Golf MK5 1.8 Turbo Conversion
Golf MK5 1.8 Turbo Conversion
Author
Discussion

VadMan

Original Poster:

46 posts

219 months

Sunday 23rd May 2010
quotequote all
Hi All,

Been thinking about this for ages, is it possible to trasplant a 1.8 Turbo (180 or 225) into a MK5 Golf? If so, are there particular things to watch out for, or has anyone done this already?



Thanks! biggrin


Cupramax

11,007 posts

283 months

Monday 24th May 2010
quotequote all
Just buy a 2.0T and save yourself the effort, then stick the S3 turbo on it. Its a much better engine. I would have though by the time you've gone to the effort of getting the 1.8T ECU to work with the dashboard you be better off buying one with the bigger engine.

VadMan

Original Poster:

46 posts

219 months

Monday 24th May 2010
quotequote all
Great, thanks for the tip! So would a 2.0 TFSi engine and gearbox fit straight into my Golf?

Does anyone know good salvage places to get such engines?

Dave^

7,903 posts

284 months

Monday 24th May 2010
quotequote all
confused

Just buy a Mk5 Golf GTi...

The suspension/brakes/wheels/everything will be better than on your 1.4s... It will be cheaper, and so will the insurance...


Matt_N

9,045 posts

233 months

Monday 24th May 2010
quotequote all
VadMan said:
Great, thanks for the tip! So would a 2.0 TFSi engine and gearbox fit straight into my Golf?
Id imagine so, seeing at thats what is fitted to the Mk5 Golf Gti!

As others have said, just get a Gti.

5harp3y

1,966 posts

230 months

Monday 24th May 2010
quotequote all
Don't build what you can buy.

Just get a Mk5 Gti. Save yourself loads of grief and you will only end up with a low spec golf with a gti engine.

aka_kerrly

12,506 posts

241 months

Monday 24th May 2010
quotequote all
5harp3y said:
Don't build what you can buy.

Just get a Mk5 Gti. Save yourself loads of grief and you will only end up with a low spec golf with a gti engine.
THIS.

Apart from if you are capable of fitting the engine/box/electrics etc yourself then the paying a pro to put a 2.0 TSFI set up and the corresponding brake and suspension upgrades could easily be heading toward £10k which is easily enough to get a GTI.

in less you plan on fitting a R36 lump or something that doesnt come in a mk5 then save your pennies.

Great Pretender

26,140 posts

245 months

Monday 24th May 2010
quotequote all
VadMan said:
Great, thanks for the tip! So would a 2.0 TFSi engine and gearbox fit straight into my Golf?

Does anyone know good salvage places to get such engines?
Ah, the innocence of youf; I remember it well. FWIW I was once determined that I would transplant a 1.7 puma engine into my then 18 month old Fiesta 1.3 'Finesse', but then I realised that a); my insurance company would laugh at me b); I didn't have any money and c); that because the car was bought on tick by my parents, I was expressly forbidden from modifying it, both by them and by the terms of the agreement. Oh and d); the car would be worth eff-all thereafter.

Sell your 1.4 Golf and save up to buy an nice early MKV GTI instead, if that's at all feasible. Otherwise, go and get pissed with your mates and worry about nice cars when you can afford them.


VadMan

Original Poster:

46 posts

219 months

Tuesday 25th May 2010
quotequote all
Seems to be a general consensus of not to bother with the transplant. The reason I asked is because I quiet fancied a project to work on as I am 100% happy with my Golf apart from the complete lack of power frown

However it seems that it would cost about the same to buy a Golf GTi, or even cheaper for a Octavia VRS with the same engine, then I think thats what I'll be doing.

Test drove a Gti on Sunday and fell in love with it really. Interestingly it didn't feel any slower than the R32 my friend drove the same day...

cuprabob

19,905 posts

245 months

Tuesday 25th May 2010
quotequote all
VadMan said:
Test drove a Gti on Sunday and fell in love with it really. Interestingly it didn't feel any slower than the R32 my friend drove the same day...
That's because it isn't. Although the R32 has more power, it is also heavier due to the larger engine and the haldex.

Alwats surprises me when people compare the GTI to teh R32, totally different animals IMO and there are many pros and cons to each

Great Pretender

26,140 posts

245 months

Tuesday 25th May 2010
quotequote all
cuprabob said:
VadMan said:
Test drove a Gti on Sunday and fell in love with it really. Interestingly it didn't feel any slower than the R32 my friend drove the same day...
That's because it isn't. Although the R32 has more power, it is also heavier due to the larger engine and the haldex.

Alwats surprises me when people compare the GTI to teh R32, totally different animals IMO and there are many pros and cons to each
yes

Think of the R32 as a practical GT car; the GTI as a practical B-road whip.

VadMan

Original Poster:

46 posts

219 months

Tuesday 25th May 2010
quotequote all
B-road whip please biggrin

What your thoughts on the MK2 Octavia VRS? Same car for less money, or are there disadvantages to it?