Discussion
Annoyingly a friend of mine is now too looking for a new car. I think it’s spurred on by my decision to sell mine. Luckily he is an Audi man and is selling his TT 225 and not going down my chosen route… The M3.
He was asking me about cars as I am always talking about them and unfortunately I know not as much as I thought on the vehicles he mentioned. I checked on Whatcar for readers reports but did not get far.
Anyone here own a S5, TTS, TT RS? How do you find their performance, running costs and MPG?
I still reckon the M3 is the way to go!
He was asking me about cars as I am always talking about them and unfortunately I know not as much as I thought on the vehicles he mentioned. I checked on Whatcar for readers reports but did not get far.
Anyone here own a S5, TTS, TT RS? How do you find their performance, running costs and MPG?
I still reckon the M3 is the way to go!
First of all, which M3 are you comparing these cars with? E46 or current E90/92?
I don't own any in that list, although I have driven both the S5 Coupe and TT-RS.
The S5 was an automatic - definately NOT the transmission to get! The torque converter was far too abrupt under full load. Having driven alot of autos, this gearbox isn't the best one out there, IMO.
The car it's self, was fantastic, though. The V8 offered in the Coupe has spades of torque and power, the quattro system really putting down the power well!
The cabin was such a pleasent place to be. The seats are very supportive and the Audis MMI is very intuitive.
The car also has a fantastic V8 engine and exhaust note! Being a sizeable coupe, there's alot of weight shifting around, however it does handle reasonably well.
Compared the a current M3, it's certainly not as good, but would be more than a match for an E46, I would say.
The TT-RS is an awesome piece of kit. The manual gearbox and quattro system work extremely well with the 5-pot Turbo motor. This sounds lovely, akin to the 5-cylinder quattros of the 80s. Again, the cabin is superbly put together. Now this car is a serious performance match for a current M3! It's faster than my RS4, for goodness sake! It also handles VERY well. I wouldn't say it's quite as good as an R8, but noticably better than an S5 or my RS4. The only thing which let it down during my drive was the braking system. It wasn't bad, although it wasn't as good as the RS4. For such a zippy little rocket, I would have expected slightly better brakes.
Unforunately, I have no experience of a TT-S, but I hope, what I have written, helps yo and your friend
The best bet is to get your friend down to a dealer to test drive the cars he's deciding between
Darren
I don't own any in that list, although I have driven both the S5 Coupe and TT-RS.
The S5 was an automatic - definately NOT the transmission to get! The torque converter was far too abrupt under full load. Having driven alot of autos, this gearbox isn't the best one out there, IMO.
The car it's self, was fantastic, though. The V8 offered in the Coupe has spades of torque and power, the quattro system really putting down the power well!
The cabin was such a pleasent place to be. The seats are very supportive and the Audis MMI is very intuitive.
The car also has a fantastic V8 engine and exhaust note! Being a sizeable coupe, there's alot of weight shifting around, however it does handle reasonably well.
Compared the a current M3, it's certainly not as good, but would be more than a match for an E46, I would say.
The TT-RS is an awesome piece of kit. The manual gearbox and quattro system work extremely well with the 5-pot Turbo motor. This sounds lovely, akin to the 5-cylinder quattros of the 80s. Again, the cabin is superbly put together. Now this car is a serious performance match for a current M3! It's faster than my RS4, for goodness sake! It also handles VERY well. I wouldn't say it's quite as good as an R8, but noticably better than an S5 or my RS4. The only thing which let it down during my drive was the braking system. It wasn't bad, although it wasn't as good as the RS4. For such a zippy little rocket, I would have expected slightly better brakes.
Unforunately, I have no experience of a TT-S, but I hope, what I have written, helps yo and your friend

The best bet is to get your friend down to a dealer to test drive the cars he's deciding between

Darren
Was the S5 a auto? I recommended a manual for him to test. Was there a lack of power in the S5? I have been reading about S5's not deliverying power as owners want.
Lol.. i googled the S5 mpg.. approx 12mpg!
