Problems, problems, problems...
Problems, problems, problems...
Author
Discussion

djwilk

Original Poster:

1,693 posts

200 months

Saturday 19th June 2010
quotequote all
Hello chaps.

I will be brief, so as follows:

The car is a VXR8 LS2. It had a free flow exhaust with de-cat done.

Later on it went to Tuner A for Service, Wortec CAI, speed limiter removal and secondary O2 sensors to be switched off. As far as I know HP Tuners was used.

Some time later the car went to Tuner B for a remap so that all above mentioned mods could be taken into account and be made to work to their best. EFI live was being used.

Partial reason for that was the fact that the car is running rich.

It also has LPG and on this evil fuel it is running lean.

Tens of Dyno runs and it appears that everytime any single setting is changed on the Petrol map the car starts misfiring above 4k revs and goes into safety mode. Once the settings are undone it goes back to normal. All of that is being done on petrol where the LPG system is switched off although signals to Petrol injectors are going through the LPG ECU (although bypassed).

Still the car pings DCT P00068. MAF blah, blah, blah...

Now what is the likelihood that signals are being distorted by LPG (strangely only when settings on petrol map have been changed).

And what is the likelihood that alterations to the petrol map done by Tuner A using HP Tuners are for some reason not allowing any mods with EFI Live by Tuner B?

Please, someone shed some light. The car is going to Tuner B on Wednesday with LPG completely bypassed (in a way that signals from ECU to Injectors are not going through LPG ECU - in other words LPG is as if it wasn't there at all). I am also going to Europe mid July and don't want to blow the engine up doing silly 155mph+...

Help anyone?

cheers
Bart

stigmundfreud

22,454 posts

241 months

Saturday 19th June 2010
quotequote all
eliminate the LPG ECU, tbh anything that is a piggyback is never a good thing. Take that fully out of the loop and start from there rather than guessing only to later find out that it was the cause. How on earth does it tie into the system anyway?


stigmundfreud

22,454 posts

241 months

Saturday 19th June 2010
quotequote all
also prior to tuner A doing anything did they take a copy of the orignal tune? I know who tuner A is and who Tuner B is just purely based on the software mentioned.

When the LPG was put on what was done to the car? Was a custom OS put onto the ECU which has subsequently been lost? It is possible that the HPT tune was a custom OS and the EFI one is based on a standard one. Did Tuner B take a copy of the map that was on the car? If so then it wasnt a custom OS. When Tuner B resets things what are they resetting? Back to the tune that Tuner A had left on it? Was this mis-fire evident before TunerB did work?

Are you saying that when the tune is on the orignal there is no misfire above 4000rpm but soon as a new tune is on something is amiss? What are the differences between the tunes? What is being changed to cause the misfire? We need to know what you mean by reset, is that reset to the HPT tune tables? What tables does the EFI flash include etc?

Only Tuner B can answer

doleboy

747 posts

248 months

Sunday 20th June 2010
quotequote all
Take the piggy back out of the equation, then check what the MAF and TPS are up to. Maybe the LPG thing is doing something hidden to the underlying tune.

Potentially could be a faulty MAF or TPS sensor or their values are being modified in an unusual way.

Some ECU's/tunes will double check the MAF reading with a predicted value calculated off the TPS. If there's a big mismatch the car will go into safety mode.



djwilk

Original Poster:

1,693 posts

200 months

Sunday 20th June 2010
quotequote all
I do not think Tuner A took a copy of the original tune, but when spoke to Tuner B they stated that it seems T/A only modified settings in the generic map, so just in case those settings can be reverted back to generic (being O2 sensors and speed limiter).

Before LPG was put on nothing was being done in terms of mods or map. When T/B got to work on the car he was working on the generic map, he strongly advised not to put or modify a map from another car. So I am guessing that no copy of original tune was being taken since we were working on the original tune. (or in other words the one that the other tuner had left which seems to be original with o2 sensors and speed limiter switched off).

Prior to Tuner B getting engaged with the map everything was dundee. Well apart from the car running rich. As soon as he modified any settings in the map it misfired. Undo the settings and it is back to normal with no misfire.

As to what it was being reset to, I couldn't tell as I don't know (only a newbie to software remap on LS engines).

As to the way LPG is wired into the the equasion. All signals to Petrol injectors are going through LPG ECU. This way LPG can read the injection timing and other parameters that then are followed by LPG injectors. Also when it is running on gas Petrol injectors are emulated but do not work at all. At the moment LPG has been bypassed completely and on Wednesday we will see what happens.

cheerio

Edited by djwilk on Sunday 20th June 18:41

MyM8V8

9,468 posts

226 months

Sunday 20th June 2010
quotequote all
LPG is for fork lift trucks.

stigmundfreud

22,454 posts

241 months

Sunday 20th June 2010
quotequote all
OK sounds normal for what T/A and T/B have done and T/B has said the right thing with regards to using other tunes. Definitely you need to take that piggyback out of the question and I bet it is that as the signal getting to the injectors appears to be getting messed up by that ECU. I'm going to hazard a guess that what T/B is doing is adjusting the injector flow rates which is a method of controling fueling and one that a piggyback might well interfere with.

