The boys are back in town: F50 vs Carrera GT
The boys are back in town: F50 vs Carrera GT
Author
Discussion

456mgt

Original Poster:

2,518 posts

297 months

Monday 21st June 2010
quotequote all


It's been a while but now the Carrera GT is back from Reading after it's valve clearance service and it's game on! Since it's been away, the F50 has taken up residence and initial impressions of that car raised the question why have the GT at all, since the F50 seemed to have all the bases covered.

To do things properly, Murcielago_boy and a couple of friends came up for the day and we drove them back to back, after several weeks of not being in either car. So everything was fresh.

First things first; which is fastest? In gear acceleration at any speed it's no contest. I had the F50 absolutely nailed and MB in the Carrera GT just romped away. It's what you'd expect since the cars weigh about the same same while the GT has an extra litre or so and 100bhp. Still, I was surprised since the 50 feels so damn fast.

In the handling stakes, it's a little closer. The F50 has a harder, more fidgety ride and doesn't roll as much as the GT, though in truth, this is angels on the head of a pin, since neither rolls very much at all. You can place both cars super-accurately, but where you can take the F50 by the scruff of the neck and throw it around, you have to be much more delicate with the Carrera GT. I suspect this is because of the electronic throttle and servo assisstance in the latter so you get the best out of it by driving with the tips of your fingers and toes. You use your arms and legs in the F50.

Where the F50 really stands out is in sheer savagery and drama. Watching the F50 fly past in a blizzard of noise and flames you're left in no doubt that this is a very special car. The sheer power of the engine note as it goes past is incredible. You can't help but catch your breath and gape at it. If you have an ounce of petrol in your veins, you'd never tire of the sight and sound of an F50 at full bore. The Carrera GT has no answer to this, and that, in effect, is the point. It's a far more honed and polished device. All the styling touches, the thought that's gone into the layout. In fact we met the designer of the car at the carrera GT event organised by Porsche, and he stressed that the design team had been involved at every stage of the car, which is unusual. It shows too, especially when you compare it to the F50. Which is basically an engine bolted to a carbon fibre box, plonk in seats, pedal box and steerring wheel. Job's a good 'un.




More subjectively, I think the strong design theme of the Carrera GT shows on the skin, and it's the better looking of the two. People often say, 'oh, that's the one that looks like a Ferrari', which I think is a compliment. As a rule, women seem to prefer the Carrera GT, men the F50. If you're a woman, your hair gets mussed up in both, and it's harder to get into the GT, but once you're there, it's the more civilised place to be. In the F50, the first thought is where's the door handle so I can get out again.

In the end, I came away with the view that you can justify keeping both. Each, in my view, represents the best of breed with the added sweetener of being convertibles. But they have very different moods. As MB said at the end, you could drive the Carrera GT in a suit and not look out of place, whereas you'd look a tt if you did that in the F50.

Complex

520 posts

206 months

Monday 21st June 2010
quotequote all
Nice read, thanks.

Forthright MC

8,362 posts

314 months

Monday 21st June 2010
quotequote all
Awesome, just awesome stuff! Nice comparison, so hard to beat the drama of the F50 tho'!... smokin

paddy328

2,930 posts

216 months

Monday 21st June 2010
quotequote all
Thanks for sharing. Both cars are in my dream garage and I think the gt looks best in black.

Rocksteadyeddie

7,971 posts

258 months

Monday 21st June 2010
quotequote all
Really good comparison from somehow who knows.

Thanks for sharing.

ilovevolvo

1,832 posts

255 months

Monday 21st June 2010
quotequote all
Great write up Kevin a true couple of dream cars you have if you ever need to test them again i am always free smile

I do like the CGT it makes a fantasic noise but the F50 is stunning and raw i like that very much in a car smile

Russ

Funk

27,820 posts

240 months

Monday 21st June 2010
quotequote all
...and this is why I love Pistonheads!

