what would you do
Author
Discussion

B0LLIKS

Original Poster:

414 posts

200 months

Saturday 26th June 2010
quotequote all
ok, so a few days ago the mazda dealer phoned me to tell me that they need the cover note so they could tax a new car i am picking up, no probs said i, so before a phoned my insurance company i thought it best to check my bank account just to make sure i had enough money in to pay them as i never keep much more than everyday running costs cash in it. went online to check and....HOLY CRAP!!!!. now maths are not my best subject, but i cant be that far out i thought. went on the the statement page and seems my banks insurance side of things payed £2000.17p into my account. i knew i had never made a claim for anything, and they never owed me anything. would you have took the money and run. me well i contacted my bank who knew nothing about it, but next day i was £2000.17p down again, makes me think, what if i had said nothing.

5potTurbo

13,687 posts

198 months

Saturday 26th June 2010
quotequote all
They'd have realised and taken the money back even if your balance was lower at a later date.
"Keeping" it or spending it is theft, so you took the best action by alerting them. thumbup

Cas_P

1,497 posts

213 months

Saturday 26th June 2010
quotequote all
You phoned up to query having more money?! You make the effort to phone when you're missing money. When you have more you go shopping....

soad

34,719 posts

206 months

Saturday 26th June 2010
quotequote all
So that's £2k of spare funds then to play with?

I'd bought a MX5 (maybe, just maybe)...

Glassman

25,064 posts

245 months

Saturday 26th June 2010
quotequote all
Ignorance.

Bliss.

Killer2005

20,621 posts

258 months

Saturday 26th June 2010
quotequote all
In my new role at a bank I spend my days finding money that customers either should or shouldn't have, so I'd always ask my bank about an extra money I had redface

Heathwood

3,036 posts

232 months

Saturday 26th June 2010
quotequote all
This happened to a friend of mine (about £1,700 IIRC) and he asked me what I would do. I replied that I would do nothing. I wouldn't spend it, transfer it, report it, nothing. Still there in a year or two then, well, maybe....

He chose to ignore my advice and spent most of it on games consoles, laptop etc that very weekend. A few days later he had a call from his wife who had just done a months shopping but the card was declined. She checked the balance at an ATM to find they were about a grand overdrawn after the bank had swiped it back and left them with an unauthorsied overdraft. No food, no petrol, no money and 3 kids to feed. Plenty of games to play on the PS3 mind.

soad

34,719 posts

206 months

Saturday 26th June 2010
quotequote all
Heathwood said:
No food, no petrol, no money and 3 kids to feed. Plenty of games to play on the PS3 mind.
Not the best end then. Yeah, they tend to notice these things fairly quckly, then take funds back.

Nolar Dog

8,786 posts

225 months

Saturday 26th June 2010
quotequote all
Cas_P said:
You phoned up to query having more money?! You make the effort to phone when you're missing money. When you have more you go shopping....
nono Return it. It's not yours.

toxgobbler

2,903 posts

221 months

Saturday 26th June 2010
quotequote all
Nolar Dog said:
Cas_P said:
You phoned up to query having more money?! You make the effort to phone when you're missing money. When you have more you go shopping....
nono Return it. It's not yours.
+1

Silent1

19,762 posts

265 months

Saturday 26th June 2010
quotequote all
The bank will take it back, the money isn't yours and if you spend it and they then take it back you could be in a whole heap of trouble.

4hero

4,505 posts

241 months

J T

930 posts

212 months

Sunday 27th June 2010
quotequote all
The best option is to call the bank and tell them. It is not your money, you have done nothing to earn, win, or be entitled to it in any other way. If someone mistakenly sends a parcel to your house does that make it yours?

Don't think that the bank won't notice, because they will. This is someones money, someone should have 2000 pounds in their account, and they don't, so they will inform the bank. Leaving it there without telling the bank might not be against any law, but it could leave you open to temptation.

