Discussion
Hi All
I have recently started looking at R8's as a second car proposition. It seems to me that the R8 V8 prices are in a "bubble" at the moment....does anyone share that view?
The reason I say this is:
I can pick up a May 2009 V10 for £89995 (no negotiation) with 5k miles and it has the usual V10 higher specification than the V8 on which everything is a cost option. 3 year old V8 are now priced at around 62-65k with a decent spec. If we are kind to the V10, by the time it is 2 years old it will probably be around £75-77k and by the time it is 3 years old with 15 k miles I would estimate it would be in the high 60's. Therefore comparing like for like I feel the V8's are overpriced. The effect of the V10 depreciation won't necessarily be felt right now, but I seriously do think that if I did buy a V8 now at 62k, when I trade in next year the value will be under 50k (not private sale, but trade. Calculating value and seeing patterns is kind of what I do for a living so I can't help it. I am not shy about losing money on cars, but when I see a situation like this it would seem naive to ignore it.
Is anyone else looking to buy and see this the same way I do? I think if I could get into a V8 around 56-57k then I would consider it, otherwise the risk to the downside is just too high - I mean who would have a V8 when the V10 is a much better car and in like for like comparison much better value once it has moved a little further down the depreciation curve?
Thanks in advance for your thoughts on this
I have recently started looking at R8's as a second car proposition. It seems to me that the R8 V8 prices are in a "bubble" at the moment....does anyone share that view?
The reason I say this is:
I can pick up a May 2009 V10 for £89995 (no negotiation) with 5k miles and it has the usual V10 higher specification than the V8 on which everything is a cost option. 3 year old V8 are now priced at around 62-65k with a decent spec. If we are kind to the V10, by the time it is 2 years old it will probably be around £75-77k and by the time it is 3 years old with 15 k miles I would estimate it would be in the high 60's. Therefore comparing like for like I feel the V8's are overpriced. The effect of the V10 depreciation won't necessarily be felt right now, but I seriously do think that if I did buy a V8 now at 62k, when I trade in next year the value will be under 50k (not private sale, but trade. Calculating value and seeing patterns is kind of what I do for a living so I can't help it. I am not shy about losing money on cars, but when I see a situation like this it would seem naive to ignore it.
Is anyone else looking to buy and see this the same way I do? I think if I could get into a V8 around 56-57k then I would consider it, otherwise the risk to the downside is just too high - I mean who would have a V8 when the V10 is a much better car and in like for like comparison much better value once it has moved a little further down the depreciation curve?
Thanks in advance for your thoughts on this

arfur daley said:
there is a white r8 needing slight remedial work on the bonnet for sale, as the driver has had enough of people on the right side of the road.
I like white - how much would that be to buy if we assume I remedy the slight damage?I guess you don't agree and I could well be wrong in my theory - but I think it would be useful to know why you don't agree if that is what your amusing comment meant?
(I should probably add that I don't have a problem with spending 100k on the right car from a value point of view so let us assume budget is not an issue here.)
Prices are holding up very well I agree. Some people prefer the V8 (supposedly more nimble) so that may have something to do with it... they sound bloody gorgeous too.
I bought mine over a year ago and sold it a couple of weeks back. With 15K miles on the clock and 27 months old I still got £61K from a dealer who wanted it. Demand is high as you do not see many about.
I bought mine over a year ago and sold it a couple of weeks back. With 15K miles on the clock and 27 months old I still got £61K from a dealer who wanted it. Demand is high as you do not see many about.
christer said:
arfur daley said:
there is a white r8 needing slight remedial work on the bonnet for sale, as the driver has had enough of people on the right side of the road.
I like white - how much would that be to buy if we assume I remedy the slight damage?I guess you don't agree and I could well be wrong in my theory - but I think it would be useful to know why you don't agree if that is what your amusing comment meant?
(I should probably add that I don't have a problem with spending 100k on the right car from a value point of view so let us assume budget is not an issue here.)
White R8 "Red Bull Paint"
After having spoken to an Audi dealer today he would be inclined to agree with my view - he admitted they had paid a bit too much for the car they have and are looking to do a deal, but not good enough for me to take on that level of risk unfortunately. It looks like a V10 in 18 months may be on the cards, so perhaps a Gallardo could be doable now althought good ones are far and few between atm imho.
