Conservatives scrap plans to cut fuel duty
Conservatives scrap plans to cut fuel duty
Author
Discussion

topless_mx5

Original Poster:

2,763 posts

248 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/politic...

No surprise there, U-turn once they get the votes. s.

Stu R

21,663 posts

245 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
They're hardly going to cut fuel duty when the two core principles of easing our national debt are cut spending and raise taxes. You do know we're in a bit of financial trouble, right?

Silent1

19,762 posts

265 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
topless_mx5 said:
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/politic...

No surprise there, U-turn once they get the votes. s.
You actually thought they would carry through on that?
We're in quite a lot of debt right now.

Elroy Blue

8,842 posts

222 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
Financial crisis or not, they'e totally renegade on most of their election promises. It even took Winky more than a week to do that. I should have just voted Lib-Dem, I'd have got the same thing!

900T-R

20,406 posts

287 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
The constant whining about fuel taxes is the reason we get burdened with stealth 'green' taxes with which governments say 'you won't get shafted (as much)...if you are a good boy/girl and ditch your dirty old family car for this shiny new sh*tbox with a lawnmower engine'. I'd rather pay a fair price for every litre of fuel I burn that includes the cost of finding sustainable alternatives and building infrastructures for them before we run out of oil, and whatever the costs to society are of the 2.2 kgs of CO2 I emit (which the EU thinks is 50 euro per tonne as that's what they want to charge industry) than have them de facto decide for me whether I should burn it in my TVR or a Prius.

thinfourth2

32,414 posts

234 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
This is going to be so much fun watching the tory fan boys squirm as it turns out they are also going to screw us over and leave the benefit scum alone

Mannginger

10,284 posts

287 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
thinfourth2 said:
...leave the benefit scum alone
Why will that be good? Regardless of your political hue?

Stu R

21,663 posts

245 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
thinfourth2 said:
This is going to be so much fun watching the tory fan boys squirm as it turns out they are also going to screw us over and leave the benefit scum alone
i think most people with even half a brain that aren't 'benefit scum', and possibly some that are, have long accepted that the sheer size of our welfare state is more than anyone can deal with in a short time frame, a decade would be optimistic. I don't really see how it can be 'fun', irrespective of which mast your flag is nailed to. It's a lose lose situation in many respects.

I do agree there's probably a far worse pinch to come. The future is by no means rosy, if anything it's going to get far worse before it gets better, we're still near as dammit in recession after some nicely massaged growth figures of 0.1% despite £200bn+ of QE, interest rates are flat, inflation is rising, markets are looking shafted etc etc. Married to this is europe going down the pan and the myriad of knock on effects... Who else is going to pick up labours tab?

That little lot is more than enough to keep me squirming, a few coalition concessions and broken promises aren't going to upset me, s'only a few quids worth of tax anyway. Well that and it's POETs day so i couldn't care less biggrin


Edited by Stu R on Friday 21st May 07:54

mat205125

17,790 posts

243 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
It was obvious that as soon as a coilition was on the cards, then the vote-luring promises that were going to cost the government money in lost revenue were going to go straight out of the window.

Please remember, however, which website the OP has linked to, and their target demograph. There are a lot of the policies outlined yesterday that I disagree with (as they are likely to cost me money in the short term), however I think there is a level of pain that this country must endure to overcome a decade of mis-spending - The doom-and-gloom-for-the-wealthy Telegraph failed to mention the announcment of the re-assessment of all those claiming disability benifits, for example. We can be as scinical as we like about how successful this kind of initiative will be, however if it gets the lazy obese parasites off of the sofa and into the Job Centre, then it will be a start.

playerone

872 posts

240 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
thinfourth2 said:
This is going to be so much fun watching the tory fan boys squirm as it turns out they are also going to screw us over and leave the benefit scum alone
Are you another leftie who would cut his nose off to spite his face?

Dracoro

9,033 posts

275 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
Each party "promised" (let's face it, they're trying to get elected, no one would vote for a party that told the truth about the hard times ahead) a number of things, many of which will come into fruition, however they are promises of what would happen if a Conservative government came to power. BUT we do NOT have a conservative government, we have a coalition government.

Fuel (and many other things) will have to go up. Yes it's not nice, Yes it's a pain but I suspect people think getting out of debt will only mean hardship on "other" people, it doesn't, it means hardship on all of us.

Fuel will go to £1.50 in no time I reckon.

People will moan it will price people off the road (well, it will reduce congestion), however they were saying the same thing when fuel was 80/90p a litre (actually, they've been saying it long before then!) and guess what, they still all driving, there's more people on the road than there ever has been. People CAN afford it and will carry on to do so. It's an essential so they'll have to cut their holiday budget, no flash new car (stick with their old one etc.), no plasma and so on.