ShadownINja

80,144 posts

312 months

Sunday 27th June 2010
quotequote all
£500k? Withdraw it all in used £50 notes, one way ticket to Rio.

£2k? Let them know they made a mistake. Or put it all on black and say you thought you'd try to invest it like they did with our savings.

thumbup

Edited by ShadownINja on Sunday 27th June 00:52

Jammy2008

3,114 posts

219 months

Sunday 27th June 2010
quotequote all
Heathwood said:
This happened to a friend of mine (about £1,700 IIRC) and he asked me what I would do. I replied that I would do nothing. I wouldn't spend it, transfer it, report it, nothing. Still there in a year or two then, well, maybe....

He chose to ignore my advice and spent most of it on games consoles, laptop etc that very weekend. A few days later he had a call from his wife who had just done a months shopping but the card was declined. She checked the balance at an ATM to find they were about a grand overdrawn after the bank had swiped it back and left them with an unauthorsied overdraft. No food, no petrol, no money and 3 kids to feed. Plenty of games to play on the PS3 mind.
No offence to your mate but he's a fking idiot.

Edited by Jammy2008 on Sunday 27th June 01:07

ymwoods

2,194 posts

207 months

Sunday 27th June 2010
quotequote all
Jammy2008 said:
Heathwood said:
This happened to a friend of mine (about £1,700 IIRC) and he asked me what I would do. I replied that I would do nothing. I wouldn't spend it, transfer it, report it, nothing. Still there in a year or two then, well, maybe....

He chose to ignore my advice and spent most of it on games consoles, laptop etc that very weekend. A few days later he had a call from his wife who had just done a months shopping but the card was declined. She checked the balance at an ATM to find they were about a grand overdrawn after the bank had swiped it back and left them with an unauthorsied overdraft. No food, no petrol, no money and 3 kids to feed. Plenty of games to play on the PS3 mind.
No offence to your mate but he's a fking idiot.

Edited by Jammy2008 on Sunday 27th June 01:07
Yup, even more so for spending it in one whack too. The banks will have fraud prevention computers watching for things like this. If a bank account which ussually only has outgoings for petrol, groceries and a few bills suddenly starts going all big spender, it will flag up. At this point someone will look as to where you got all your cash from...whereby they will realise the mistake.

zollburgers

1,285 posts

213 months

Sunday 27th June 2010
quotequote all
What would I do? Pobably post about it on here I think.

B0LLIKS

Original Poster:

414 posts

200 months

Sunday 27th June 2010
quotequote all
i did phone the bank to tell them i had something that belonged to them, they took it back the next day so all was well again.

Famous Graham

26,553 posts

255 months

Sunday 27th June 2010
quotequote all
ShadownINja said:
£500k? Withdraw it all in used £50 notes, one way ticket to Rio.

£2k? Let them know they made a mistake. Or put it all on black and say you thought you'd try to invest it like they did with our savings.

thumbup

Edited by ShadownINja on Sunday 27th June 00:52
Damn right. If it were a life-changing amount, I'd be off like a shot.

But then my morals are somewhat...elastic.

Heathwood

3,036 posts

232 months

Sunday 27th June 2010
quotequote all
Jammy2008 said:
Heathwood said:
This happened to a friend of mine (about £1,700 IIRC) and he asked me what I would do. I replied that I would do nothing. I wouldn't spend it, transfer it, report it, nothing. Still there in a year or two then, well, maybe....

He chose to ignore my advice and spent most of it on games consoles, laptop etc that very weekend. A few days later he had a call from his wife who had just done a months shopping but the card was declined. She checked the balance at an ATM to find they were about a grand overdrawn after the bank had swiped it back and left them with an unauthorsied overdraft. No food, no petrol, no money and 3 kids to feed. Plenty of games to play on the PS3 mind.
No offence to your mate but he's a fking idiot.

Edited by Jammy2008 on Sunday 27th June 01:07
Yes he can be. He's one of those people that, given a choice to make, will always take the wrong road.