Straight 6 v V8?
Author
Discussion

swindorski46

Original Poster:

1,017 posts

312 months

Thursday 11th March 2004
quotequote all
Ok, excuse the lack of my technical knowledge, but what are the advantages/disadvantages of a V8 as opposed to a straight 6? (In lamens terms)

I'm sure it's been done before, but for me!

oxbow

567 posts

279 months

Thursday 11th March 2004
quotequote all
Advantage of straight six is it's in a TUS.

satman

2,455 posts

275 months

Thursday 11th March 2004
quotequote all
V8 definately sounds much nicer...

the dodger

2,376 posts

292 months

Thursday 11th March 2004
quotequote all
The advantages and disadvantages of a V8 are two more cylinders. A straight six is naturally balanced. Nothing in this world sounds as good as a V8 - especially TVR V8.

li'l pugs

1,323 posts

288 months

Friday 12th March 2004
quotequote all
Rover V8 virtually bomb proof, sounds the dogs danglies. TVR V8 a little more "tempremental", sounds the dogs danglies. Straight 6, sounds the dogs danglies, but in a missing 2 cylinders kind of way.

tubbystu

3,846 posts

289 months

Friday 12th March 2004
quotequote all
And sixes is for pussy's, in a jaguar kind of way

I was overtaken a couple of weeks ago on the A31 near the Hen and Chickens by a Tuscan and I couldn't hear it, even when it went passed.

Other motorists move over because they can hear my V8S coming up behind them - its like a snowplough with some of the middle and outside lane hogs. I think of it as a community service. Jeez knows what effect a SEAC would have, though I'm sure I'll get told.

valhalla

2,246 posts

285 months

Friday 12th March 2004
quotequote all
the dodger said:
The advantages and disadvantages of a V8 are two more cylinders. A straight six is naturally balanced. Nothing in this world sounds as good as a V8 - especially TVR V8.


Some day all TVR's will have a straight six Roger

Dave

900T-R

20,406 posts

286 months

Friday 12th March 2004
quotequote all
I love them both for different reasons. Speed 6 -the closest thing to a pure racing engine I've ever sampled in a road car, raw, sounds like a great big superbike, fantastic throttle response and goes up and down the rev range like you wouldn't believe. RV8 - sounds like distant thunder as you pootle along, wads of big fat torque to shift you along, absolutely hammers like a NASCAR engine when you nail the loud pedal.

As to paraphrase a car mag, both sound good enough to have their own recording contract, though the RV8 might be more appealing when wafting along instead of absolutely gunning it. Then again, the instant revability and shocking pace of the Sp6 and its rawness are a great experience, too.

Never drove an AJP8-engined car, though.

the dodger

2,376 posts

292 months

Friday 12th March 2004
quotequote all
just trouble said:

valhalla said:


the dodger said:
The advantages and disadvantages of a V8 are two more cylinders. A straight six is naturally balanced. Nothing in this world sounds as good as a V8 - especially TVR V8.




Some day all TVR's will have a straight six Roger

Dave


Not in my F****** life time!!

('Ere 'ere) JT.

Long live the AJPV8.
..anyone else aware that the AJP is based on John Judd's F1 engine?

T88CAN

3,474 posts

286 months

Friday 12th March 2004
quotequote all
tubbystu said:

I was overtaken a couple of weeks ago on the A31 near the Hen and Chickens by a Tuscan SP6


Nothing else to add

glena

362 posts

277 months

Friday 12th March 2004
quotequote all
And the Rover V8 is or was originally an American engine which first went into production in 1961 into Buick and Pontiac cars

the dodger

2,376 posts

292 months

Friday 12th March 2004
quotequote all
glena said:
And the Rover V8 is or was originally an American engine which first went into production in 1961 into Buick and Pontiac cars

Yes/No - original Buick lump was earlier than that - but all iron.

tubbystu

3,846 posts

289 months

Saturday 13th March 2004
quotequote all
T88CAN said:

tubbystu said:

I was overtaken a couple of weeks ago on the A31 near the Hen and Chickens by a Tuscan SP6



