CAT delete
Author
Discussion

boggie

Original Poster:

393 posts

253 months

Tuesday 29th June 2010
quotequote all
Hi all,

What are the pros / cons of removing the catalytic convertor? Fortunately I have a friendly MOT man so I am not too woried about testing but what do I need to do? John - are yours available for ezxperimentation and/or possible sale?

Cheers,
B



Edited by Boggie on Sunday 12th June 14:43

mobile01

470 posts

238 months

Wednesday 30th June 2010
quotequote all
i been running without cats for past 3 years with no issues mate

Granby

2,473 posts

246 months

Wednesday 30th June 2010
quotequote all
No cons really, I had a scooby decatted for 6 years with no problems smile

Boggie

Original Poster:

393 posts

253 months

Wednesday 30th June 2010
quotequote all
Cheers both!

Anyone know if there is a CAT delete pipe readily available for the Monaro or will I have to get something made bespoke?

V88Dicky

7,373 posts

214 months

Wednesday 30th June 2010
quotequote all
You'll almost certainly have to get them made up mate. Shouldn't cost any more than a couple of hundred quid though.

MyM8V8

9,468 posts

226 months

Wednesday 30th June 2010
quotequote all
OP. Bit silly to post something like that on a public forum????!!!!

You'll have VOSA after you now.

Edited by MyM8V8 on Wednesday 30th June 13:42

Boggie

Original Poster:

393 posts

253 months

Wednesday 30th June 2010
quotequote all
MyM8V8 said:
What a ******* stupid thing to post on a public forum!!!!
Really? Why?

An annonymous poster, in unknown part of the country on a free to access, public forum, says he wants to remove a part of an unidentified car, 'saying' he has a 'friendly MOT man', again unidentified, who may or may not bend the rules with regards the removal of this part?

With all due respect: Do you think there is a goverment body set up to trawl the hundreds (even thousands) of car forums, looking for posts where a member suggests the law may be bent? They may then have to spend considerable time either fishing for identity information to try OR take out court orders against Piston Heads and the email provider the username's email is registered to so they can get a name and address. Visit the forum member with a warrant and try and force him (perhaps in court) to divulge the name of his friendly MOT tester, only to have it denied when they visit the MOT station? That would be a lot of trouble and expense over heresay on a public forum.

I don't see the problem, please explain why you do as I am always ready to admit when I am wrong.



Edited by Boggie on Wednesday 30th June 14:29

stigmundfreud

22,454 posts

241 months

Wednesday 30th June 2010
quotequote all
benefits? Absolutely none = no power increase at all. Downsides, well points make fines and prizes. I wouldnt bother. You will get no, absolutely no benefit at all but a raft of potential issues with road legality. Desptie what mates downt he pub will tell you all cars after 1993 that are supplied with a cat must be fitted with a cat at all times.

You might even lose out at the low end of the rev range too. In other words, save yoru money.

Having said that, if its an LS1 I have some bypass pipes you can have for 2 score

Granby

2,473 posts

246 months

Wednesday 30th June 2010
quotequote all
Boggie said:
MyM8V8 said:
What a ******* stupid thing to post on a public forum!!!!
Really? Why?

An annonymous poster, in unknown part of the country on a free to access, public forum, says he wants to remove a part of an unidentified car, 'saying' he has a 'friendly MOT man', again unidentified, who may or may not bend the rules with regards the removal of this part?

With all due respect: Do you think there is a goverment body set up to trawl the hundreds (even thousands) of car forums, looking for posts where a member suggests the law may be bent? They may then have to spend considerable time either fishing for identity information to try OR take out court orders against Piston Heads and the email provider the username's email is registered to so they can get a name and address. Visit the forum member with a warrant and try and force him (perhaps in court) to divulge the name of his friendly MOT tester, only to have it denied when they visit the MOT station? That would be a lot of trouble and expense over heresay on a public forum.

I don't see the problem, please explain why you do as I am always ready to admit when I am wrong.



Edited by Boggie on Wednesday 30th June 14:29
My thoughts exactly, on various scooby forums its the first mod recommended and talked about by hundreds of members (including tuners) yet i never heard of anyone being pulled up for it by seeing a post on the forum

MyM8V8

9,468 posts

226 months

Wednesday 30th June 2010
quotequote all
The problem here is that VOSA are having major roadside purges.

The more you post up stuff like this the more you are likely to have our cars targeted.

And don't for a moment think these sites are not monitored. When my car was nicked, CID had my password to gain access to the forum.

Read up on a section 59 too.

We are very lucky in this country that we have the freedom to carry out our own mods. In certain parts of Oz you can't have any mods, and in the States there are even checks on your PCM to ensure you have not messed with your tune to get thorugh a test.

Carry on like this and we will be catching up with them.

