The Tank has to go.... so, time for a what car
The Tank has to go.... so, time for a what car
Author
Discussion

SWH

Original Poster:

1,261 posts

232 months

Thursday 1st July 2010
quotequote all
Our 850 T5 has pretty much passed the just run in stage and at 229K is heading for just run out. The options considered were to spend a bit and keep it going until it properly goes pop (current situation); to spend a load and make it mighty once again, but still only ever getting 28mpg; or in fact just bin it and face the fact I have to get something powered by the devil’s fuel....

The dead air con, full power misfire, and a lack of time/inclination to fix it lead me to a what car thread. Mrs SWH has the Saab, and although great on the commute, it’s hardly the height of economy; so here goes:

The commute:
24K miles per year (Eastbourne area to Canary Wharf, three times a week).

The car:
Maximum of £5K
Something approaching 50mpg, extra points if more
Capable of another 100K without falling apart at the seams (being realistic, some fixing and of course properly maintaining it is fine!)
Comfortable and reliable

I’ll consider pretty much anything, other than the train... over to you...

Gizmo!

18,150 posts

239 months

Thursday 1st July 2010
quotequote all
Traditional answer at this point must be a BMW E39 5-series, preferably diesel, 530d MSport for preference...

dan19evans

4,954 posts

197 months

Thursday 1st July 2010
quotequote all
Gizmo! said:
Traditional answer at this point must be a BMW E39 5-series, preferably diesel, 530d MSport for preference...
this smile

RobM77

35,349 posts

264 months

Thursday 1st July 2010
quotequote all
I can second the above suggestion, and add to that a V70 D5.

eltax91

10,764 posts

236 months

Thursday 1st July 2010
quotequote all
Octavia Estate TDi, All those taxi drivers cannot be wrong

SWH

Original Poster:

1,261 posts

232 months

Thursday 1st July 2010
quotequote all
eltax91 said:
Octavia Estate TDi, All those taxi drivers cannot be wrong
Yep, looked at one duffer so far, sadly this is more the MPG I'd be looking for; although a 530D is a strong contender...

Right, M25 time!

PeteG

4,278 posts

241 months

Thursday 1st July 2010
quotequote all
The Crack Fox said:
There's an 850R estate in black in our local paper, c.100k miles, FSH and only £1000 (!). Get that and spend the rest on petrol smile
yes

Do the sums and work out how much to spend on the car, leaving the rest for fuel. Proper fuel. PETROL.

Superhoop

4,913 posts

223 months

Thursday 1st July 2010
quotequote all
eltax91 said:
Octavia Estate TDi, All those taxi drivers cannot be wrong
Is that the same taxi drivers that are having such a big problem with dual mass flywheels failing that Skoda are now replacing them with a standard single mass item? (So I was told by a Skoda dealer the other day?)

martin mrt

3,883 posts

231 months

Thursday 1st July 2010
quotequote all
Gizmo! said:
Traditional answer at this point must be a BMW E39 5-series, preferably diesel, 530d MSport for preference...
this would be my choice, infact this is exactly what I'm looking for but trying to find a decent one below 5k isn't easy

H_Kan

4,942 posts

229 months

Thursday 1st July 2010
quotequote all
The derv e39's do have a number of faults you need to look out for.

In addition to this, the 530d is never going to return 50mpg in mixed driving.

SWH

Original Poster:

1,261 posts

232 months

Thursday 1st July 2010
quotequote all
PeteG said:
The Crack Fox said:
There's an 850R estate in black in our local paper, c.100k miles, FSH and only £1000 (!). Get that and spend the rest on petrol smile
yes

Do the sums and work out how much to spend on the car, leaving the rest for fuel. Proper fuel. PETROL.
Yep, that's what I'm currently doing with the T5 really.... it's going to end in something tedious I suspect, but that does encourage faster fixing of the GTV, so not all bad!

eltax91

10,764 posts

236 months

Friday 2nd July 2010
quotequote all
Superhoop said:
eltax91 said:
Octavia Estate TDi, All those taxi drivers cannot be wrong
Is that the same taxi drivers that are having such a big problem with dual mass flywheels failing that Skoda are now replacing them with a standard single mass item? (So I was told by a Skoda dealer the other day?)
Nope. not at this guys budget. I'm suggesting he go for a mk1 estate, traditional taxi spec. If he was at mk2 money I would jump into a mondeo over the Skoda for precisely the reason you mention. Although the Ford is not without its similar issues. Estate form in mk1 octavia hung around much longer than the saloon did so mk2 estates are newer and more cash.

