S8 for a London family?
Discussion
Hi I live in London and have a 6 year old X5 since new which I am thinking or replacing. There is absolutely no point in buying new considering I only do 4-6.000 miles per year, therefore looking to spend £30k on a replacement.
How would you guys rate the long term reliability of the car and the overall enjoyment, remember that I would be using it in and around London for my wife, 1-2 very small children (the 2nd hopefully soon!!!), and want something sporty, elegant, fully optioned on creature comforts BUT reliable.
Other cars being considered a new X5 and Q7, clearly not sporty but more family oriented with higher driving position and better for my wife's weak back when loading / unloading children.
Thanks
JAG
How would you guys rate the long term reliability of the car and the overall enjoyment, remember that I would be using it in and around London for my wife, 1-2 very small children (the 2nd hopefully soon!!!), and want something sporty, elegant, fully optioned on creature comforts BUT reliable.
Other cars being considered a new X5 and Q7, clearly not sporty but more family oriented with higher driving position and better for my wife's weak back when loading / unloading children.
Thanks
JAG
Suitability for London? First of all they're absolutely massive! Parking and maounvering can be a bit of a nightmare even with the cleverest of clever parking sensors.
Fuel economy will be in single figures in traffic, low teens when moving.
Wheels and tyres are very easily damaged in confined spaces.
Reliability wise however they're fine - have had no real complaints from customers past isolated and minor niggles. Had a few through with 50-60k on that didn't anything need more than brakes and tyres.
I don't know of any of our customers that use them in town every day but I do have one customer who uses a V10 S6 as his sole transport in the middle of London. He part exchanged a Prius of all things as his annual mileage was so low he wanted to do it in something a bit more fun.
Fuel economy will be in single figures in traffic, low teens when moving.
Wheels and tyres are very easily damaged in confined spaces.
Reliability wise however they're fine - have had no real complaints from customers past isolated and minor niggles. Had a few through with 50-60k on that didn't anything need more than brakes and tyres.
I don't know of any of our customers that use them in town every day but I do have one customer who uses a V10 S6 as his sole transport in the middle of London. He part exchanged a Prius of all things as his annual mileage was so low he wanted to do it in something a bit more fun.
For what it's worth, I drive a 4.2V8 (petrol) and live in central London, so although it's a litre and 2 cylinders down, maybe I can offer some insight...
Comfort wise, it's fantastic, no complaints there.
20" wheels are slightly crashy on some of the capital's roads, and the suspension doesn't absorb speed bumps as well as the S Class or 7 series. They are also very easy to kerb, particularly if you're not used to the size of the car.
I don't find the size of the car that bad, and I only have on street parking. You're coming from something pretty big anyway (I had another A8 before this one), so I'm sure you'll be fine.
Auto box (I'm assuming relatively similar) is great in town, I put mine in 3rd gear and waft around getting around 11mpg in zone 1. I too, do about 5k miles a year.
Reliability wise, it's been absolutely fine, save for a water pump or thermostat, not sure which it was from memory. Mine's got 60k on the clock, and has only ever needed standard maintenance other than that. I guess the usual applies for a big powerful car, you can end up spending money on brakes and tyres if you have a heavy right foot.
Comfort wise, it's fantastic, no complaints there.
20" wheels are slightly crashy on some of the capital's roads, and the suspension doesn't absorb speed bumps as well as the S Class or 7 series. They are also very easy to kerb, particularly if you're not used to the size of the car.
I don't find the size of the car that bad, and I only have on street parking. You're coming from something pretty big anyway (I had another A8 before this one), so I'm sure you'll be fine.
Auto box (I'm assuming relatively similar) is great in town, I put mine in 3rd gear and waft around getting around 11mpg in zone 1. I too, do about 5k miles a year.
Reliability wise, it's been absolutely fine, save for a water pump or thermostat, not sure which it was from memory. Mine's got 60k on the clock, and has only ever needed standard maintenance other than that. I guess the usual applies for a big powerful car, you can end up spending money on brakes and tyres if you have a heavy right foot.
AKA8 said:
For what it's worth, I drive a 4.2V8 (petrol) and live in central London, so although it's a litre and 2 cylinders down, maybe I can offer some insight...
Comfort wise, it's fantastic, no complaints there.
20" wheels are slightly crashy on some of the capital's roads, and the suspension doesn't absorb speed bumps as well as the S Class or 7 series. They are also very easy to kerb, particularly if you're not used to the size of the car.
I don't find the size of the car that bad, and I only have on street parking. You're coming from something pretty big anyway (I had another A8 before this one), so I'm sure you'll be fine.
Auto box (I'm assuming relatively similar) is great in town, I put mine in 3rd gear and waft around getting around 11mpg in zone 1. I too, do about 5k miles a year.
