Monaro/VXR8
Author
Discussion

jmn

Original Poster:

1,320 posts

311 months

Tuesday 15th June 2010
quotequote all
I am considering buying one of these cars. Additional interior space of VXR8 does not matter as such as I am more interested in handling, spares back up etc.

Are the VXR8 brakes uprated when compared to a Monaro?

Presumably the VXR8 will handle better? (Comparing one standard car with another).

Many years ago when I owned a variety of old american cars it was easy and relatively cheap to increase bhp by about 25% by altering the cam, heads, and intake. Is this the case with the 5.7 and 6litre GM engine? Although others will no doubt disagree around 500bhp seems more than enough to me...

Will it be easier, in theory at least, to get spares for the VXR8?

Is the VXR8 better protected against corrosion?

Thanks for any info provided.


the_ferret82

25,627 posts

215 months

Tuesday 15th June 2010
quotequote all
jmn said:
I am considering buying one of these cars. Additional interior space of VXR8 does not matter as such as I am more interested in handling, spares back up etc.

Are the VXR8 brakes uprated when compared to a Monaro? Yes!!

Presumably the VXR8 will handle better? (Comparing one standard car with another). cant comment never driver a R8 (RO owner)

Many years ago when I owned a variety of old american cars it was easy and relatively cheap to increase bhp by about 25% by altering the cam, heads, and intake. Is this the case with the 5.7 and 6litre GM engine? Although others will no doubt disagree around 500bhp seems more than enough to me... (the engines are the old LS range so parts are ready available. can be expensive comparted to US prices due to import duties etc. but all manner of options are available.

Will it be easier, in theory at least, to get spares for the VXR8? less VXR8's where imported to the UK then Monaro's. most parts come for either OZ or USA. VX in this country have a bad reputation with these cars.

Is the VXR8 better protected against corrosion? not 100% sure but would say no.

Thanks for any info provided.

petrolzed

182 posts

227 months

Tuesday 15th June 2010
quotequote all
I moved from a Monaro to a VXR8 so here are my personal opinions.
Comparing std with std.
VXR8 brakes way better.
VXR8 feels quicker and more lively even though it is significantly heavier.
Handling much better.
spares, don't think that there is much difference apart from the 8 is the newer car and as such spares will be more readily available for a longer period of time.
Corrosion protection is limited for both so get them undersealed or don't use them on salty roads.
Power increase potential is similar but the last VXR8's have the LS3 engine with a little more capacity and better heads.
My VXR8 is better built than the monaro and has up to now been virtually trouble free.
My Monaro was always having warranty work done on well known faults, leaky doors, brakes, flaky door handles etc.
By the time I sold it these were all put right and the next owner got a great car.
I loved my Monaro and only sold it because the last new VXR8's were total bargains.
Which would I say is the better car? VXR8 with the LS3 no question.
Would you make a mistake in buying a Monaro, definitely not as long as its issues had been sorted.

ringram

14,702 posts

279 months

Tuesday 15th June 2010
quotequote all
Monaro is ok IF you get the 04 model with the large boot.
BUT brakes suck and the wheels are 8" wide so traction is a major issue.
If you are looking to upgrade the 10" wide vxr8 wheels are way better as are the brakes as mentioned.
They also have bluetooth phone support and as mentioned are basically superior in almost all aspects.

The vxr8 is a 2005 design, whereas the Monaro is a 1997 or so and it tells.

There is suggestion that the new vxr8 model will be here at the end of this year. That should help with parts and spares. Plus lower 2nd hand prices on the older models. Are the LS3's worth £6 more than the LS2's?
Im not so sure. The heads are $1300 USD and the intake around $600 from memory, so for £1300 odd you have the same top end, but with 20 less cubes or so.
Id pay maybe 2-3K more for the LS3 no more. A cam only LS2 will waste any and all stock LS3's Actually rockers and intake will beat a stock LS3 for £500.

The LS3 is definately better, but its not worth the current £6k differential on prices.

007 VXR

64,187 posts

218 months

Tuesday 15th June 2010
quotequote all
vxr8 wheels are 9.5 not 10 biggrin

i love my monaro ,but have been in a vxr8, standard the r8 is better than a standar ro ..IMHO

but would still have the monaro smile

Edited by 007 VXR on Tuesday 15th June 20:23

ringram

14,702 posts

279 months

Tuesday 15th June 2010
quotequote all
007 VXR said:
vxr8 wheels are 9.5 not 10 biggrin
The OBR says its 10. Hehe, Ive had C6's on the brain recently. So yes 9.5 smile

ARAF

20,759 posts

254 months

Tuesday 15th June 2010
quotequote all
The interior on a Monaro is better screwed together than a VXR8, (IMHO) and feels like a nicer place to be - though isn't as modern in appearance.

