Posting Rules are bias
Discussion
How comes as soon as you ask a serious question it gets removed, this forum is one of the major reasons for making the decisions I made in the past (in multiples of 10k). Maybe the moderators should also remove and delete all of the (let's say tuner) recommendation posts too then the forum would be left to discussions only and would not be bias to only good reports. Hopefully this will not get removed.
I dont think the questions you asked were serious in a forum environment as they were purely aimed at an individual company regarding issues between you and them.
Dont have a go at me im simply saying why they will have probably been removed.
Public forums arent the place to make such directed comments at a single individual/company.
Dont have a go at me im simply saying why they will have probably been removed.
Public forums arent the place to make such directed comments at a single individual/company.
If it's an honest post and his phone calls are not getting answered, can't see what else he can do apart from waste more money paying a visit. Don't see why we are allowed to post how well we think some tuners are yet when things go bad, we all have to keep quiet !!
May be if the OP had mentioned what has gone wrong and what has or has not happened, perhaps the thread may of stayed on ?
May be if the OP had mentioned what has gone wrong and what has or has not happened, perhaps the thread may of stayed on ?
From what I can see you're three posts where deemed to contravene the sites No Naming and Shaming policy.
You should have received mails informing you of that.
We operate a very strict N&S policy, Ted outlined some of the reasons here.
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...
HTH.
You should have received mails informing you of that.
We operate a very strict N&S policy, Ted outlined some of the reasons here.
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...
HTH.
spudmonkeybikes said:
How comes as soon as you ask a serious question it gets removed, this forum is one of the major reasons for making the decisions I made in the past (in multiples of 10k). Maybe the moderators should also remove and delete all of the (let's say tuner) recommendation posts too then the forum would be left to discussions only and would not be bias to only good reports. Hopefully this will not get removed.
I sympathise with you completely. Having dealt with a particular "specialist" back in 2006 whilst with another company (who are still trading) I swore never to let him near my cars again. All of us on here are willing to pay a little extra for quality work when it comes to our cars and I felt (or feel now since the shocking truth has been revealed) that my faith had certainly been misplaced.
I sold my GTS to a friend in 2009 and still see the car regularly. As far as I was concerned, the car was in superb order and had had all it's major work carried out by one particular company (which fortunately was all in 2006) and their so called best man. This was part of the reason I bought the car ( having researched the company etc and taking a lot of reviews from this forum!) and I was confident the new owner was getting a good car.
The new owner has since decided to do a few internal mods and I was disgusted to hear (and see) the state of the engine. Having been "rebuilt" by our, and I use the term in its loosest form "specialist" only 20,000 miles ago, I was disgusted to see the botch jobs and short cuts that had been taken. Mismatched bolts and fasteners, misaligned and siliconed intake, instant gasket EVERYWHERE, only the heads had proper gaskets fitted. The bearing shells not changed on the original rebuild, nor were the piston rings and a crushed engine loom under the block where he'd refitted it to name a few problems.
Disgraceful to say the least, I'm sure you'll agree. I've never been so embarrassed and have been fortunate enough that it hasn't affected my friendship with the new owner, though I have contributed financially to some of the rectification required.
I had the chance of another car from another and at the time, about the only other independent available. Had I known what I know now, I'd have bought that one every time. Not because the one I did buy was bad, I loved it and aside from a clutch and a few minor bits, it performed well but because in spite of its reliability, the shoddy work lurking underneath it could have led to a very expensive affair.
The bottom line is, if there were more HONEST posts regardless of perspective, I probably would have been able to form a more balanced opinion, rather than being left with the rose tinted stuff that led me astray. Hindsight is 20/20, I know but how do you avoid the cowboys and not get burned in a niche market like ours without being able to see what's really going on? If somebody isn't delivering what they promise, it should be made public. Mods and work of almost any kind aren't cheap these days and if a member was going to be spending £££ with a company, I would hope that any one of you on here would voice your honest opinion.
Rant over
Edited by woody vt on Thursday 24th June 09:24
I agree totally. If people are happy with work done to their car then they come on here giving praise to the company that carried out the work as i have many times when returning from Monkfish. Its quite simple, i ring Roger or Andy tell them what i want, they give me an agreed price and a date for work to be done. I drop the off, leave it in excellent hands and collect when arranged. Simples. I have never ever had a single complaint with them and know that if something wasn't to my liking they'd sort it for me.
The problem is that those that have had bad work done by whoever and good business code is not followed through could possibly be a little dubious about airing their views on here for fear of getting accused of slander.
Simply do a good job in the first place and there will be no bad press.
The problem is that those that have had bad work done by whoever and good business code is not followed through could possibly be a little dubious about airing their views on here for fear of getting accused of slander.
Simply do a good job in the first place and there will be no bad press.
I must add though that when a car fails to tickover and deteriorates as the summer ends and only returns 12 mph in 6th at 50mph on a run is a little more than an accusation. And when a test point on a fuel regulator is left undone and fills the boot and underbody with fuel is priceless.
I think the OP is right, if you dont want them turning into 10 page arguements maybe they should be locked quickly but left for people to view to make their own minds up, surely if a search on a company throws up 10 praise threads Vs 1 slag off thread people can discard that information, but to see no negative at all when really it could be 10 positive Vs 50 negative links to the reasoning 'there is no smoke without fire'. I wish id checked things out like this in the past i heard bad things about one modifier who later went on to steal my car, extreme but it happens.
P.s it was only a rover.
P.s it was only a rover.
crisisjez said:
The problem with an open forum is anyone could accuse anyone of anything if there were no safeguards in place.
This is a small enough community that its not necessary to name names anyway.
There are, they are called Courts of Law. This is a free country with Human rights attached. This is a small enough community that its not necessary to name names anyway.
Pistonheads needs to decide what they are about and if they have the interests of the enthusiast motoring public at heart.
Actually these threads demonstrate to me, quite clearly, that we can't take PH seriously and up to now they are just another business, who couldn't give a toss about who gets burnt by any rogue outfit that may need outing.
We have the laws of the land and don't need PH to get in between that process. If someone makes a false claim on here, by libling or defaming anyone, then that person should have recourse in the Courts of the Land. They should not need to be hidden behind PH's apron strings.
In the meantime, do what I do, and tell every interested party, about your personal experiences with trader X, Y, or Z. Just don't let the f
kers get away with poor service, false promises and shoddy workmanship any longer.Gassing Station | HSV & Monaro | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




