pay back the dividends as that is spent. I want to pay back the money back but I believe the company is now (technically) insolvent and no longer allowed to trade?? Will I have to open a new company to carry on earning and to live and pay back what I owe?
I am no expert and I am sure Eric Mc will be the oracle as usual, but do you already have a suit with little arrows on?
Hi thanks for the replies.
I have tried HMRC but they just said not to take more money out of the company unless there is enough to pay the liabilities and that I shouldn't have done it and my company is insolvent. I somehow need to work and earn money and pay off my debt to them.
I have no other creditors. Yes I have taken dividends when the profits (after CT, in theory) were not there.
Heres hoping Eric Mc looks in.
I have tried HMRC but they just said not to take more money out of the company unless there is enough to pay the liabilities and that I shouldn't have done it and my company is insolvent. I somehow need to work and earn money and pay off my debt to them.
I have no other creditors. Yes I have taken dividends when the profits (after CT, in theory) were not there.
Heres hoping Eric Mc looks in.
plasticpig said:
It is obvious you are not competent to run your own company. My advice would be to wind up the company; petition for personal bankruptcy; then seek full time employment.
Harsh and not true,Running a company is a massive learning curve, I hope he will learn from the error and move the business forward.
Good luck with everything, pretty crap situation to be in!
Notwhoyouthink said:
Thanks for all the replies.
Plastic pig - Yes I do feel incompetent right now but why would I need to apply for personal bankruptcy?
Chris_Ocr - Yes its a crap situation that is all my own doing so now ive got to get myself out of it. Cheers
If you can pay off the 6K you owe in income tax you don't; or if you can come to an arrangement with HMRC over a repayment plan you don't. If your income tax is due January 2011 rather than being due Jan 2010 the you don't either. Plastic pig - Yes I do feel incompetent right now but why would I need to apply for personal bankruptcy?
Chris_Ocr - Yes its a crap situation that is all my own doing so now ive got to get myself out of it. Cheers
You may not even need to wind the company up if you can trade out of your current position very quickly. It has been done but it's a high risk strategy.
plasticpig said:
If you can pay off the 6K you owe in income tax you don't; or if you can come to an arrangement with HMRC over a repayment plan you don't. If your income tax is due January 2011 rather than being due Jan 2010 the you don't either.
You may not even need to wind the company up if you can trade out of your current position very quickly. It has been done but it's a high risk strategy.
I cant pay off the 6k immediately, but will in instalments. I just cant see how I am able to carry on trading with this company in the current position. I think I have no option but to leave this one open with the debts and open a new one and run it properly and pay off the other debts in instalments. Is this even possible?You may not even need to wind the company up if you can trade out of your current position very quickly. It has been done but it's a high risk strategy.
Notwhoyouthink said:
plasticpig said:
If you can pay off the 6K you owe in income tax you don't; or if you can come to an arrangement with HMRC over a repayment plan you don't. If your income tax is due January 2011 rather than being due Jan 2010 the you don't either.
You may not even need to wind the company up if you can trade out of your current position very quickly. It has been done but it's a high risk strategy.
I cant pay off the 6k immediately, but will in instalments. I just cant see how I am able to carry on trading with this company in the current position. I think I have no option but to leave this one open with the debts and open a new one and run it properly and pay off the other debts in instalments. Is this even possible?You may not even need to wind the company up if you can trade out of your current position very quickly. It has been done but it's a high risk strategy.
It does seem that your accountant let you down to some extent.
Did he/she not warn you of the implications of excessive dividends?
Did he/she not suggest some alternative methods of dealing with the excessive amounts taken out by you?
How close to the various filing deadlines were your accounts and personal tax returns prepared?
It sounds like there isn't a lot you can do except -
Work like a dog to try and generate as much income in the company as you can. This (hopefully) will ptrovide the inward cash flow to allow the company's Corporation Tax and your personal Income Taxes to be paid.