Rich,
I love the way you justify the LS2 over the LS3 to yourself. laugh

scz4

2,857 posts

272 months

Tuesday 15th June 2010
quotequote all
ringram said:
There is suggestion that the new vxr8 model will be here at the end of this year
Tell me more! smile Any spy shots, specifications etc yet? I could be tempted to hold off from buying a used VXR8.

007 VXR

64,187 posts

218 months

Tuesday 15th June 2010
quotequote all
scz4 said:
ringram said:
There is suggestion that the new vxr8 model will be here at the end of this year
Tell me more! smile Any spy shots, specifications etc yet? I could be tempted to hold off from buying a used VXR8.
think walkinshaw have one

ARAF

20,759 posts

254 months

Tuesday 15th June 2010
quotequote all
...and Picadors are advertising them.

ringram

14,702 posts

279 months

Tuesday 15th June 2010
quotequote all
ARAF said:
I love the way you justify the LS2 over the LS3 to yourself. laugh
Its all about power mate. Otherwise the cars are basically the same.
People pay for ethereal things which have no intrinsic value only percieved value. Like personalised plates and the Daily Mail newspaper.
I like to boil down things to fundamentals smile

MyM8V8

9,468 posts

226 months

Wednesday 16th June 2010
quotequote all
ringram said:
ARAF said:
I love the way you justify the LS2 over the LS3 to yourself. laugh
Its all about power mate. Otherwise the cars are basically the same.
People pay for ethereal things which have no intrinsic value only percieved value. Like personalised plates and the Daily Mail newspaper.
I like to give people st at every available opportunity smile
wink

Edited by MyM8V8 on Wednesday 16th June 00:49

scz4

2,857 posts

272 months

Wednesday 16th June 2010
quotequote all
ARAF said:
...and Picadors are advertising them.
Do you have a link to this? Had a look on their website but couldn't see anything.

ARAF

20,759 posts

254 months

Wednesday 16th June 2010
quotequote all
scz4 said:
ARAF said:
...and Picadors are advertising them.
Do you have a link to this? Had a look on their website but couldn't see anything.
In their news items

http://www.picadorplc.co.uk/plus/new-vxr8

scz4

2,857 posts

272 months

Wednesday 16th June 2010
quotequote all
ARAF said:
Thanks, too early for me smile

Is it just me or does the interior look exactly the same?

Wonder if I should hold off or not smile

motomk

2,189 posts

275 months

Wednesday 16th June 2010
quotequote all
ARAF said:
scz4 said:
ARAF said:
...and Picadors are advertising them.


Do you have a link to this? Had a look on their website but couldn't see anything.


In their news items

www.picadorplc.co.uk/plus/new-vxr8


Seen a few on the road down here now and they still look like they have walked off the set of the Fast and Furious! The older version is nicer in my opinion! In the lastest Wheels magazine they have an artists impression of the lastest VE II SS which looks rather nice to me....but then I am bias!

looks a bit like a cross beween a Pontiac GXP, VE SS and a HSV VE R8.

ARAF

20,759 posts

254 months

Wednesday 16th June 2010
quotequote all
motomk said:
ARAF said:
scz4 said:
ARAF said:
...and Picadors are advertising them.
Do you have a link to this? Had a look on their website but couldn't see anything.
In their news items

http://www.picadorplc.co.uk/plus/new-vxr8
Seen a few on the road down here now and they still look like they have walked off the set of the Fast and Furious! The older version is nicer in my opinion! In the lastest Wheels magazine they have an artists impression of the lastest VE II SS which looks rather nice to me....but then I am bias!

looks a bit like a cross beween a Pontiac GXP, VE SS and a HSV VE R8.
I think the new front suits the E2 Maloo, but the saloon is just too busy for me.

ringram

14,702 posts

279 months

Wednesday 16th June 2010
quotequote all
Im pretty sure its just a body kit change. It looks crap IMO too.
But if its released it will put pressure on 2nd hand prices. Even though it will list in the mid/high £30k range IMO.

C8PPO

20,881 posts

234 months

Wednesday 16th June 2010
quotequote all
ARAF said:
yikes That's fvcking hideous! (And no, I'm not coming from the Monaro vs R8 angle. It just is.)

Looks like ten years down the line when the "kids" can afford to buy 'em and then throw the entire contents of the Halfords Ripspeed catalogue at the car.

Ghastly.


motomk

2,189 posts

275 months

Wednesday 16th June 2010
quotequote all
ringram said:
Im pretty sure its just a body kit change. It looks crap IMO too.
But if its released it will put pressure on 2nd hand prices. Even though it will list in the mid/high £30k range IMO.


I seem to remember reading something about a wider front or rear guards/track so they could fit wider rubber on it.