I'm in the same situation, I've been looking for an R8 for a while and have come to the same opinion as you. I think its because the R8 is comparitively cheap to run for that type of car. Servicing is not excessive and nor are parts, unlike a Gallardo or Ferrari. Even the fuel economy is not bad for that type of car!
christer said:
After having spoken to an Audi dealer today he would be inclined to agree with my view - he admitted they had paid a bit too much for the car they have and are looking to do a deal, but not good enough for me to take on that level of risk unfortunately. It looks like a V10 in 18 months may be on the cards, so perhaps a Gallardo could be doable now althought good ones are far and few between atm imho.
Why not get a V8? Why do you have to have a V10?garyhun said:
christer said:
After having spoken to an Audi dealer today he would be inclined to agree with my view - he admitted they had paid a bit too much for the car they have and are looking to do a deal, but not good enough for me to take on that level of risk unfortunately. It looks like a V10 in 18 months may be on the cards, so perhaps a Gallardo could be doable now althought good ones are far and few between atm imho.
Why not get a V8? Why do you have to have a V10?
christer said:
garyhun said:
christer said:
After having spoken to an Audi dealer today he would be inclined to agree with my view - he admitted they had paid a bit too much for the car they have and are looking to do a deal, but not good enough for me to take on that level of risk unfortunately. It looks like a V10 in 18 months may be on the cards, so perhaps a Gallardo could be doable now althought good ones are far and few between atm imho.
Why not get a V8? Why do you have to have a V10?
I am looking at R8s currently. I am slightly concerned because they do not seem to have depreciated much in the past year. They have been around £60k for a while now. I have come across one at nearly 40k miles which doe not seem to be selling due to its mileage. It is up for £57K ish.
I think that the depreciating V10s will push the price of the V8 down over the next year, but then I think that they are not significantly different and so the price between the two models will be more similar than I think you are predicting. I also predict that the V10 will depreciate less than you are guestimating.
I think that the depreciating V10s will push the price of the V8 down over the next year, but then I think that they are not significantly different and so the price between the two models will be more similar than I think you are predicting. I also predict that the V10 will depreciate less than you are guestimating.
minerva said:
but then I think that they are not significantly different and so the price between the two models will be more similar than I think you are predicting. I also predict that the V10 will depreciate less than you are guestimating.
HiWell, we don't need to argue about 100hp here or there or the difference in power delivery or sound. I say there is a substantiual difference, you disagree. They look almost identical though - perhaps you are referring to that?
In terms of depreciation, the V10 has dumped at least 20 k in 13 months and 5k miles - what are your predictions in terms of future values? Do you think the V8 will hold the values up?
Edited by christer on Monday 5th July 22:47
Sorry yes, I meant that they look very similar. I think that the R8 V8 moved the goalposts significantly. I think that the R8 V10 was, although very good, not quite such a ground breaker because it looked so similar. I really think that that will count against it. People will look at the difference in price and be hard pushed to justify the extra expense, hence the reason to go for the V8... but then for just a little more, I could get the TEN cylinder version!.... So, I conclude that I think that although R8 V8 prices seem to have hovered around the £60 000 mark for a year now and I think that they will drop a bit this year, I believe that they will remain higher than say, the same age Carrera because they are much lower volume. The R8 V10, I can see being closer to the V8 in second hand price, but the overall value of the both being bouyed by the rarity and looks.
minerva said:
One more thing, what are the desirable options I should be looking for on an R8?
"light package" for instance. Is it worth it? Do they all come with satnav/bluetooth?
Nope! Light pack is nice but not really desirable."light package" for instance. Is it worth it? Do they all come with satnav/bluetooth?
Must haves = Mag Ride, Parking Aid (preferably with camera), B&O Sound, Probably Sat Nav
Nice to have = Full Leather (Top of dash mainly - although a must for me), Lighting Pack.
Just to give you an idea of a big spec, mine had all these and I'd have all of them again (all of these are cost options - this is one other difference of V10, more stuff stadard):
DVD Sat Nav
Electric front seats
Heated Front Seats
Audi Magnetic Ride
Auto Dimming Folding door Mirrors
6 CD Changer
Audi Parking System Advanced
Bang & Olufsen Sound System
Cruise Control
Storage Pack
Tyre Pressure Monitors
Lighting Pack
Fine Nappa Leather Pack 3
Pedals and footrest in stainless steel
Blue Tooth
Edited by anonymous-user on Tuesday 6th July 21:46
Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



