Diesel Golf Engine Sizes
Author
Discussion

Lordbenny

Original Poster:

8,754 posts

250 months

Thursday 15th July 2010
quotequote all
I want to purchase a diesel powered Golf but need to know what engine sizes are available, which is the best all round engine considering power, economy, road tax bracket etc. We're chopping in our Tdi 130 Passat Estate which we love, its powerful, torquey and roomy. What golf would you recommend for around £5000 to £7000?

fatboy b

9,666 posts

247 months

Thursday 15th July 2010
quotequote all
Have you condsidered a Seat Leon. You get more for your money with the same engine choice & mechanicals.

In any case, they're 1.9 & 2.0. 1.9's about 100 bhp. The 2.0 is 140 or 170.

TDIfurby

1,997 posts

206 months

Thursday 15th July 2010
quotequote all
I think there could be a Greenline new Golf with the 1.4 TDI engine in it, but don't quote me on that.

As above really you have the 105bhp 1.9 PD and the 2.0 TDI common rail (PD engine pre 2009ish) engine in 140bhp and 170bhp forms. Dad has the 170CR engine in his '59 Audi TT and it is good. Just a shame that the lardy Audi and quattro saps a lot of that power.

MElliottUK

846 posts

243 months

Friday 16th July 2010
quotequote all
for your budget you wont get a CR one:

You want a MK5 2.0 TDI (140ps), the 170ps will be too pricey.

Will be on par with your passat i should think in terms of torque and performance

Lordbenny

Original Poster:

8,754 posts

250 months

Thursday 22nd July 2010
quotequote all
Whats the difference between a TDi GT and a Tdi S ?

Andy Gardiner

20 posts

207 months

Thursday 22nd July 2010
quotequote all
You only had to call me!!!!!!!
GT TDi comes with a sports interior, ie seats and steering wheel. A decent set of alloys, not the plastic trims seen on the S model, and the GT has 130bhp.S model has 105) I'm sure there is more technical stuff, but come and look in mine, it's identical to the Mk 4 GT TDi

Lordbenny

Original Poster:

8,754 posts

250 months

Thursday 22nd July 2010
quotequote all
Andy Gardiner said:
You only had to call me!!!!!!!
GT TDi comes with a sports interior, ie seats and steering wheel. A decent set of alloys, not the plastic trims seen on the S model, and the GT has 130bhp.S model has 105) I'm sure there is more technical stuff, but come and look in mine, it's identical to the Mk 4 GT TDi
Oooh get you, posting on PH, you'll be starting a topic of your own soon. Thanks for that! wink

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Saturday 24th July 2010
quotequote all
MK5 has the following diesel engines:
2.0 SDI 75
1.9 TDI PD 105 (this was also the engine used for the bluemotion)
2.0 TDI PD 140/ 170

Some general spec info:

Don't bother with the SDI, its painfully slow and underpowered, very poor engine choice for the overweight MK5. The 1.4 75/ 80 are both similaraly underpowered, but slightly quicker due to reduced weight. 1.4 FSI is 90PS and fairly lively, although not exactly fast. Quite rare. 1.6 FSI is a decent engine with 115PS and a 6-speed gearbox. Its a better bet than the more expensive 1.9 TDI 105 unless your doing lots of motorway miles, in which case the diesel makes more sense. In your case I guess your going to be best of with the oil burner, but do bear in mind its quite an old out of date noisy engine with a narrow power band, compared to the modern CR TDI units in the latest Golf.

With the specs I'll copy and paste what I posted in another thread...

These are the main differences between an S and SE:

◦Semi Automatic 'Climatic' Air Conditioning (note - S got this from 2006)
◦15" Misano Alloys
◦Body Colored Door Mirrors (note - S had this included pre 2007)
◦'Comfort' Seats with passenger height adjust and lumbar support
◦RCD300 with 8-Speakers Front and Rear
◦Conveinence Pack including Automatic Dimming Mirror, Automatic Lights, Automatic Wipers (for a few months the SE lost this)
◦'Midline' Trip Computer (not until 2006)
◦Cruise Control
◦Alarm
◦Rear Electric Windows (a few won't have this, unsure of date)
The SE models are well worth going for above the S models, which are really very basic. The upgraded seats on an SE especially make a big difference.

SE was replaced with Match in late 2006, with the following additions over the above spec list:

◦Silver Dash Trim
◦15" Canberra Alloys
◦Colour Coded body
◦Armrest with rear air-vents and iPod dock
◦Leather-covered Steering Wheel, Gear-stick and hand-brake
◦MFSW with Highline Computer
And you could also buy a Sport model between 2005-2007 with the same engines as SE/ Match, this is the spec difference:

◦Cruise Control Removed
◦Convienence Pack Removed
◦Comfort Seats Removed
◦Rear Electric Windows Removed
◦Leather-covered Steering Wheel, Gear-stick and hand-brake
◦16" 'Imola' or 'Hockenheim' or 'Mugello' Alloys
◦Sports Seats
◦Sports Suspension
◦6-Speed Gearbox
This table shows what was offered each model year:

Finally S & Sport where offerered in both 3dr and 5dr, SE was both until 2006, Match was only ever 5dr.

To the best of my knowledge the above is all correct, but there may be the odd car that dosen't quite fit in for all sorts of reasons. For info on the GT models see http://uk-mkivs.net/forums/t/255622.aspx and for model year changes see http://uk-mkivs.net/forums/t/255767.aspx


Edited by va1o on Saturday 24th July 02:00


Edited by va1o on Saturday 24th July 02:01