Also.. I was comparing to the E90 M3 as that is what I want to get. Hopefully the M3 will be good enough to beat his next car. I am sure he will remap.. if poss.
Lol.. i googled the S5 mpg.. approx 12mpg!
Also.. I was comparing to the E90 M3 as that is what I want to get. Hopefully the M3 will be good enough to beat his next car. I am sure he will remap.. if poss.
The S5 had a auto 'box option. It just so happened that the dealer only had an automatic Demo at the time. Manual transmission is standard.
I really didn't feel the S5 was lacking any power. In fact it's got ~10 lb/ft more torque than the RS4's engine! 350-ish bhp from the S5's engine meant it was quick enough.
The S5 wouldn't be a handling or "off-the-mark" match for an E90 M3. Mid range, it maybe more of a match, as the S5 had more torque than an M3.
I'm not too sure how accurate that MPG figure is! My RS4 averages around 18-20 MPG across most tankfuls (and that's with a decent mixture of town, country and dual carriageway driving).
I had the S5 for a day. I'm not sure about the MPG figure, but I used around £40 of fuel
Out of the box, a TT-RS will be more of a match for an M3.
Also, the TT-RS would be a better candidate for tuning (on a £
erformance ratio).
Obviously the downside of a TT-S and TT-RS is that it is only a 2 seater.
Darren
I really didn't feel the S5 was lacking any power. In fact it's got ~10 lb/ft more torque than the RS4's engine! 350-ish bhp from the S5's engine meant it was quick enough.
The S5 wouldn't be a handling or "off-the-mark" match for an E90 M3. Mid range, it maybe more of a match, as the S5 had more torque than an M3.
I'm not too sure how accurate that MPG figure is! My RS4 averages around 18-20 MPG across most tankfuls (and that's with a decent mixture of town, country and dual carriageway driving).
I had the S5 for a day. I'm not sure about the MPG figure, but I used around £40 of fuel

Out of the box, a TT-RS will be more of a match for an M3.
Also, the TT-RS would be a better candidate for tuning (on a £
erformance ratio).Obviously the downside of a TT-S and TT-RS is that it is only a 2 seater.
Darren
I have an S5 and its an auto. I think the auto is much more suited to the car, but the caviat is that I certainly don't chuck the car about or go for vmax all the time. I use it as my day to day car and for that purpose it is brilliant. Its quick, sounds nice, very smooth and all the kit works, as you would expect. The interior is a nice place to be and it'll do 3-400 miles a day without any worries at all and I can still function at the end of it!
Discounting the caviat above when you do want to go quickly its great and it handles much better than you would expect for a car of its bulk. If you are pushing on make sure its in sport mode and use the paddles, it has a different feel to the standard day to day auto mode.
MPG can be painful, single figures giving some off lights etc, but generally I can get high teens in traffic, maybe lower in central London, and on a motorway run as long as there is not too much stop start its high 20s although I have seen low 30s every now and again. Its not the car to buy if MPG is a worry!
I have also driven the TTRS, I would agree with what has been said above. The only thing I found was that the engine was so good that it felt like the rest of the car was playing catch up. Its a massively different car to the S5, I would have thought you either want one or the other, they are not really compariable. I haven't driven the TTS.
Get your mate to drive them all and se what goes. Also, considering the current lead times for Audi, what about looking at the RS5?
Discounting the caviat above when you do want to go quickly its great and it handles much better than you would expect for a car of its bulk. If you are pushing on make sure its in sport mode and use the paddles, it has a different feel to the standard day to day auto mode.
MPG can be painful, single figures giving some off lights etc, but generally I can get high teens in traffic, maybe lower in central London, and on a motorway run as long as there is not too much stop start its high 20s although I have seen low 30s every now and again. Its not the car to buy if MPG is a worry!
I have also driven the TTRS, I would agree with what has been said above. The only thing I found was that the engine was so good that it felt like the rest of the car was playing catch up. Its a massively different car to the S5, I would have thought you either want one or the other, they are not really compariable. I haven't driven the TTS.
