My Monaro misery.. update
My Monaro misery.. update
Author
Discussion

AndiD

Original Poster:

147 posts

198 months

Thursday 17th June 2010
quotequote all
So mines the VXR that stalls and cuts out all time since I bought it a couple of months ago..

No luck with Vauxhall and nobody has been able to find out what's causing it.

A couple of weeks ago it got so bad it became dangerous so I stuck it on the back of a trailer and sent it down to Walkinshaw. The guys down there have been really good to be honest and spent a lot of time on the phone to Australia. They've even been on to the MD and the guys from the R&D dept who worked on designing it!

There's some weird issue where the chassis number doesn't match the ECU and although there's no record, a previous owner has swapped the ECU and had it mapped somewhere. Either a bad map has caused a big problem, the ECU is failing or something between all of them is just not right.

Ken called today to say HSV are recommending a new ECU and ignition system, all recoded from scratch to basically start again with the electronics. Total cost £2k!! They've already spent hours and hours trying to find it so it's a fair price but 2 grand is a LOT of money, especially when the actual engine and everything else is fine.. and it doesn't even guarantee to fix the problem, but if that's what HSVs top guys reckon it's got to be worth a shot. Unfortunately I don't have any choice.

I spoke to Picador in Southampton where the car came from today, to ask if they'd give a goodwill contribution to the cost as it's only just out of the VX warranty, but as a trader friend bought it for me it didn't come with their warranty so they wouldn't help. Fair play really.

I'd be interested to know if someone else from this board ever had the car previously. There's also only 3 or 4 places it could have been mapped so it's weird there's no record of it. It's an 07 silver and the reg is L*** VXR.

Cross fingers time now, and hope that in a couple of weeks it'll be all worth it when I turn the key and hear that rumble.

For now.. sad face!!

ringram

14,702 posts

279 months

Thursday 17th June 2010
quotequote all
Ok, so new coil packs and ECU? How often does it fault?
Sounds like the area of trouble anyway. Pity you cant "borrow" a coil pack from someone to see if that fixes the problem to eliminate either or. Rather than buying a new one of both.
An E40 ECU shouldnt cost too much either. That should also be an easy swap to test if you have the where-with-all
Anyway Im sure WPUK will sort you out.
Could also be dodgy wiring shorting out, which may require a new loom.
Ill give you £2k for the car if it gets too much biggrin

gsd2000

11,515 posts

214 months

Thursday 17th June 2010
quotequote all
ringram said:
Ok, so new coil packs and ECU? How often does it fault?
Sounds like the area of trouble anyway. Pity you cant "borrow" a coil pack from someone to see if that fixes the problem to eliminate either or. Rather than buying a new one of both.
An E40 ECU shouldnt cost too much either. That should also be an easy swap to test if you have the where-with-all
Anyway Im sure WPUK will sort you out.
Could also be dodgy wiring shorting out, which may require a new loom.
Ill give you £2k for the car if it gets too much biggrin
i was thinking that, maybe a dodgy wiring loom

I bit 2k and a penny wink

Edited by gsd2000 on Thursday 17th June 21:13

spudmonkeybikes

1,205 posts

241 months

Thursday 17th June 2010
quotequote all
That don't sound good, have they re-flashed a clean map into the ECU yet and tried that. Have you called Monkfish yet for some advice as 2k is a lot to spend if it's not a 100% fix.

AndiD

Original Poster:

147 posts

198 months

Thursday 17th June 2010
quotequote all
spudmonkeybikes said:
That don't sound good, have they re-flashed a clean map into the ECU yet and tried that. Have you called Monkfish yet for some advice as 2k is a lot to spend if it's not a 100% fix.


I'm not 100% on the details but because there's this weird non-matching problem with the codes there's very little they can do with the ECU - I think they have to be programmed to the car in Oz. Basically.. nothing can be done until the ECu is changed. VX said the same.

I've cancelled my Monkfish appointment on the 28th as WP have already spent hours going through everything with HSV and with this kind of thing they're good due to their direct links with Oz.

Hopefully I'll be booking another Fish appointment in a few months for some mods

monkfish1

12,522 posts

255 months

Thursday 17th June 2010
quotequote all
scratchchin

AndiD

Original Poster:

147 posts

198 months

Thursday 17th June 2010
quotequote all
ringram said:
Ok, so new coil packs and ECU? How often does it fault?
Sounds like the area of trouble anyway. Pity you cant "borrow" a coil pack from someone to see if that fixes the problem to eliminate either or. Rather than buying a new one of both.
An E40 ECU shouldnt cost too much either. That should also be an easy swap to test if you have the where-with-all
Anyway Im sure WPUK will sort you out.
Could also be dodgy wiring shorting out, which may require a new loom.
Ill give you £2k for the car if it gets too much


Sorry - bad explanation - it's not coil packs.. it's something like a PRM module (or something like that - can't remember off hand) to do with the ignition control.. costs around £300

My fear is the wiring loom if this doesn't work.. it's got to be difficult to find a fault in all those tiny cables.. and a lot of labour to replace!

Can only cross fingers now and hope it works

AndiD

Original Poster:

147 posts

198 months

Thursday 17th June 2010
quotequote all
monkfish1 said:
scratchchin


haha.. what does that little face mean?

Emailed you guys this afternoon Roger.. had to get it in to WP a couple of weeks ago as it became totally undrivable and I know you didn't have any space for another month.

Shame you guys are so busy! too good for your own good!

