Engine Temp High - Warning.
Engine Temp High - Warning.
Author
Discussion

Tiger_kpt

Original Poster:

708 posts

212 months

Sunday 23rd May 2010
quotequote all
Hi guys,

I managed to put quite a few miles on the Ro this weekend. I have just got back from a round trip to Newcastle and back. No drama's with the Ro - took it in her stride as usual. I drive her quite a bit, put a few miles on her and not had any problems yet.

However, when calling in at a service station today half way back to fill her up with fuel. I noticed that when stationary and at very low speeds, the coolant temp gauge started to creep up - then I got the "Engine Temp High" warning on the dash. It has never done this before - like my last Ro, the temp usually stays well below the halfway mark on this gauge. When I set off again, the guage reading dropped off to the usual levels - due to the increased air flow of travelling at speed. When I got back home and pulled up on the drive, raised the bonnet and waited with the car to see if it would do it again. It did, so killed the engine and checked the basics. The fans are cutting in and out. There are no coolant leaks. The coolant tank is full. I'm thinking that it may be down to the long journey mixed with the weather and the heat wave we have had - especially today - El Scorchio! - causing a case of really bad heat soak? I also remember, that on the way up to Newcastle, the "Engine Check" warning light came up on the dash just after setting off from a service station half way up there, which was unusual - not sure if it is connected.

What do you guys think? Anything else it could be?

Edited by Tiger_kpt on Sunday 23 May 15:21

gsd2000

11,515 posts

214 months

Sunday 23rd May 2010
quotequote all
i would say thermostat, but if the fans are kicking in then then i would have thought that its working okay. scratchchin

Is it worth altering the points at which the fans kick in by using efi live or this a bad idea?

Tiger_kpt

Original Poster:

708 posts

212 months

Sunday 23rd May 2010
quotequote all
The weird thing was that when stationary on the drive, with the engine on and the bonnet up. The temp gauge reading was climbing and all while the fans were on (both fans working).

gsd2000

11,515 posts

214 months

Sunday 23rd May 2010
quotequote all
Would a small amount of air in the cooling system cause this?

Magic919

14,592 posts

232 months

Sunday 23rd May 2010
quotequote all
gsd2000 said:
i would say thermostat, but if the fans are kicking in then then i would have thought that its working okay.
Thermostat and the ECT sensor are two different things though G.

Tiger_kpt

Original Poster:

708 posts

212 months

Sunday 23rd May 2010
quotequote all
gsd2000 said:
Would a small amount of air in the cooling system cause this?


Hmmm, could be. May be worth a check. Where is the bleed point on the Ro's coolant system?

Tiger_kpt

Original Poster:

708 posts

212 months

Sunday 23rd May 2010
quotequote all
Magic919 said:
gsd2000 said:
i would say thermostat, but if the fans are kicking in then then i would have thought that its working okay.


Thermostat and the ECT sensor are two different things though G.


So the thermostat could be faulty?

Bonnie and Clyde

11,701 posts

223 months

Sunday 23rd May 2010
quotequote all
I had this on my old 535 BMW. I was scared in the end to go out if there was traffic. It was initially found to be an air lock in the cooling system which we had bled. Worked for a while but the happened again. Eventually it was found to be a head gasket This is i believe common on BMW 5's.
I have to say though the Monaro has always stayed steady as you say Kyle just under the half way mark. Its really been tested as well. Waiting in the queue at race days then thrashing the arse off it, then waiting etc etc etc.....
I'd have a word with Roger or Mark tomorrow.

gsd2000

11,515 posts

214 months

Sunday 23rd May 2010
quotequote all
Would a faulty thermostat show up error codes?

L2VXR

1,014 posts

244 months

Sunday 23rd May 2010
quotequote all
Tiger_kpt said:
Where is the bleed point on the Ro's coolant system?


the system should bleed its self via a connected pipe across the top/front of the cylinder heads going to the top of the rad.

are the fans coming on in two stages ie; both fans at slow speed then as temps increase both fans step up to stage 2 fast speed.seem to remember people posting about faulty relays

check out this old post as well for a bit more info and the links i posted there

www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&t=772332&r=12876261&hm=65670&mid=65670#12876261

Edited by L2VXR on Sunday 23 May 20:13

snowwolf

11,503 posts

206 months

Sunday 23rd May 2010
quotequote all
first simple thing is to change the stat if all the other stuf looks ok, how many miles has it done?