Get your mate to drive them all and se what goes. Also, considering the current lead times for Audi, what about looking at the RS5?
Twit said:
I have an S5 and its an auto. I think the auto is much more suited to the car, but the caviat is that I certainly don't chuck the car about or go for vmax all the time. I use it as my day to day car and for that purpose it is brilliant. Its quick, sounds nice, very smooth and all the kit works, as you would expect.
Discounting the caviat above when you do want to go quickly its great and it handles much better than you would expect for a car of its bulk. If you are pushing on make sure its in sport mode and use the paddles, it has a different feel to the standard day to day auto mode.
Many thanks for the insight into owning the auto version Discounting the caviat above when you do want to go quickly its great and it handles much better than you would expect for a car of its bulk. If you are pushing on make sure its in sport mode and use the paddles, it has a different feel to the standard day to day auto mode.
During the day I had it, there wasn't too much city driving, most of the miles covered were "pressing on".
It certainly highlights the difference between having a demonstrator for a day, and actually driving one day in, day out

Despite what I have said about the gearbox, I did find the paddles great down twisty A- and B-Roads

Darren
Edited by iluvmercs on Thursday 6th May 21:44
I'll chime in for the TT-S then but it's very much a 'junior' version of the comments on the RS above.
It's both deceptively and surprisingly quick and a very well balanced package. The bigger TFSI doesn't sound amazing but it's reasonable on fuel, hills of torque for plodding around and with the bigger turbo is a lot keener to rev (and rev hard it does) than its siblings. massively tunable too. Cabin is a lovely place to be and standard kit is reasonable, doesn't need as much dosh in options as many Audis do.
Residual values have been firm since launch.
It's both deceptively and surprisingly quick and a very well balanced package. The bigger TFSI doesn't sound amazing but it's reasonable on fuel, hills of torque for plodding around and with the bigger turbo is a lot keener to rev (and rev hard it does) than its siblings. massively tunable too. Cabin is a lovely place to be and standard kit is reasonable, doesn't need as much dosh in options as many Audis do.
Residual values have been firm since launch.
Dr G said:
I'll chime in for the TT-S then but it's very much a 'junior' version of the comments on the RS above.
It's both deceptively and surprisingly quick and a very well balanced package. The bigger TFSI doesn't sound amazing but it's reasonable on fuel, hills of torque for plodding around and with the bigger turbo is a lot keener to rev (and rev hard it does) than its siblings. massively tunable too. Cabin is a lovely place to be and standard kit is reasonable, doesn't need as much dosh in options as many Audis do.
Residual values have been firm since launch.
Indeed, the TT s does look nice inside. Prices are doing well too. I wonder how different the TT RS is to the TTS. TTRS have dropped to 40k now on autotrader, TTS are approx 28k. 12k diff but i suppose for the same years the price diff is approx 8k. Fair bit...It's both deceptively and surprisingly quick and a very well balanced package. The bigger TFSI doesn't sound amazing but it's reasonable on fuel, hills of torque for plodding around and with the bigger turbo is a lot keener to rev (and rev hard it does) than its siblings. massively tunable too. Cabin is a lovely place to be and standard kit is reasonable, doesn't need as much dosh in options as many Audis do.
Residual values have been firm since launch.
I forwarded this link to him last night; he is readin but has no login account. Pleb.
Lostprophet said:
cuprabob said:
The auto boxes in the TTS & TTRS are DSG which are ery good IMO
I am assuming the DSG in the TTS and TTRS is different to the one in the S5? S5 auto box is poor imo.Whereas the DSG is one of these twin clutch systems. DSGs are VERY good! I drove a Pasat R36 with DSG, and the gearbox was seamless!
I'm not sure how many gears the DSG TT-S and -RS have. I would assume it's 6, but I'm sure someone will definately know

Darren
I stand to be corrected as I have no sales involvement, but I was under the impression that TT RS is Manual only, because the DSG box cant take the torque of the 5 cylinder turbo motor.
Having driven them all, I would say.