Boggie

Original Poster:

393 posts

253 months

Wednesday 30th June 2010
quotequote all
stigmundfreud said:
benefits? Absolutely none = no power increase at all. Downsides, well points make fines and prizes. I wouldnt bother. You will get no, absolutely no benefit at all but a raft of potential issues with road legality. Desptie what mates downt he pub will tell you all cars after 1993 that are supplied with a cat must be fitted with a cat at all times.

You might even lose out at the low end of the rev range too. In other words, save yoru money.

Having said that, if its an LS1 I have some bypass pipes you can have for 2 score
Agreed, in part. I know that sports cats flow more gas therefore and possibly with a suitable map there will be more power available but it will be only slight. Perhaps 10BHP or so. However, my problem may be that the cats need replacing (according to MF), possibly due to running a supercharger or the LPG the beastie breathes in. Either way and as I indeed do have an LS1, I would be very glad to take your bypass pipes until I can afford the sports cats. Where are you based?

Cheers,
B

the_ferret82

25,627 posts

215 months

Wednesday 30th June 2010
quotequote all
Boggie said:
stigmundfreud said:
benefits? Absolutely none = no power increase at all. Downsides, well points make fines and prizes. I wouldnt bother. You will get no, absolutely no benefit at all but a raft of potential issues with road legality. Desptie what mates downt he pub will tell you all cars after 1993 that are supplied with a cat must be fitted with a cat at all times.

You might even lose out at the low end of the rev range too. In other words, save yoru money.

Having said that, if its an LS1 I have some bypass pipes you can have for 2 score
Agreed, in part. I know that sports cats flow more gas therefore and possibly with a suitable map there will be more power available but it will be only slight. Perhaps 10BHP or so. However, my problem may be that the cats need replacing (according to MF), possibly due to running a supercharger or the LPG the beastie breathes in. Either way and as I indeed do have an LS1, I would be very glad to take your bypass pipes until I can afford the sports cats. Where are you based?

Cheers,
B
im sure you have a LS2 as you have an 05 CV8 wink

Boggie

Original Poster:

393 posts

253 months

Wednesday 30th June 2010
quotequote all
I had a feeling that the ID plate in the engine bay says LS1. Will check tonight.

Thanks

gsd2000

11,515 posts

214 months

Wednesday 30th June 2010
quotequote all
only later VXR monaros are LS2's, all other monaros are LS1's including the later CV8's

stigmundfreud

22,454 posts

241 months

Wednesday 30th June 2010
quotequote all
Gareth not sure at all why CID would have your password to this forum. Interesting to talk off line about that as its the field I work in so would like to hear more

Scoobies are always removing cats but despite their huge power potential its a chav mod carried out by barry boys.

I monitored the changes to volume efficiency between cats and no cats and it was 0. Absolutely 0 but then the cats were, it has to be said, high flow cats so over stock there may be some advantage but only with a remap.

If its a cv8, even an 05 with a small boot, its an LS1.

Granby

2,473 posts

246 months

Wednesday 30th June 2010
quotequote all
stigmundfreud said:
Scoobies are always removing cats but despite their huge power potential its a chav mod carried out by barry boys.
fpmsl, it makes a big different on scoobies (maybe because they are turbo engines the effect is greater), i don't think any of the major scooby tuners are classed as barry boys yet that is one of the first mods recommended, we all have our own opinions so will leave it at that smile

MyM8V8

9,468 posts

226 months

Wednesday 30th June 2010
quotequote all
stigmundfreud said:
Gareth not sure at all why CID would have your password to this forum. Interesting to talk off line about that as its the field I work in so would like to hear more

Scoobies are always removing cats but despite their huge power potential its a chav mod carried out by barry boys.

I monitored the changes to volume efficiency between cats and no cats and it was 0. Absolutely 0 but then the cats were, it has to be said, high flow cats so over stock there may be some advantage but only with a remap.

If its a cv8, even an 05 with a small boot, its an LS1.
Answer the dog & bone then.

S800VXR

5,877 posts

231 months

Wednesday 30th June 2010
quotequote all
stig, didnt you know of a shop that will take cats out for free so long as you have other work done? wink

Boosted LS1

21,200 posts

291 months

Wednesday 30th June 2010
quotequote all
As far as I'm aware a cat isn't a legal requirement so long as the car will pass the emmissions in force at the time it was manufactured. At worst if VOSA were even interested they's send you to a testing station but if you had a valid mot they'd probably not bother. How often do you see VOSA pulling over cars anyway and doing emissions checks?

MadMaxHSV

1,816 posts

229 months

Wednesday 30th June 2010
quotequote all
Boosted LS1 said:
As far as I'm aware a cat isn't a legal requirement so long as the car will pass the emmissions in force at the time it was manufactured. At worst if VOSA were even interested they's send you to a testing station but if you had a valid mot they'd probably not bother. How often do you see VOSA pulling over cars anyway and doing emissions checks?
Pretty sure the rule is that if your car was originally fitted with them, you have to have them for the MOT.
I know this was an issue with a mates VW Corrado when he changed the exhaust.