Jasandjules

72,611 posts

259 months

Friday 2nd July 2010
quotequote all
I may sound a bit like a broken record, but a Passat Tdi 130. Comfy, plenty of gadgets (those heated rear view mirrors are handy in the rain!) and gets 50mpg on a run fairly easily.

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

220 months

Friday 2nd July 2010
quotequote all
SWH said:
Our 850 T5 has pretty much passed the just run in stage and at 229K is heading for just run out. The options considered were to spend a bit and keep it going until it properly goes pop (current situation); to spend a load and make it mighty once again, but still only ever getting 28mpg; or in fact just bin it and face the fact I have to get something powered by the devil’s fuel....

The dead air con, full power misfire, and a lack of time/inclination to fix it lead me to a what car thread. Mrs SWH has the Saab, and although great on the commute, it’s hardly the height of economy; so here goes:

The commute:
24K miles per year (Eastbourne area to Canary Wharf, three times a week).

The car:
Maximum of £5K
Something approaching 50mpg, extra points if more
Capable of another 100K without falling apart at the seams (being realistic, some fixing and of course properly maintaining it is fine!)
Comfortable and reliable

I’ll consider pretty much anything, other than the train... over to you...
These have to be great value for money IMO.

Genuine good car, good chassis, good drive, good handling. The engine is a BMW unit, and IMO the interior looks like a very nice place to sit. If you want more racey there's the MG alternative of course. But this Rover is a 50,000 mile 2004 car for peanuts!


http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/1418373.htm


http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/1825876.htm

That's a diesel Jag. But there are adds for LPG conversions for about £1500, so a 3.0 litre V6 might be an option too.





http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/1765253.htm

This ones already converted to run on LPG.


smile

SWH

Original Poster:

1,261 posts

232 months

Saturday 3rd July 2010
quotequote all
Thanks chaps, will see what I can find today.

X-Type - tempting, not considered one of these, I see a few high-ish milage estates in budget as well.
Rover 75 - Possible, checked out a tatty MG ZT and wasn't impressed, but that's just one car.
Passat - Yep, certainly a contender, as is an Octavia.

Will see what Autotrader (or my patience with the website) throws up in easy range this morning....

SWH

Original Poster:

1,261 posts

232 months

Friday 9th July 2010
quotequote all
Well, after looking round a couple more duffers and with a hint of garlic in the air... I've gone for a Laguna of all things, 2007 1.9 DCi (130bhp) with a grand total of 37K miles, appears to be well looked after, collecting it on Wednesday.




So... the T5 is heading for the classifieds and the money off vouchers from Shell should slow down a bit.

Think it really is time to repair the Alfa now(!)


gog440

9,298 posts

220 months

Friday 9th July 2010
quotequote all
SWH said:
Well, after looking round a couple more duffers and with a hint of garlic in the air... I've gone for a Laguna of all things, 2007 1.9 DCi (130bhp) with a grand total of 37K miles, appears to be well looked after, collecting it on Wednesday.




So... the T5 is heading for the classifieds and the money off vouchers from Shell should slow down a bit.

Think it really is time to repair the Alfa now(!)
given the choice I would have kept the t5

or bought almost anything else even a vecta

Renault really are st, the multiplex wiring is a disaster area (and my ex brother in law helped design it).
Colleague of mine had a y reg v6 with so many electrical faults that it is now sitting in a scrapyard as it was uneconomical to repair, (after she had spent a 4 figure sum trying to fix it all)

nsmith1180

3,941 posts

208 months

Friday 9th July 2010
quotequote all
Off the wall suggestion.

Signum 1.9 CDTi 150. You would get a decent Elite for that.

All of em came with Navi and leather on the Elite. 5K should see you a facelift version with relitivly low miles.

Get one which has had the EGR Valve done because they are known to clog. Dont press the button when applying the handbrake, do it as per the owners manual!

On the plus side. A great spec, bit different, 2yrs/20k service intervals and Eleventy Bazillion indies which specialise in Vauxhall in your area.