TTS is great fun and is what all TT's should have been like (no one would ever had called them hair dressers cars if they had been this fast), it drives and handles like a really good hot hatch, and with more power. I'm not a fan of auto boxes but the DSG really suits this car, with the slight pop/parp from the exhaust on full throtle upshift.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9pn0-NYuwpk
TTRS performance is fantastic, mush faster than you think. Handles well with bags and bags of grip but still feels more like a hot hatch than a sports car. IMO too expensive for a TT, which is after all a golf at heart.
S5 makes the right noises and is nicer to drive a long distance, but is ultimatly a bit more of a tourer than a sports coupe, just a tad to heavy to be "chuckable" like the TT and with the new A4/A5 steering lacks feed back and doesnt have the most positive turn in, S4 had a few tricked added to it to it that S5 doesn, to improve these problems. S5 is more stable and composed over bumps and at very high speed where the TTS+TTRS can be a bit flyty.
Having driven them all, I would say.
TTS is great fun and is what all TT's should have been like (no one would ever had called them hair dressers cars if they had been this fast), it drives and handles like a really good hot hatch, and with more power. I'm not a fan of auto boxes but the DSG really suits this car, with the slight pop/parp from the exhaust on full throtle upshift.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9pn0-NYuwpk
TTRS performance is fantastic, mush faster than you think. Handles well with bags and bags of grip but still feels more like a hot hatch than a sports car. IMO too expensive for a TT, which is after all a golf at heart.
S5 makes the right noises and is nicer to drive a long distance, but is ultimatly a bit more of a tourer than a sports coupe, just a tad to heavy to be "chuckable" like the TT and with the new A4/A5 steering lacks feed back and doesnt have the most positive turn in, S4 had a few tricked added to it to it that S5 doesn, to improve these problems. S5 is more stable and composed over bumps and at very high speed where the TTS+TTRS can be a bit flyty.
Forgot to say...............
The 5 cylinder engine sounds fantastic too. Maybe even better than the V8.
Book test drives is the only way to decide, dont let anyone put you off the one you end up liking best.
Some will say the ride on the TT is to stiff and it has to be the S5
Others will say the S5 is too heavy.
Depends what you are after.
The 5 cylinder engine sounds fantastic too. Maybe even better than the V8.
Book test drives is the only way to decide, dont let anyone put you off the one you end up liking best.
Some will say the ride on the TT is to stiff and it has to be the S5
Others will say the S5 is too heavy.
Depends what you are after.
S5 is actually quite light for its size, engine, drive train. Take a look at some other big V8 engined cars and its weight (1630kg IIRC) is impressive. It is still heavy next to a TTS Coupe though - 1400kg ish.
The TTRS is getting a seven speed DSG/S Tronic box option but has been manual so far. Personally I prefer a manual in a sporty car and have been more than happy with the manual box in my 3.2 TT.
The TTRS is getting a seven speed DSG/S Tronic box option but has been manual so far. Personally I prefer a manual in a sporty car and have been more than happy with the manual box in my 3.2 TT.
My mate and I both went to see the S5 and TTRS over the weekend... Unfortunately could not arrange a test drive as he forgot his license!
The audi garage had a TTRS coupe in the show room, a R8 and a few other decent cars. Anyway on looks alone the TTRS was a good looking machine. I thought it was too small but he reckons it’s big enough to get his 1 year old kid in the back. Hmm I was less convinced. The boot is tiny too… cant get a decent pushchair in the back!
The S5 was on the used car forecourt. It definitely looked chunky! The S5 was in silver; prob not the best colour for it. I think the colour was a put off and so i think my mate will check out a black one local to him.
I have to say the MPG on the S5 is poor. Folks getting lowish 13-14mpg.
We went pass a dealer in N-London as I was keen to check out the M3 and to show him the car. The dealer had one in white. Looked quite nice but soon as you got into it I was reminded of the saloon, estate, coupe 3 series interior. Hmmm felt quite sad as my mate was just rippin the car. I had nothing to say apart from the test is in the driving experience!
Will keep you posted.
Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