Also, cut back as much as possible on the amounts you are drawing from teh company. Not easy to do, of course, but, for a while anyway, you will have to reconsider seriously what you are spending personally.
How much of your Income Tax liability relates to Payments omn Account for 2010/11?
Moving forward, what type of remuneration strategy have you established for taking personal money fromm your company in the future? What is you dividend/salary mix?
Did he/she not warn you of the implications of excessive dividends?
Did he/she not suggest some alternative methods of dealing with the excessive amounts taken out by you?
How close to the various filing deadlines were your accounts and personal tax returns prepared?
It sounds like there isn't a lot you can do except -
Work like a dog to try and generate as much income in the company as you can. This (hopefully) will ptrovide the inward cash flow to allow the company's Corporation Tax and your personal Income Taxes to be paid.
Also, cut back as much as possible on the amounts you are drawing from teh company. Not easy to do, of course, but, for a while anyway, you will have to reconsider seriously what you are spending personally.
How much of your Income Tax liability relates to Payments omn Account for 2010/11?
Moving forward, what type of remuneration strategy have you established for taking personal money fromm your company in the future? What is you dividend/salary mix?
Edited by Eric Mc on Thursday 6th May 07:43
HMRC wiil pursue any moneys owed to them. At the moment, because of the recession they are supposed to be operating a "light touch" regime - although I haven't seen a huge amount of evidence for this.
What surprises me about this case is that -
i) the director allowed the situation to develop without realising there might be tax problems down the line
ii) the accountant didn't advise him of the implications or seemingly come up with a strategy that might have mitigated the tax impact.
I would have been inclined to try and treat the excessive amounts taken by the director as an overdrawn loan account rather than a dividend. This would have had short term Section 419 Corporation Tax implications but S419 tax will be refunded to the company when the overdrawn Director's Loan account balance is cleared - so it is only a temporary liability.
Once a dividend is drawn, Income Tax will be paid and you will not get that back.
There would have been no Income Tax liability arising.
There are PAYE implications of interest free loans given to directors but the tax arising on such loans will generally be a lot less than the tax on a dividend.
The only time dividends are "tax free" is when the tax payer's overall income in a given tax year is not high enough to put him/her into the Higher Rate tax brackets. I am assumimng in all the above that the OP must have had income greater than the Higher Rate thresholds or otherwise HMRC would not be pursuing him for Income Tax on the dividend amounts he paid himself.
(As the OP is remaining anonymous - I just hope he isn't one of MY clients
).
What surprises me about this case is that -
i) the director allowed the situation to develop without realising there might be tax problems down the line
ii) the accountant didn't advise him of the implications or seemingly come up with a strategy that might have mitigated the tax impact.
I would have been inclined to try and treat the excessive amounts taken by the director as an overdrawn loan account rather than a dividend. This would have had short term Section 419 Corporation Tax implications but S419 tax will be refunded to the company when the overdrawn Director's Loan account balance is cleared - so it is only a temporary liability.
Once a dividend is drawn, Income Tax will be paid and you will not get that back.
There would have been no Income Tax liability arising.
There are PAYE implications of interest free loans given to directors but the tax arising on such loans will generally be a lot less than the tax on a dividend.
The only time dividends are "tax free" is when the tax payer's overall income in a given tax year is not high enough to put him/her into the Higher Rate tax brackets. I am assumimng in all the above that the OP must have had income greater than the Higher Rate thresholds or otherwise HMRC would not be pursuing him for Income Tax on the dividend amounts he paid himself.
(As the OP is remaining anonymous - I just hope he isn't one of MY clients
).hornetrider said:
Eric - I trust in cases like this, where perhaps the company is declared insolvent with large CT liability- that HMRC will pursue the Director for the same?
That very much depends on the circumstances. A plea of incompetence can go a long way to mitigate the situation. What HMRC dislike are people who think they are clever and try to hide and evade the problem. Someone holding their hands up and saying they totally screwed up are far more likely to get away with it.Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