When you say it is running rich, how rich? What AFR? Is it only rich when at WOT or PE ranges or is it rich even at normal conditions? The car should be in closed loop with the O2 sensors providing trim controls so is it only when you are entering power enrichment that it is rich and if so what is the AFR? Any graphs to show? If you are only chasing a small AFR to be leaned out at PE/WOT ranges then is it worth it? You said you knew it was lean when on LPG, how did you know this?

Tuning the fuel output by adjusting the IFR isnt the best of methods but it is a method that works but its not the most accurate. If you get your VE table dialed in to your spark and IFR maps then everything is kept in track. The key is what is your AFR at normal driving on petrol and what is it when giving it some, then the same for when on LPG.

It wont be something either T/A or T/B has done, it will be 99% that bloody piggy back

stigmundfreud

22,454 posts

241 months

Sunday 20th June 2010
quotequote all
MyM8V8 said:
LPG is for fork lift trucks.
lol!

Also to the O/P make sure if you are eliminating TPS you record the correct PID as the SAE.TPS is a % of 5v which means at WOT it will register something like 88% which is 88% of 5v or 100% throttle open so log on the GM.TPS reading. As doleboy said though you would get a CEL code if there was an issue there.

djwilk

Original Poster:

1,693 posts

200 months

Sunday 20th June 2010
quotequote all
I will post a graph from Dyno when I get home shortly. That one shows the AFR for both Petrol and LPG. As to all other things I don't know what T/A or T/B was adjusting. As said before it is complete magic for me.

I am hoping that it is LPG that messes up, but then what do I do with it in the end since I spent well over £2k last December. I know - don't use it but that defeats the point of having it in the first place... (yes, I shouldn't have done it - but then how come others with S/C are running no probs?) Would there be any problem with LPG itself?

djwilk

Original Poster:

1,693 posts

200 months

Sunday 20th June 2010
quotequote all
As mentione before the graph from the dyno. The red line is the petrol AFR, the blue one is the LPG one.



Edited by djwilk on Sunday 20th June 21:26

stigmundfreud

22,454 posts

241 months

Sunday 20th June 2010
quotequote all
cant decypher that afr as the chart is using what measurements? Is that just a bad scan, you appear to be missing the details for the AFR readings. Yes we can see teh lines but not the actual reading as the numbers on the side seem to go all over the shop

also 393hp at the wheels?!

Magic919

14,595 posts

232 months

Sunday 20th June 2010
quotequote all
Got to admire the LPG guys for blaming the petrol map for the inadequacy of their piggyback set-up. Not the first time I've heard that. They blame the petrol map for their AFR going barmy. Interesting.

Bonnie and Clyde

11,701 posts

223 months

Sunday 20th June 2010
quotequote all
Thats an odd looking graph. Mind you i dont know anything about dyno's. It just looks a bit bitty silly

djwilk

Original Poster:

1,693 posts

200 months

Sunday 20th June 2010
quotequote all
Sorry, corrected the graph, hopefully makes sense now.

As to the LPG guys, they weren't blaming the petrol map, but naturally for me as well as the LPG follows the Petrol map settings, Petrol map has to be right and optimal. And as the mods have been done after the LPG has been fitted, therefore LPG AFR is going looney as well.


Mel, the map does only show the AFR and power curve so yeah, a lil bit twisty

As to the power... I wish it was on the wheels, that is flywheel however (I know not at its best, the best result shown was 396hp).

Edited by djwilk on Sunday 20th June 21:34


Edited by djwilk on Sunday 20th June 21:35

stigmundfreud

22,454 posts

241 months

Sunday 20th June 2010
quotequote all
Looking at those AFR's I wouldnt touch it, at all.

djwilk

Original Poster:

1,693 posts

200 months

Sunday 20th June 2010
quotequote all
How do you mean?

stigmundfreud

22,454 posts

241 months

Sunday 20th June 2010
quotequote all
djwilk said:
How do you mean?
your petrol AFR looks good and your LPG one looks a little rich on one and a little lean on the other but you aren't in any danger zones. IE Dont do anything to the car. Its bloody ok as it is.

I dont know how many other ways I can tell you to save your money but simply dont touch it

djwilk

Original Poster:

1,693 posts

200 months

Sunday 20th June 2010
quotequote all
Well, I was hoping that by doing the map I could get some more ponies as well. No?

Bonnie and Clyde

11,701 posts

223 months

Sunday 20th June 2010
quotequote all
djwilk said:
Well, I was hoping that by doing the map I could get some more ponies as well. No?
It could work that way or it could work the other If it aint broke dont fix it. Seriously

djwilk

Original Poster:

1,693 posts

200 months

Sunday 20th June 2010
quotequote all
Now it makes me wonder. So although the CAI and free flow exhaust, by doing the remap I am potentially losing some power? Certainly something that some tuners charge £700 for are there to make a positive difference, no?