Will defo be down soon though.

well_fans

4,193 posts

255 months

Friday 18th June 2010
quotequote all
ecu on a vxr isnt the same as the cv8 is it? could let you borrow a cv8 ecu if they're the same to test out the theory but I've got a feeling they're different models. be no issues with wiping it either as I've already got it backed up with efilive. must be someone with an ecu lying about for a vxr that could be wiped to start again with?

mfurse

19 posts

200 months

Friday 18th June 2010
quotequote all
OMG, had this car done ~7K miles when you bought it? I think I might have looked at it in Picador back along...

crisisjez

9,209 posts

236 months

Friday 18th June 2010
quotequote all
Just a thought before you go repacing the ecu. If its not the one in the HSV record it may already have been changed so perhaps someone has gone down that route to fix the same problem.
Maybe its worthwhile contacting the previous owner, they may be able to help, especially if its an existing problem that occurred within the warranty period

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 18th June 2010
quotequote all
Soundslike wiring to me. From what I know, the ecm, bcm etc will either work or not. I had a similar issue which took ages to find. I took it to mark who in turn got an auto electrician to go through the wiring. Turned out there is a connector block where the loom splits behind the bulk head to go into the engine bay. There have also been reported problems with the immobiliser cutting out. Just swapping bits out at random is not the answer in my opinion. Gets decent auto electrician to look at it.

ringram

14,702 posts

279 months

Friday 18th June 2010
quotequote all
crisisjez said:
Just a thought before you go repacing the ecu. If its not the one in the HSV record it may already have been changed so perhaps someone has gone down that route to fix the same problem.
Maybe its worthwhile contacting the previous owner, they may be able to help, especially if its an existing problem that occurred within the warranty periodsmile
Yep, good idea. Maybe messing around with the connectors when swapping the ECU made it seem like it had worked, but actual problem is in loom.
Anyway, much better to find someone with bits to swap... maybe Raving can help out!? Or call around some more. Instead of getting new stuff from Oz try raving, he might have some stuff in stock at a much better price and be willing to let you swap them around and return whats not used. Im sure he could mark the items so they dont get mixed up.

AndiD

Original Poster:

147 posts

198 months

Friday 18th June 2010
quotequote all
mfurse said:
OMG, had this car done ~7K miles when you bought it? I think I might have looked at it in Picador back along...


No.. it's got 34k on the clock.. however it's been sold through Picador so it may have been the same one a couple of years back..?

AndiD

Original Poster:

147 posts

198 months

Friday 18th June 2010
quotequote all
ringram said:
crisisjez said:
Just a thought before you go repacing the ecu. If its not the one in the HSV record it may already have been changed so perhaps someone has gone down that route to fix the same problem.
Maybe its worthwhile contacting the previous owner, they may be able to help, especially if its an existing problem that occurred within the warranty period


Yep, good idea. Maybe messing around with the connectors when swapping the ECU made it seem like it had worked, but actual problem is in loom.
Anyway, much better to find someone with bits to swap... maybe Raving can help out!? Or call around some more. Instead of getting new stuff from Oz try raving, he might have some stuff in stock at a much better price and be willing to let you swap them around and return whats not used. Im sure he could mark the items so they dont get mixed up.


I'm really not good with electronics so I'm way out of my depth, but (from what I've been told) does the ECU not have to be paid with the chassis number and programmed in Oz for it to work? I may be wrong here but I didn't think you could just swap them around.

I did ask Walkinshaw what if I spend £2k and the problem's still there..? They said they'd come to an agreement and keep the ECU on the shelf so hopefully all wouldn't be lost.

SimonV8ster

13,039 posts

259 months

Friday 18th June 2010
quotequote all
Can't see why you can't unplug one and then plug another in ? You could a few years back with other cars. Unless its now programmed into the immobiliser/alarm as well ?

monkfish1

12,522 posts

255 months

Friday 18th June 2010
quotequote all
SimonV8ster said:
Can't see why you can't unplug one and then plug another in ? You could a few years back with other cars. Unless its now programmed into the immobiliser/alarm as well ?


It is. You cant just swap them around.

ringram

14,702 posts

279 months

Friday 18th June 2010
quotequote all
No you can swap ECU's as much as you like.
You just need some software like efilive etc to do it.
ECU tune files like the ones here www.holdencrazy.com just flash in. You can write your VIN number in there as well, but it doesnt matter if its there or not.
You can also tell it to rebond to the key for VATS and thats pretty much all you need to do.
VXR8's you need the right year ECU as they changed slightly between years, but as long as the hardware is the same you can just swap it over and flash it with the correct tune.

monkfish1

12,522 posts

255 months

Friday 18th June 2010
quotequote all
ringram said:
No you can swap ECU's as much as you like.
You just need some software like efilive etc to do it.
ECU tune files like the ones here www.holdencrazy.com just flash in. You can write your VIN number in there as well, but it doesnt matter if its there or not.
You can also tell it to rebond to the key for VATS and thats pretty much all you need to do.
VXR8's you need the right year ECU as they changed slightly between years, but as long as the hardware is the same you can just swap it over and flash it with the correct tune.


You know thats what i meant. You cant just swap and start the car.

MyM8V8

9,468 posts

226 months

Friday 18th June 2010
quotequote all
VATS = Vehicle Anti Theft System.

What do you know about the history of this car???

Something is a bit fishy.

Edited by MyM8V8 on Friday 18th June 18:03