New Tusc or used F355?
New Tusc or used F355?
Author
Discussion

Waveboy14

Original Poster:

276 posts

259 months

Tuesday 16th March 2004
quotequote all
What car would you pick. Was thinking of posting this on the Ferrari forum as well, but guess there are less biased views in this forum.

rico

7,917 posts

270 months

Tuesday 16th March 2004
quotequote all
One less biased view:

355!!!!!

rico

7,917 posts

270 months

Tuesday 16th March 2004
quotequote all
Ok ok...

Tuscan and 355 won't be thaaaat much difference in service/insurance/blah costs

Both will depreciate, but the 355 is very much mileage based.

Speed6 engine is fine now so not much in them reliability wise.

I'd personally go for the 355 as its a bit rarer, sounds better, but i think the Tuscan looks better and is faster.

Close call!

TUS 373

4,944 posts

296 months

Tuesday 16th March 2004
quotequote all
OK - I looked into this. Speedsix has had issues but is sorted now as already said. 355, cam belt change is an engine out job - costs £000s (£3-5K depending whether Fez franchise or independent). I therefore think that deeper pockets will be required for the Ferrari - plus it costs more to buy in the first place.

flasher

9,241 posts

299 months

Tuesday 16th March 2004
quotequote all
No comparison. 355 every time. Youll get your money back too as opposed to losing a fortune on the TVR.

Sad but true.

apache

39,731 posts

299 months

Tuesday 16th March 2004
quotequote all
Assuming the S6 gremlins are history, at what stage would the fezzers running costs catch up with the tuscs depreciation?

basil brush

5,352 posts

278 months

Tuesday 16th March 2004
quotequote all
Why a new Tuscan? Get one that somebody else has suffered the 1st year's depreciation on.

Graham66

850 posts

299 months

Tuesday 16th March 2004
quotequote all
I would go for the 355.....well, I already have a Tuscan so another one would be wasted

jigs

1,840 posts

265 months

Tuesday 16th March 2004
quotequote all
Believe it or not I have to agree with Flasher and Graham66 this time - the 355 is already a rock solid classic - if you can keep the mileage down and look after it the longterm value is assured.

456mgt

2,511 posts

281 months

Tuesday 16th March 2004
quotequote all
TUS 373 said:
OK - I looked into this. Speedsix has had issues but is sorted now as already said. 355, cam belt change is an engine out job - costs £000s (£3-5K depending whether Fez franchise or independent). I therefore think that deeper pockets will be required for the Ferrari - plus it costs more to buy in the first place.
www.verdiferrari.biz/servicing.htm

TUS 373

4,944 posts

296 months

Tuesday 16th March 2004
quotequote all
456mgt said:

TUS 373 said:
OK - I looked into this. Speedsix has had issues but is sorted now as already said. 355, cam belt change is an engine out job - costs £000s (£3-5K depending whether Fez franchise or independent). I therefore think that deeper pockets will be required for the Ferrari - plus it costs more to buy in the first place.

www.verdiferrari.biz/servicing.htm


OK, I stand corrected £1800. When I was looking at them, I was told £3K by an independent - so I didn't buy one. Also, I could not get an insurance quote below <£2K on a Fez, the Tuscan came in at 1/3 of the money. I expect if I had tried harder, I could have found cheaper - but I gave up!

joospeed

4,473 posts

293 months

Tuesday 16th March 2004
quotequote all
Much as we love TVRs on this site, I have to say that if it was a choice of TVR v Ferrari, the red stallion has to win every time .. just to say you've owned one is reason enough.
Oh... to have the choice

GI Jnr

1,903 posts

276 months

Tuesday 16th March 2004
quotequote all
I'm lucky enough to be running both cars presently.

Difficult choice to have (good one though! ). I personally would ask myself "used Tuscan or F355" and the arguement towards the TVR are more compelling.

For at least £10k less than a good F355, you can get a mint year old Tusc.

For all out grunt the TVR wipes the floor with the F355, I got in the Fezza after a drive in the Tusc on Sunday and it honestly felt slow.

But you only have to shut the door on the Fcar and you know where the extra £ had gone. A solid sound for a solidly built car. It's the "whole package" I'm slowly growing to the Stallion...

Try them both, new Tusc: lose too much £, Fezza more £ but kudos from all. Used Tusc, kudos from Petrolheads and you save a package.

Keep us updated. Drop me a line if you fancy a chat.
Tuan

oxbow

567 posts

265 months

Tuesday 16th March 2004
quotequote all
Had both, Still got TUSC. Need I say more?

andyvdg

1,537 posts

298 months

Tuesday 16th March 2004
quotequote all
I guess this isn't a serious question. If it was for an everyday car - Tuscan easily. Fun thing at the weekend to show off to certain types of people in pubs - 355.

You've got to be able to live with the Rarri image as well.

Waveboy14

Original Poster:

276 posts

259 months

Tuesday 16th March 2004
quotequote all
I'm not in the market for such a decision just yet, but if it would arise, it would be a new Tuscan(S) vs F355 because I want a left handy (not much around). (993 Turbo S also crossed my mind, but is in a different league, more common, ...)

mcspreader

328 posts

276 months

Tuesday 16th March 2004
quotequote all
Don't forget the hidden costs. My tusc was scraped by a hit and scarper scumbag. The GRP is very resilient to minor knocks. Just a £250 respray of a wing. New finish better than TVR's. I suspect the same impact to a 355 would have damaged metal leading to an expensive new wing and paint. Got to be way over a grand.

pbrettle

3,280 posts

298 months

Wednesday 17th March 2004
quotequote all
Fixed price servicing for a Fezza is now a reality and it does bring costs down to a more manageable level. HOWEVER, this is assuming NOTHING goes wrong with the car. Parts are notoriously expensive and labour to fix them, although cheaper than you might expect, just takes time..... your service might be £1800 but the other remedial work needed will often bring a service into the £3K bracket. If you can afford it then great, but I am afraid that a TVR will be much more manageable cost than a 355....

Warranties and deals can be done on both, but seeing as there are some seriously good experts on the SP6 engine, I would be much more happy going this route rather than a 355.

As for loosing a packet on a TVR - dont quite agree. Sports cars of this size and type (i.e. two seater and very fast) appeal to a small market and hence need to be in perfect condition with the ideal mileage and the right colour / spec. Otherwise you will pay the price. A Ferrari is even more susceptible to mileage and demand and do be warned that demand is VERY fickle - a 348 is regarded as cheap these days (ok, I know its not the best one), but they go for less than a 328 WTF?!?!?! A 355 will very quickly plumet in depreciation once cheaper 360's come on the market.

Buy a 355 and keep an eye on the market and you will be fine, but miss the boat and you will loose a packet. To a certain degree its the same with a TVR, but less so - get a Tuscan for £44K and sell later for £30K and loose £14k or get a 355 for £50k (get a good 'un) and sell later for £35k - there is little in it....

Plotloss

67,280 posts

285 months

Wednesday 17th March 2004
quotequote all
New Tuscan.

Spec it down to the n th level and its your car, there probably wont be another like it on earth if you specify everything.

The Tuscan will never ever look dated whereas the Fezza is right on the edge of that now.

tiny

415 posts

266 months

Wednesday 17th March 2004
quotequote all
love my Griff but my 355 was the only car I have ever regretted selling - the combination of its looks, performance,noise and sheer character were to me unique.