Tiger_kpt

Original Poster:

708 posts

212 months

Sunday 23rd May 2010
quotequote all
Well... just took the Ro back out on the road, now that the sun has gone down, to see if the antics that occurred earlier was a one off due to the high ambient temperatures. Same thing happened. It seems to keep the temperature down when the car is moving. Although at one point whilst driving, the gauge needle seemed erratic for a few minutes, climbing and then falling off suddenly - strange. However, once parked up, with the engine running, the temperature starts to climb again and does so fairly quickly. So not a one off - something is up with it.

The car has covered 34k miles - it isn't supercharged (FI). Still NA. It is a cammed LS2 VXR. Full Wortec package.

The fans are both working and both speeds seem to be functioning - I have seen them function at the low speed and the high speed at various points tonight. Even with the fans on high speed the temperature gauge reading rises. I am thinking either air-lock or thermostat. I don't think it is head gasket from what I have seen. There doesn't seem to be any "boiling".

Edited by Tiger_kpt on Sunday 23 May 21:12

dreamtoy

890 posts

204 months

Sunday 23rd May 2010
quotequote all
Did i hear someone before having temp raising up, ended up just the coolant cap needed replacing scratchchin

snowwolf

11,503 posts

206 months

Sunday 23rd May 2010
quotequote all
dreamtoy said:
Did i hear someone before having temp raising up, ended up just the coolant cap needed replacing scratchchin
Yup faulty rad cap can cause that problem

L2VXR

1,014 posts

244 months

Sunday 23rd May 2010
quotequote all
dreamtoy said:
Did i hear someone before having temp raising up, ended up just the coolant cap needed replacing scratchchin


think this is the post containing this info

www.hsv.org.uk/topic.asp?t=810196&f=69&h=27

mogv8

836 posts

259 months

Sunday 23rd May 2010
quotequote all
I had something similar on my old 'ro, it actually kicked out about a litre of fluid as well after high speed running on a hot day.

Happened again to a lesser degree, so I had it tested but I believe it was an airlock as it never repeated itself after that.

monkfish1

12,522 posts

255 months

Monday 24th May 2010
quotequote all
Tiger_kpt said:
Hi guys,

I managed to put quite a few miles on the Ro this weekend. I have just got back from a round trip to Newcastle and back. No drama's with the Ro - took it in her stride as usual. I drive her quite a bit, put a few miles on her and not had any problems yet.

However, when calling in at a service station today half way back to fill her up with fuel. I noticed that when stationary and at very low speeds, the coolant temp gauge started to creep up - then I got the "Engine Temp High" warning on the dash. It has never done this before - like my last Ro, the temp usually stays well below the halfway mark on this gauge. When I set off again, the guage reading dropped off to the usual levels - due to the increased air flow of travelling at speed. When I got back home and pulled up on the drive, raised the bonnet and waited with the car to see if it would do it again. It did, so killed the engine and checked the basics. The fans are cutting in and out. There are no coolant leaks. The coolant tank is full. I'm thinking that it may be down to the long journey mixed with the weather and the heat wave we have had - especially today - El Scorchio! - causing a case of really bad heat soak? I also remember, that on the way up to Newcastle, the "Engine Check" warning light came up on the dash just after setting off from a service station half way up there, which was unusual - not sure if it is connected.

What do you guys think? Anything else it could be?

Edited by Tiger_kpt on Sunday 23 May 15:21


Have you checked the level in the radiator itself? Checking the tank with the yellow plastic lid tells you nothing. Make sure its cold though, ie overnight.

Tiger_kpt

Original Poster:

708 posts

212 months

Monday 24th May 2010
quotequote all
monkfish1 said:
Tiger_kpt said:
Hi guys,

I managed to put quite a few miles on the Ro this weekend. I have just got back from a round trip to Newcastle and back. No drama's with the Ro - took it in her stride as usual. I drive her quite a bit, put a few miles on her and not had any problems yet.