Reliability wise, it's been absolutely fine, save for a water pump or thermostat, not sure which it was from memory. Mine's got 60k on the clock, and has only ever needed standard maintenance other than that. I guess the usual applies for a big powerful car, you can end up spending money on brakes and tyres if you have a heavy right foot.
This. Comfort wise, it's fantastic, no complaints there.
20" wheels are slightly crashy on some of the capital's roads, and the suspension doesn't absorb speed bumps as well as the S Class or 7 series. They are also very easy to kerb, particularly if you're not used to the size of the car.
I don't find the size of the car that bad, and I only have on street parking. You're coming from something pretty big anyway (I had another A8 before this one), so I'm sure you'll be fine.
Auto box (I'm assuming relatively similar) is great in town, I put mine in 3rd gear and waft around getting around 11mpg in zone 1. I too, do about 5k miles a year.
Reliability wise, it's been absolutely fine, save for a water pump or thermostat, not sure which it was from memory. Mine's got 60k on the clock, and has only ever needed standard maintenance other than that. I guess the usual applies for a big powerful car, you can end up spending money on brakes and tyres if you have a heavy right foot.
I'm also in the 4.2 A8 in London boat. Petrol costs are tiresome, but if your mileage is low the absolute cost is isn't bad. Very reliable car. I've collected a few scuffs on the bumpers, partly courtesy of Mrs. 66, and partly through other drivers' inability to park. TBH, I think if you drive and park in London, you might as well resign yourself to scuffs.
The D3 S8 is, IMO, a genuine "I want" car. Completely off most people's radar, but great. Mine 4.2 munches m-ways and autoroutes like pac-man.
Do it.
Many thanks for all the answers and feedback. I just want to point out that yes, when living in London you do not need a large car, but both my wife and I enjoy a "rapid" mode of transportation when do we get out of London or do longer journeys.
The jeep class cars are all nice, but consumption on my X5 really shocked me, and that is coming from a 911 previously. I am also aware that suspension on my Sport packed equipped X5 is pathetic.
Realistically I am looking for a 4 door saloon that will stand the test of time and "feel" good, as well as look noble. I have an XFR in Greece which I love, incidentally it feels quite front heavy but then again in that country I can drive the pants off it. The M5 is a technological marvel and a possibility, the Quattroporte would not be reliable at £30-40K (guessing), not interested in an AMG.
Finally scratches are part and parcel of London life one way or another.
The jeep class cars are all nice, but consumption on my X5 really shocked me, and that is coming from a 911 previously. I am also aware that suspension on my Sport packed equipped X5 is pathetic.
Realistically I am looking for a 4 door saloon that will stand the test of time and "feel" good, as well as look noble. I have an XFR in Greece which I love, incidentally it feels quite front heavy but then again in that country I can drive the pants off it. The M5 is a technological marvel and a possibility, the Quattroporte would not be reliable at £30-40K (guessing), not interested in an AMG.
Finally scratches are part and parcel of London life one way or another.
I'm sure an S8 will suit you very well, and there's some good ones for around £30k (I've been watching prices for a while and am also tempted).
All the other cars you've mentioned are great, but once you've had something with reasonable amounts of power and 4wd, it will be very difficult to go back. Braking distances aside, the quattro is fantastic for UK conditions - I seem to end up driving on rainy Friday nights and the stability from the quattro is outstanding. It's put me off BMW's and AMG Mercedes. The BMW's are just oo edgy at the wrong times and from my experience, the AMG spends far too much time with the traction control light flashing away.
Scuffs are just an unfortunate inevitability if you live in central London. Unfortunately, I've become a bit of a snob about who I park next to, and it's worked to date. I also park my car on the right hand side of the street whenever possible, because I think drivers are more likely to hit you with their nearside rather than offside.
Lastly, size doesn't matter, it's all relative and once you're used to it, you can fit into some pretty tight spaces (phnar phnar)
All the other cars you've mentioned are great, but once you've had something with reasonable amounts of power and 4wd, it will be very difficult to go back. Braking distances aside, the quattro is fantastic for UK conditions - I seem to end up driving on rainy Friday nights and the stability from the quattro is outstanding. It's put me off BMW's and AMG Mercedes. The BMW's are just oo edgy at the wrong times and from my experience, the AMG spends far too much time with the traction control light flashing away.
Scuffs are just an unfortunate inevitability if you live in central London. Unfortunately, I've become a bit of a snob about who I park next to, and it's worked to date. I also park my car on the right hand side of the street whenever possible, because I think drivers are more likely to hit you with their nearside rather than offside.
Lastly, size doesn't matter, it's all relative and once you're used to it, you can fit into some pretty tight spaces (phnar phnar)
Is there a reason why you want an S8 specifically? Would an A8 with the petrol or diesel V8, or maybe even the 6.0 W12 suit you? Might be a bit cheaper. Alternatively, why not look at the S6? It has the same 5.2 V10 (albeit running 430 BHP instead of 450 BHP), and isn't a whole lot smaller, but it's a good deal cheaper.