I'd rather more tax on fuel than higher VED - although we'll probably get both frown

I'll re-iterate though, people all agree that there are tough times ahead but only agree if it doesn't affect them personally........

wildatheart

164 posts

209 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
900T-R said:
The constant whining about fuel taxes is the reason we get burdened with stealth 'green' taxes with which governments say 'you won't get shafted (as much)...if you are a good boy/girl and ditch your dirty old family car for this shiny new sh*tbox with a lawnmower engine'. I'd rather pay a fair price for every litre of fuel I burn that includes the cost of finding sustainable alternatives and building infrastructures for them before we run out of oil, and whatever the costs to society are of the 2.2 kgs of CO2 I emit (which the EU thinks is 50 euro per tonne as that's what they want to charge industry) than have them de facto decide for me whether I should burn it in my TVR or a Prius.
Problem is, exactly 0% of the fuel duty you pay is used for ANY of the causes you mention above. Most of it is used to pay off interest on debt to banks, whom you have already paid with your money, and are now charging you to lend your own money back. Any investment into infrastructure etc. is funded by income taxes.

deeen

6,413 posts

275 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
Taxes from motoring should be "ring-fenced" for transport. I have no problem with some cross-subsidy to public transport, to reduce congestion, but i fail to see why the motorist should bail out the country. Oh, and there is no "cost to society" from CO2.

madala

5,063 posts

228 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
....when are people going to get it in their thick heads that we are ALL going to have to pay very heavily for thirteen years of Labour misrule and over spending.....there are not going to be any short cuts.....stop bleating

sleep envy

62,260 posts

279 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
wildatheart said:
900T-R said:
The constant whining about fuel taxes is the reason we get burdened with stealth 'green' taxes with which governments say 'you won't get shafted (as much)...if you are a good boy/girl and ditch your dirty old family car for this shiny new sh*tbox with a lawnmower engine'. I'd rather pay a fair price for every litre of fuel I burn that includes the cost of finding sustainable alternatives and building infrastructures for them before we run out of oil, and whatever the costs to society are of the 2.2 kgs of CO2 I emit (which the EU thinks is 50 euro per tonne as that's what they want to charge industry) than have them de facto decide for me whether I should burn it in my TVR or a Prius.
Problem is, exactly 0% of the fuel duty you pay is used for ANY of the causes you mention above. Most of it is used to pay off interest on debt to banks, whom you have already paid with your money, and are now charging you to lend your own money back. Any investment into infrastructure etc. is funded by income taxes.
how do you work that out when revenue goes into one central pot?

The Wookie

14,209 posts

258 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
thinfourth2 said:
This is going to be so much fun watching the tory fan boys squirm as it turns out they are also going to screw us over and leave the benefit scum alone
After over 10 years of 'it's thatcher's fault' being rammed down our necks while labour ruined us, we deserve at least a year or two of 'it's winky's fault'

LuS1fer

43,543 posts

275 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
Elroy Blue said:
Financial crisis or not, they'e totally renegade on most of their election promises. It even took Winky more than a week to do that. I should have just voted Lib-Dem, I'd have got the same thing!
"reneged"

A renegade is something else, including a Jeep. wink

What people have to understand is that basically politics is about one party with 3 different colours. A bit like Top Trumps - same principles, different pictures.

kambites

71,567 posts

251 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
The Wookie said:
thinfourth2 said:
This is going to be so much fun watching the tory fan boys squirm as it turns out they are also going to screw us over and leave the benefit scum alone
After over 10 years of 'it's thatcher's fault' being rammed down our necks while labour ruined us, we deserve at least a year or two of 'it's winky's fault'
Surely we'll have however many years the Tories are in power of "it's Winky's fault", just as we had as many years as Labour were in power of "it's the Thatcher's fault". That's just how the system works.

kambites

71,567 posts

251 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
Gaz. said:
John Major must be laughing then.
He didn't actually do anything as PM did he?

ExPat2B

2,159 posts

230 months

Friday 21st May 2010
quotequote all
sleep envy said:
wildatheart said:
900T-R said:
The constant whining about fuel taxes is the reason we get burdened with stealth 'green' taxes with which governments say 'you won't get shafted (as much)...if you are a good boy/girl and ditch your dirty old family car for this shiny new sh*tbox with a lawnmower engine'. I'd rather pay a fair price for every litre of fuel I burn that includes the cost of finding sustainable alternatives and building infrastructures for them before we run out of oil, and whatever the costs to society are of the 2.2 kgs of CO2 I emit (which the EU thinks is 50 euro per tonne as that's what they want to charge industry) than have them de facto decide for me whether I should burn it in my TVR or a Prius.
Problem is, exactly 0% of the fuel duty you pay is used for ANY of the causes you mention above. Most of it is used to pay off interest on debt to banks, whom you have already paid with your money, and are now charging you to lend your own money back. Any investment into infrastructure etc. is funded by income taxes.
how do you work that out when revenue goes into one central pot?
The same way the americans do it.