Golf Mk3 GTI 16v - misfire help please
Golf Mk3 GTI 16v - misfire help please
Author
Discussion

wrighty78

Original Poster:

6,313 posts

245 months

Thursday 13th May 2010
quotequote all
The daily driver has developed a misfire of some sort. It only happens when the car is warmed up and even then it only happens occasionally, but when it happens it is quite startling.

If the car is idling when it happens, it stalls. If the car is moving, it sends a real thud through the car - almost as if you've turned the ignition off and then let the car immediately bump start itself. There's no obvious pattern to it, the car ticks over smoothly and there are no warning lights or anything.

So before I order a full set of replacement plugs, leads, dizzy cap, rotor arm and coil (sum total approx £120 off EuroCarParts), in the hope that one or other of these sorts it out, would anyone like to hazard a guess at what is wrong with it?

mbrain

4,553 posts

199 months

Thursday 13th May 2010
quotequote all
Maybe the throttle body needs a good clean out?

T89 Callan

8,422 posts

224 months

Thursday 13th May 2010
quotequote all
Check the wires from the TPS (throttle position sensor) mine melted on the exhaust manifold.

wrighty78

Original Poster:

6,313 posts

245 months

Thursday 13th May 2010
quotequote all
mbrain said:
Maybe the throttle body needs a good clean out?
This was my first idea. I've had the tube off and squirted a fair amount of carb cleaner into the throttle bottle and cleaened it up with a clean rag - the car runs a bit smoother as a result, but it hasn't solved the problem. Maybe I need to give it another go...

wrighty78

Original Poster:

6,313 posts

245 months

Thursday 13th May 2010
quotequote all
T89 Callan said:
Check the wires from the TPS (throttle position sensor) mine melted on the exhaust manifold.
Hmmm - I'm not sure I know what I'm looking for... I'll have a look over the weekend.

Thanks for the suggestions!

Pentoman

4,838 posts

294 months

Thursday 13th May 2010
quotequote all
Have heard of this being 'a relay' before on this exact model. Drove it and it was fine except for occasionally an extremely sudden and violent misfire at times.

5harp3y

1,966 posts

230 months

Friday 14th May 2010
quotequote all
Coil ... they are notoriously unreliable. Mine used to arc and all sorts!

wrighty78

Original Poster:

6,313 posts

245 months

Friday 14th May 2010
quotequote all
Pentoman said:
Have heard of this being 'a relay' before on this exact model. Drove it and it was fine except for occasionally an extremely sudden and violent misfire at times.
Interesting! "Sudden and violent" sounds spot on, so maybe you're on to something. Any idea which relay?

wrighty78

Original Poster:

6,313 posts

245 months

Friday 14th May 2010
quotequote all
5harp3y said:
Coil ... they are notoriously unreliable. Mine used to arc and all sorts!
Thanks - I'd heard this before. I might go and get one tomorrow morning and see whether it solves the problem.

aka_kerrly

12,506 posts

241 months

Friday 14th May 2010
quotequote all
ECU or Fuel pump relays. Both have a habbit of strangeley just dying and bursting back into life and can give the symptoms you describe.
http://www.harland1979.freeserve.co.uk/golf/htchan... this should help.

both are circa £10 or less and well worth swapping before spending any more money. Perhaps find someone who has VagCom as well who can scan the ECU and check for any fault codes.

dave

JB!

5,255 posts

211 months

Friday 14th May 2010
quotequote all
5harp3y said:
Coil ... they are notoriously unreliable. Mine used to arc and all sorts!
this.

wrighty78

Original Poster:

6,313 posts

245 months

Friday 14th May 2010
quotequote all
Thanks guys. Much appreciated.

My local EuroCarParts has the coil in stock and the local VW dealership is getting the ECU relay in overnight (they can't get a fuel pump relay), so I'll fit both tomorrow and see whether that solves the problem.

Fingers crossed!

wrighty78

Original Poster:

6,313 posts

245 months

Saturday 15th May 2010
quotequote all
So today I fitted the new coil and ECU relay and.... it still misfires. Aaarrggghhh!

So I'll order the fuel pump relay and see if that sorts it out.

Edited by wrighty78 on Saturday 15th May 14:56

Pentoman

4,838 posts

294 months

Sunday 16th May 2010
quotequote all
Sorry I've no idea what relay it was that was the problem on the example I drove. It was in at my parents' garage and I know it took a while to find the cause but in the end I just asked out of interest and the response was 'a relay'. Was a good 5 years ago too so I bet they can't even remember!

I suppose you could diagnose fuel pump relay by hooking a multimeter to the fuel pump connections (at the pump end) and driving along. I'm guessing it would read 12 volts, but if it drops when the misfire happens, then it sounds like a fuel pump relay....

wrighty78

Original Poster:

6,313 posts

245 months

Saturday 29th May 2010
quotequote all
I'm getting bored now.

Coil changed, ECU relay changed, fuel pump relay changed, throttle body cleaned, and STILL the bloody thing misfires, but still only when it has warmed up. And occasionally it stalls and now is becoming more difficult to re-start.

Its supposed to be the bangernomics daily driver, so I'm reluctant to spend any more time and money on it and we've ordered a new Fiat 500 that'll turn up in a couple of months, so it's not like it's a keeper.

It seems I've got three options:

1. buy new plugs, leads, dizzy cap and rotor arm and then progress to fuel pump, throttle body sensor, ignition system etc etc (but I've got no time over the next few weeks to sort it out and am loathe to spend any more effort on it, )

2. send it to auction (AKA - the easy way out)

3. flog it to someone who has the time and inclination to try to sort it out... does anyone want a Golf with FSH, new cambelt, 10 months MOT and tax til the end of the month?

What would you do? Any last bright ideas as to what the problem might be?

istoo

2,365 posts

233 months

Saturday 29th May 2010
quotequote all
hmm, have you tried running it at night in as dark a place as you can get and flip the bonnet with the lights off. If there is any spark hop, coils or dodgy leads you should see it. The mk3 should be new enough to have onboard diagnostics, i would get it scanned for any registerd faults vagCOM will do this if you know anyone near you with a copy, or a descent garage shoudl be able to read codes for you for not very much.

As you say you could be replacing bits until you eventually get the right bit. Althohg description sounds like coils which i also had in a previosu car, woudl stutter and really drop in power then come alive again. No rythym as to when and why. Bloody annoying though.


martin vr6

3,885 posts

232 months

Sunday 30th May 2010
quotequote all
Coolant temperature sensor sounds like it's had it's day, before it's only misfiring when it's warm,

paultownsend

3,463 posts

214 months

Monday 31st May 2010
quotequote all
have you changed all the vacume lines? especially the one to the ecu? only costs a few ££,


oh and use avs vw on the web. top prices and always bosch/buru items

Edited by paultownsend on Monday 31st May 12:28

MikeDD

1 posts

190 months

Wednesday 12th January 2011
quotequote all
This is an old topic, but no one else has mentioned the distributor.

Not the distributor cap, but the actual distributor itself. My Golf MK3 16v had a misfiring problem and the root cause was a faulty sensor in the distributor.

Had to take it to a VW specialist to get it diagnosed, he told me he had seen it happen a few time before. This was after changing the other parts, including the relay.