Edited by Witchfinder on Tuesday 13th July 12:36
Thanks for all the info.
I want an S8 vs. an S6 because it looks better in and out, it also has more space which is always good. Parking wise living in Chelsea with an X5 we are used to large cars (and so are most people around here!), so that is ok.
As for other iterations of the A8, well I have a British racing licence and I always like something with poke, it also happens that these cars are usually fully optioned and depreciate like a bomb so make good bargains.
Can anyone tell me whether there is a big difference between the facelifted models aside from the SatNav?
Sincerely,
JAG
I want an S8 vs. an S6 because it looks better in and out, it also has more space which is always good. Parking wise living in Chelsea with an X5 we are used to large cars (and so are most people around here!), so that is ok.
As for other iterations of the A8, well I have a British racing licence and I always like something with poke, it also happens that these cars are usually fully optioned and depreciate like a bomb so make good bargains.
Can anyone tell me whether there is a big difference between the facelifted models aside from the SatNav?
Sincerely,
JAG
johnag007 said:
As for other iterations of the A8, well I have a British racing licence and I always like something with poke, it also happens that these cars are usually fully optioned and depreciate like a bomb so make good bargains.
The 6.0 W12 is as quick as the S8, albeit without the sports suspension setup that the S8 has. But in London, how often are you likely to need that? Anyway, just a suggestion.I have to say no one needs a large engine in London or really most places.
I like the looks though, the options that usually come with the S8, the seats, the noise and the power (preference for peak rather than torque), it should give you an indication that I have my Racing Licence (not that this is the car to go racing with but still).
I like the looks though, the options that usually come with the S8, the seats, the noise and the power (preference for peak rather than torque), it should give you an indication that I have my Racing Licence (not that this is the car to go racing with but still).
johnag007 said:
I have to say no one needs a large engine in London or really most places.
I like the looks though, the options that usually come with the S8, the seats, the noise and the power (preference for peak rather than torque), it should give you an indication that I have my Racing Licence (not that this is the car to go racing with but still).
And? A race licence? What the fI like the looks though, the options that usually come with the S8, the seats, the noise and the power (preference for peak rather than torque), it should give you an indication that I have my Racing Licence (not that this is the car to go racing with but still).
k has got to do with a road barge?!PIGINAWIG said:
johnag007 said:
I have to say no one needs a large engine in London or really most places.
I like the looks though, the options that usually come with the S8, the seats, the noise and the power (preference for peak rather than torque), it should give you an indication that I have my Racing Licence (not that this is the car to go racing with but still).
And? A race licence? What the fI like the looks though, the options that usually come with the S8, the seats, the noise and the power (preference for peak rather than torque), it should give you an indication that I have my Racing Licence (not that this is the car to go racing with but still).
k has got to do with a road barge?!bga said:
PIGINAWIG said:
johnag007 said:
I have to say no one needs a large engine in London or really most places.
I like the looks though, the options that usually come with the S8, the seats, the noise and the power (preference for peak rather than torque), it should give you an indication that I have my Racing Licence (not that this is the car to go racing with but still).
And? A race licence? What the fI like the looks though, the options that usually come with the S8, the seats, the noise and the power (preference for peak rather than torque), it should give you an indication that I have my Racing Licence (not that this is the car to go racing with but still).
k has got to do with a road barge?!
t thought he'd 'mention' he had a race licence just because he has one. Big deal.PIGINAWIG said:
bga said:
PIGINAWIG said:
johnag007 said:
I have to say no one needs a large engine in London or really most places.
I like the looks though, the options that usually come with the S8, the seats, the noise and the power (preference for peak rather than torque), it should give you an indication that I have my Racing Licence (not that this is the car to go racing with but still).
And? A race licence? What the fI like the looks though, the options that usually come with the S8, the seats, the noise and the power (preference for peak rather than torque), it should give you an indication that I have my Racing Licence (not that this is the car to go racing with but still).
k has got to do with a road barge?!
t thought he'd 'mention' he had a race licence just because he has one. Big deal.
t than the OP is. PIGINAWIG said:
bga said:
PIGINAWIG said:
johnag007 said:
I have to say no one needs a large engine in London or really most places.
I like the looks though, the options that usually come with the S8, the seats, the noise and the power (preference for peak rather than torque), it should give you an indication that I have my Racing Licence (not that this is the car to go racing with but still).
And? A race licence? What the fI like the looks though, the options that usually come with the S8, the seats, the noise and the power (preference for peak rather than torque), it should give you an indication that I have my Racing Licence (not that this is the car to go racing with but still).
k has got to do with a road barge?!
t thought he'd 'mention' he had a race licence just because he has one. Big deal.Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