Nothing else to add


I was pootleing along near treble figures , going to for a cuppa tea with my 90 yr old grandmother, the Tusc glid passed almost SILENTLY. It wasn't a race, and I know who would have one if it was, before you start.

joospeed

4,473 posts

307 months

Saturday 13th March 2004
quotequote all
the dodger said:


..anyone else aware that the AJP is based on John Judd's F1 engine?



yeah rumour has it he thought that basing a modern engine on two coventry climax Imp fours was taking the piss so he dumped it, TVR bought it for peanuts .. lol

T88CAN

3,474 posts

286 months

Saturday 13th March 2004
quotequote all
tubbystu said:

T88CAN said:


tubbystu said:

I was overtaken a couple of weeks ago on the A31 near the Hen and Chickens by a Tuscan SP6




Nothing else to add



I was pootleing along near treble figures , going to for a cuppa tea with my 90 yr old grandmother, the Tusc glid passed almost SILENTLY. It wasn't a race, and I know who would have one if it was, before you start.



Hi Stu
I`m normally a very active member of the South Hants mob but have been off the scene recently,no doubt we will meet over the next couple of months and rest assured you will be hearing me

whitey

2,508 posts

313 months

Saturday 13th March 2004
quotequote all
T88CAN said:

tubbystu said:


T88CAN said:



tubbystu said:

I was overtaken a couple of weeks ago on the A31 near the Hen and Chickens by a Tuscan SP6





Nothing else to add




I was pootleing along near treble figures , going to for a cuppa tea with my 90 yr old grandmother, the Tusc glid passed almost SILENTLY. It wasn't a race, and I know who would have one if it was, before you start.




Hi Stu
I`m normally a very active member of the South Hants mob but have been off the scene recently,no doubt we will meet over the next couple of months and rest assured you will be hearing me


CCC's are us.

the dodger

2,376 posts

292 months

Saturday 13th March 2004
quotequote all
joospeed said:

the dodger said:


..anyone else aware that the AJP is based on John Judd's F1 engine?




yeah rumour has it he thought that basing a modern engine on two coventry climax Imp fours was taking the piss so he dumped it, TVR bought it for peanuts .. lol

Jules, did the Imp lump have fabricated crankcase then? I thought it was cast alloy
Oh well, somedays you learn nothing!

T88CAN

3,474 posts

286 months

Sunday 14th March 2004
quotequote all
whitey said:

T88CAN said:


tubbystu said:



T88CAN said:




tubbystu said:

I was overtaken a couple of weeks ago on the A31 near the Hen and Chickens by a Tuscan SP6






Nothing else to add





I was pootleing along near treble figures , going to for a cuppa tea with my 90 yr old grandmother, the Tusc glid passed almost SILENTLY. It wasn't a race, and I know who would have one if it was, before you start.





Hi Stu
I`m normally a very active member of the South Hants mob but have been off the scene recently,no doubt we will meet over the next couple of months and rest assured you will be hearing me



CCC's are us.



The last time we spoke Andrew i said i was concerned about the overall refinement on motorways ect with the CCC`s fitted, so i`m going for sleeves first to see how it goes, We must get together again soon Tony

Whitey

2,508 posts

313 months

Sunday 14th March 2004
quotequote all
T88CAN said:

whitey said:


T88CAN said:



tubbystu said:




T88CAN said:





tubbystu said:

I was overtaken a couple of weeks ago on the A31 near the Hen and Chickens by a Tuscan SP6







Nothing else to add






I was pootleing along near treble figures , going to for a cuppa tea with my 90 yr old grandmother, the Tusc glid passed almost SILENTLY. It wasn't a race, and I know who would have one if it was, before you start.






Hi Stu
I`m normally a very active member of the South Hants mob but have been off the scene recently,no doubt we will meet over the next couple of months and rest assured you will be hearing me




CCC's are us.




The last time we spoke Andrew i said i was concerned about the overall refinement on motorways ect with the CCC`s fitted, so i`m going for sleeves first to see how it goes, We must get together again soon Tony


you can borrow my sleeved cans first to try them if you want? or just swap em for your standard cans so I can do track days...

T88CAN

3,474 posts

286 months

Sunday 14th March 2004
quotequote all
Whitey YHM