However, when calling in at a service station today half way back to fill her up with fuel. I noticed that when stationary and at very low speeds, the coolant temp gauge started to creep up - then I got the "Engine Temp High" warning on the dash. It has never done this before - like my last Ro, the temp usually stays well below the halfway mark on this gauge. When I set off again, the guage reading dropped off to the usual levels - due to the increased air flow of travelling at speed. When I got back home and pulled up on the drive, raised the bonnet and waited with the car to see if it would do it again. It did, so killed the engine and checked the basics. The fans are cutting in and out. There are no coolant leaks. The coolant tank is full. I'm thinking that it may be down to the long journey mixed with the weather and the heat wave we have had - especially today - El Scorchio! - causing a case of really bad heat soak? I also remember, that on the way up to Newcastle, the "Engine Check" warning light came up on the dash just after setting off from a service station half way up there, which was unusual - not sure if it is connected.

What do you guys think? Anything else it could be?

Edited by Tiger_kpt on Sunday 23 May 15:21


Have you checked the level in the radiator itself? Checking the tank with the yellow plastic lid tells you nothing. Make sure its cold though, ie overnight.


Hi Roger, thanks for the heads up. I admit, that I did only check the coolant level in the tank with the yellow plastic dip stick. When I took her out for the second time lastnight, the few minutes of eratic readings from the coolant temp gauge whilst driving - made me think it must either be low coolant, air-lock or faulty radiator fill cap (pressure cap). I will do a few checks tonight when I get back in from work. I will check the level in the radiator itself, I will make sure that the radiator fill cap is secured correctly and that it isn't leaking or damaged. I may also try fitting another cap to see if that makes a difference.

Granby

2,473 posts

246 months

Monday 24th May 2010
quotequote all
monkfish1 said:
Tiger_kpt said:
Hi guys,

I managed to put quite a few miles on the Ro this weekend. I have just got back from a round trip to Newcastle and back. No drama's with the Ro - took it in her stride as usual. I drive her quite a bit, put a few miles on her and not had any problems yet.

However, when calling in at a service station today half way back to fill her up with fuel. I noticed that when stationary and at very low speeds, the coolant temp gauge started to creep up - then I got the "Engine Temp High" warning on the dash. It has never done this before - like my last Ro, the temp usually stays well below the halfway mark on this gauge. When I set off again, the guage reading dropped off to the usual levels - due to the increased air flow of travelling at speed. When I got back home and pulled up on the drive, raised the bonnet and waited with the car to see if it would do it again. It did, so killed the engine and checked the basics. The fans are cutting in and out. There are no coolant leaks. The coolant tank is full. I'm thinking that it may be down to the long journey mixed with the weather and the heat wave we have had - especially today - El Scorchio! - causing a case of really bad heat soak? I also remember, that on the way up to Newcastle, the "Engine Check" warning light came up on the dash just after setting off from a service station half way up there, which was unusual - not sure if it is connected.

What do you guys think? Anything else it could be?

Edited by Tiger_kpt on Sunday 23 May 15:21
Have you checked the level in the radiator itself? Checking the tank with the yellow plastic lid tells you nothing. Make sure its cold though, ie overnight.
Should the level in the radiator be to the top or a little below?

Tiger_kpt

Original Poster:

708 posts

212 months

Tuesday 25th May 2010
quotequote all
Well, got access to the radiator lastnight when the car was cold. Removed the cap. I could see the level in the radiator, but it was a good few inches from the top. I filled it up to the top, it took between 2 and 3 litres in the end to fill. I started the car, warmed it up, no over-heating and couldn't see any leaks. I switched her off and again, couldn't see any leaks after monitoring for around 30 minutes. I will take a look at her later on to see if the level has dropped again overnight whilst cooling down.

Looks like the water pump and thermostat are functioning fine. Just wondering why the coolant was low now! It just goes to show that the coolant tank with the yellow level dip-stick is not to be relied on! That was reading full when the radiator was not.