ZeroH

2,922 posts

220 months

Monday 21st June 2010
quotequote all
Great read... Thanks for sharing your thoughts on these two beasts !!

jon-

16,534 posts

247 months

Monday 21st June 2010
quotequote all
Here's a hard question, which do you think sounds better? The F1 inspired V12 in the F50, or the ultra high tech V10 in the CGT? They are quite literally the two best sounding cars in the world, what a dream garage!

PS, were you flying after an F40 last Monday on the M25 around 10pm?

cronk-flakes

3,480 posts

284 months

Monday 21st June 2010
quotequote all
Wow... Thanks for sharing, what a great read!

thumbup

RallyRider

1,127 posts

235 months

Monday 21st June 2010
quotequote all
Nice little write-up, thanks

abarth130

257 posts

231 months

Monday 21st June 2010
quotequote all
Great to read an owners experience of these rare beasts.

Thank you for sharing. Good read. clap

munch997

2,325 posts

218 months

Monday 21st June 2010
quotequote all
2 great cars, I certainly couldn't choose!
That gallardo in the last pic is also very nice, had the pleasure of hearing it in london! WOW...

RosCabezas

118 posts

284 months

Monday 21st June 2010
quotequote all
Thank you for sharing. It's a pleasure to read you trying to sound logical while you justify owning a carrera gt and an f50. XD

Enjoy them and share your feelings!!

Mike Rob

1,017 posts

222 months

Monday 21st June 2010
quotequote all
Hi Kevin - judging by the seat position in the CGT, your legs are as short as mine smile.

lambo_xx

2,199 posts

228 months

Monday 21st June 2010
quotequote all
Great read thanks for that! I love the Carrera GT, but I have to say I'd have the F50 any day!

Mike Rob

1,017 posts

222 months

Monday 21st June 2010
quotequote all
Great read thanks for that! I love the Carrera GT, but I have to say I'd have the CGT any day! smile

-DeaDLocK-

3,368 posts

282 months

Tuesday 22nd June 2010
quotequote all
456mgt said:
In the end, I came away with the view that you can justify keeping both.
Clutching at straws here, aren't you? hehe

Not Ideal

3,060 posts

219 months

Tuesday 22nd June 2010
quotequote all
Thanks for the write up and comparison - great to be involved in ownership of two awesome cars.

For me it has to be the F50.

On a really boring note - are they both the same amount of work to run and own..??

456mgt

Original Poster:

2,518 posts

297 months

Tuesday 22nd June 2010
quotequote all
Mike Rob said:
Hi Kevin - judging by the seat position in the CGT, your legs are as short as mine smile.
You're a funny bd Mike! I think we're both average height and I like to sit closer to the wheel than most. You know, I used to wish I was taller but that would rule out lots of interesting stuff. Nick Phelps, the guy who Ventureshielded the 50 and runs The Curvature Group is 6ft 4 or something and simply won't fit these cars. He was gutted.

-DeaDLocK- said:
456mgt said:
In the end, I came away with the view that you can justify keeping both.
Clutching at straws here, aren't you? hehe
Not wanting to sound like a dick, but I don't have to justify this stuff to anyone else, fortunately. But I don't like too much overlap between the cars because it means they don't get used and I'd be better off swapping it for something else a bit diffeent. You do have a point though smile

jon- said:
Here's a hard question, which do you think sounds better? The F1 inspired V12 in the F50, or the ultra high tech V10 in the CGT? They are quite literally the two best sounding cars in the world, what a dream garage!

PS, were you flying after an F40 last Monday on the M25 around 10pm?
With the present exhaust setups it's the F50 that sounds best and it's not even close. The GT may be F1-inspired but the 50 is F1-derived. In part, that's also because you can't hear the GT over the F50. And no, that wasn't me chasing an F40. Officer!

And thanks for all the comments; I'm just glad there's an outlet for this stuff.